The Great Places Erased by Suburbia (the Third Place)

Not Just Bikes
21 Nov 202211:26
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe script discusses the importance of 'third places' - informal public spaces outside of home and work where community members can socialize and build relationships. It explores how third places like cafes, pubs, and parks nurture social ties, provide respite, spark chance encounters and promote trust. However, zoning laws and car-centric development in North America have increasingly erased these spaces, leaving suburbs lacking the community fabric third places naturally foster in denser, mixed-use neighborhoods.

Takeaways
  • 😊 Third Places are enjoyable public spaces where people can socialize and meet up outside of home or work.
  • 😞 Third Places are disappearing in North America due to suburbanization and strict zoning laws.
  • 🍻 Classic examples of Third Places include cafes, pubs, community centers, churches, etc.
  • 👪 Third Places help build social cohesion by bringing together diverse groups of people.
  • 👷 They also create weak social ties that can lead to job opportunities.
  • 🤝 Neighbors who have Third Places nearby tend to trust each other more.
  • 🔨 Third Places serve as resilience hubs after disasters by providing aid and assistance.
  • 🚗 Attempts to recreate Third Places in suburbs through backyard gatherings lack spontaneity.
  • 🛒 Shopping malls don't function well as Third Places since people don't know each other.
  • 🏘 Zoning reform is needed for Third Places to exist again in North American neighborhoods.
Q & A

  • What are some examples of third places mentioned in the transcript?

    -Some examples of third places mentioned are French cafes, Japanese bath houses, libraries, churches, community centers, local pubs, and barber shops.

  • How do third places contribute to social cohesion?

    -Third places bring together people from different backgrounds who wouldn't ordinarily interact. This can improve the local economy as people exchange services and make professional connections.

  • What is the benefit of 'weak ties' formed at third places?

    -Research shows that many people find jobs and other opportunities through acquaintances they've met at third places rather than close friends.

  • How can third places improve neighborhood trust?

    -People who regularly visit third places are more likely to trust their neighbors. These spaces facilitate positive interactions.

  • Why are third places scarce in suburban areas?

    -Zoning laws in the US and Canada make it very difficult to build small businesses like cafes and pubs outside of urban centers. Car-dependency also reduces opportunities for spontaneous social interactions.

  • How did the pandemic impact third places?

    -Lockdowns and economic impacts caused many third places to close down. Surveys show that fewer Americans had a regular community spot to visit in 2021 compared to pre-pandemic.

  • Why don't malls effectively replace third places?

    -Malls lack local, spontaneous interactions. People are unlikely to bump into their neighbors or form community bonds in the mostly-planned environment.

  • What prevents recreating third places in private?

    -Attempts like backyard gatherings reduce opportunities for chance meetings and interacting with diverse people beyond one's own social circles.

  • How can cities better plan for third places?

    -Updating zoning laws to allow small businesses in residential areas helps. Improving walkability and access also enables community spots to thrive.

  • Why prioritize third places in neighborhoods?

    -Well-integrated third places lead to greater social cohesion, local economic activity, chance encounters and overall livability even for non-frequent visitors.

Outlines
00:00
😀 What is a 'Third Place' and why are they important?

A 'Third Place' is an enjoyable public space like a pub, cafe, or town square where people can casually socialize and form community connections. They promote social cohesion by facilitating relationships between diverse groups. Suburban sprawl and strict zoning laws have largely erased Third Places in North America, harming neighborhood trust and support systems.

05:02
😡 Zoning laws and the suburban built environment make Third Places impossible

Zoning laws prohibit mixed-use development and enforce single-family housing, making it impossible to build Third Places. Suburbanites try to recreate Third Places privately, but backyard gatherings and malls don't facilitate diverse interactions nor spontaneity. Some cities are establishing public spaces for socializing, but accessibility barriers persist.

10:05
🏘️ We must fix zoning to bring back Third Places

Trying to recreate Third Places in exclusionary suburban environments always fails. People dismiss Third Places if they've never had access, but accessible social infrastructure improves quality of life. Ultimately neighborhoods need to enable diverse social spaces through zoning reform to prioritize Third Places.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Third Place
The Third Place refers to free or inexpensive public spaces outside of home and work where people can gather, socialize, and connect with their local community. Examples are cafes, pubs, parks, and community centers. The video argues that Third Places are essential for neighborhood cohesion, local economic development, and resilience during crises, but they have disappeared in many car-dependent North American suburbs due to restrictive zoning laws.
💡walkable city
A walkable city has dense mixed-use development and good public transit, allowing residents to access amenities and services without needing to drive everywhere. The video says choosing to live in a walkable neighborhood with a Third Place nearby is a major benefit of urban living.
💡zoning laws
Zoning laws regulate land use in many North American cities, often mandating single-family housing and separating residential areas from businesses/amenities. The video argues that zoning makes it nearly impossible to build Third Places in many suburbs.
💡social cohesion
Social cohesion refers to the bonds built through positive social relationships within a community. The video states that Third Places help create social cohesion by facilitating interaction between diverse groups who otherwise wouldn't mix.
💡loitering laws
Loitering laws ban lingering or hanging out in public spaces for no clear purpose. The video notes that these laws undermine Third Places by criminalizing the casual socializing that defines them.
💡suburban recreation
With few genuine public Third Places, some suburbanites attempt to recreate them through backyard gatherings, private clubs, etc. But the video argues these private substitutes lack the diversity and spontaneity of real Third Places.
💡shopping malls
Shopping malls are sometimes seen as suburban replacements for the town square or Main Street. However, the video says malls don't facilitate local social ties and community in the way a neighborhood pub or cafe does.
💡pandemic impact
The COVID-19 pandemic and lockdown measures caused many Third Places to close down. This accelerated the broader decline of these spaces in the US, negatively impacting social connectedness.
💡neighborhood priority
The video argues that neighborhoods designed with Third Places as a priority tend to be more livable, walkable, and community-oriented. Their presence facilitates positive interactions between residents.
💡suburban dismissal
Some suburbanites dismiss the value of Third Places, but the video speculates this may be because they've never had easy access to vibrant public social spaces within walking distance.
Highlights

Third Places are places like cafes, pubs, and parks where people can casually socialize outside of home and work.

Third Places facilitate connections between diverse groups of people and build social cohesion in neighborhoods.

Third Places create "weak ties" between acquaintances that can lead to job opportunities and other economic benefits.

People with access to Third Places are more likely to trust their neighbors compared to those without.

Third Places serve as community hubs during emergencies by providing assistance faster than national aid.

Strict zoning laws in North America make it difficult to build Third Places, contributing to their disappearance.

Private suburban attempts to recreate Third Places lack diversity and spontaneity compared to authentic ones.

Shopping malls fail as Third Places because they don't facilitate local social connections.

The decline of Third Places during the pandemic amplified social isolation and loneliness.

Walkable neighborhoods with Third Places nearby have higher social connectivity and overall livability.

Third Places create spaces outside of home and work that are vital for wellbeing and human connection.

Barber shops persist as social Third Places in certain neighborhoods in America.

Cities struggle to artificially recreate Third Places; they need to emerge organically from planning.

Lack of Third Places contributes to drunk driving in car-dependent North American suburbs.

The disappearance of Third Places erodes communities and exacerbates isolation.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Designing Urban Places that Don't Suck (a sense of place)

How to turn your Neighborhood into a Village

Should We Ban Cars From Cities?

Suburbs that don't Suck - Streetcar Suburbs (Riverdale, Toronto)

Even Small Towns are Great Here (5 Years in the Netherlands)

Solving A Classic Google Interview Logic Puzzle

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: