Coffin Problems (with Edward Frenkel) - Numberphile Podcast

The Numberphile Podcast
3 Dec 201981:40
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this podcast, renowned mathematician Edward Frenkel shares his inspiring journey from Soviet Russia to the esteemed halls of Berkeley. He discusses his early fascination with physics, his pivotal encounter with a mathematician that transformed his career, and the challenges he faced due to anti-Semitism in the Soviet Union. Frenkel also delves into his research on the Langlands Program and his passion for making mathematics accessible and beautiful to a broader audience.

Takeaways
  • ๐ŸŒ Edward Frenkel, a renowned mathematician, shared his journey from Russia to Berkeley, which is also documented in his book.
  • ๐Ÿ“š Growing up in the Soviet Union, Frenkel was inspired by the high regard for science and the availability of popular science books, which fueled his early interest in physics and quantum mechanics.
  • ๐Ÿš€ The Soviet government's emphasis on science was partly due to the need for scientists in nuclear research and space exploration, as well as the relative freedom scientists had compared to other fields.
  • ๐Ÿ”ข Despite initially disliking math in school, Frenkel's perspective changed dramatically after meeting a mentor, Evgeny, who introduced him to the beauty and depth of advanced mathematics.
  • ๐Ÿ”„ Frenkel discovered his passion for pure mathematics, which was a stark contrast to the mundane math curriculum he experienced in school.
  • ๐Ÿ›๏ธ Frenkel faced significant challenges in pursuing higher education in mathematics due to anti-Semitic discrimination in the Soviet Union's university admissions process.
  • ๐ŸŽ“ Despite being denied admission to Moscow State University, Frenkel was accepted at the Oil and Gas Institute, where he continued to excel and conduct research under the guidance of another mentor, Dmitry Fuchs.
  • ๐ŸŒŸ At the age of 18, Frenkel had already written significant papers that led to an invitation from Harvard University as a visiting professor.
  • ๐Ÿ“˜ Frenkel's book not only tells his personal story but also aims to convey the beauty of mathematics, which he believes is often hidden from view.
  • ๐ŸŽฌ Frenkel ventured into filmmaking with 'Rights of Love and Math,' a project that reflects his personal journey and passion for mathematics, despite its controversial reception.
  • ๐Ÿ”ฎ Looking forward, Frenkel hopes to continue making significant contributions to the Langlands Program in mathematics and remains driven by curiosity and the love for his subject.
Q & A
  • Where was Edward Frenkel born?

    -Edward Frenkel was born in the Soviet Union, in a small town called Kolomna, which is about 117 kilometers (approximately 70 miles) from Moscow.

  • What was the cultural significance of science in the Soviet Union during Edward's childhood?

    -During Edward's childhood in the Soviet Union, science was highly respected. Books about science were widely available, and the government recognized the need for good scientists, especially in areas like nuclear research and space exploration.

  • Why was mathematics particularly revered in the Soviet Union?

    -Mathematics was revered in the Soviet Union because it was seen as a field that could be pursued with relative freedom. Unlike social sciences or humanities, which were heavily censored and controlled by the state, mathematics and theoretical science offered a space where ideas could be freely explored without political interference.

  • What was Edward's initial attitude towards mathematics?

    -Initially, Edward did not like mathematics. He found what was taught in school to be trivial, pointless, and boring, despite finding it easy. His interest was more in physics and the mysteries of the universe.

  • How did Edward's perspective on mathematics change?

    -Edward's perspective on mathematics changed when he met a mathematician named Evgeny, who introduced him to more advanced and abstract concepts in mathematics. This exposure revealed the beauty and depth of mathematics, which he had not seen in his school curriculum.

  • What was the significance of the encounter with Evgeny for Edward's academic journey?

    -The encounter with Evgeny was pivotal for Edward. Evgeny became his mentor, teaching him advanced mathematics and sparking his interest in the subject. This relationship led Edward to pursue mathematics more seriously and ultimately become a mathematician.

  • What challenges did Edward face when applying to Moscow State University?

    -Edward faced significant challenges when applying to Moscow State University due to a system of discrimination against students with Jewish backgrounds. Despite performing well on the entrance exams, he was subjected to unfair treatment and was ultimately denied admission.

  • How did Edward overcome the obstacles in his path to becoming a mathematician?

    -Edward overcame the obstacles by not giving up. After being denied admission to Moscow State University, he was accepted into the applied mathematics program at the Oil and Gas Institute. He continued to study independently and with the help of mentors, eventually writing his first paper at the age of 18, which led to his invitation to Harvard as a visiting professor.

  • What role did the Langlands Program play in Edward's research?

    -The Langlands Program, a broad area of mathematical research initiated by mathematician Robert Langlands, became a significant focus of Edward's research. It connects problems in number theory and harmonic analysis, and Edward's work has contributed to this field.

  • What was the inspiration behind Edward's film 'Rights of Love and Math'?

    -The film 'Rights of Love and Math' was inspired by a desire to present mathematics in an unconventional and visceral way. The idea of tattooing a mathematical formula on the body symbolizes the deep connection between mathematics and human passion, highlighting that mathematics is not just an abstract discipline but a product of love and creativity.

Outlines
00:00
๐ŸŒŸ Edward Frenkel's Journey from Russia to Mathematics

The first paragraph introduces the guest, mathematician Edward Frenkel, highlighting his intriguing journey from sneaking into math lectures in Moscow to becoming a renowned mathematician at Berkeley. Born in the Soviet Union, Frenkel discusses the high regard for science during his upbringing, particularly in the fields of physics and quantum mechanics. He shares his initial disinterest in mathematics, considering it trivial and boring compared to the excitement of physics. However, the culture of the Soviet Union at the time, which revered scientists and provided ample opportunities in science and technology, played a significant role in shaping his early interests.

05:00
๐Ÿ“š From Disinterest to Discovery: Frenkel's Mathematical Awakening

In this paragraph, Frenkel reveals how his initial dislike for mathematics transformed into a deep passion. He explains that his turning point came when he met a mathematician who introduced him to the more profound and exciting aspects of the subject. This encounter opened his eyes to the real mathematics that existed beyond the basic Euclidean geometry and algebra taught in school. Frenkel's newfound interest in mathematics was further fueled by the realization that understanding theoretical physics, especially quantum physics, required a strong foundation in mathematics. His mentor's influence led him to explore advanced mathematical concepts, such as representation theory and periodic numbers, which he found captivating and counter-intuitive.

10:02
๐Ÿ” The Impact of Teachers and Mentors on Frenkel's Path

Frenkel discusses the pivotal role his teachers and mentors played in his life, particularly his high school mentor, Evgeny, who recognized his potential and guided him through the complexities of advanced mathematics. Despite initially disliking math, Frenkel's weekly meetings with Evgeny ignited a passion for the subject. Evgeny's approach to teaching, which involved discussing books on linear algebra, number theory, and topology, laid a strong foundation for Frenkel's mathematical education. This mentorship not only changed Frenkel's academic trajectory but also provided an escape from the political and social challenges of living in the Soviet Union during its decline.

15:03
๐Ÿซ The Struggle for Academic Excellence Amidst Discrimination

This paragraph delves into the challenges Frenkel faced in his pursuit of higher education, particularly the discrimination he encountered due to his Jewish heritage. Despite excelling in his studies and demonstrating exceptional mathematical abilities, Frenkel was denied admission to Moscow State University due to anti-Semitic policies. The narrative highlights the systemic bias against Jewish students in the Soviet Union's educational system, where even the brightest minds were denied opportunities based on their ethnicity. Frenkel's story underscores the resilience and determination required to overcome such barriers and the importance of perseverance in the face of adversity.

20:05
๐ŸŒ Overcoming Obstacles: Frenkel's Entry into Moscow's Academic World

Frenkel shares his experience of navigating the academic landscape of Moscow, which was fraught with challenges due to discrimination. Despite being denied admission to Moscow State University, he managed to secure a place at the Oil and Gas University, which had a small applied mathematics program. Here, he continued to excel and further his mathematical education. Frenkel's story illustrates the importance of finding alternative paths to success and the role of supportive individuals in overcoming institutional barriers. His determination to prove his worth and contribute to the field of mathematics remained unwavering, even in the face of systemic obstacles.

25:05
๐Ÿ“ˆ The Ascent to Harvard: Frenkel's Mathematical Breakthroughs

In this paragraph, Frenkel recounts his rapid ascent in the world of mathematics, which led to an invitation to Harvard as a visiting professor. His collaboration with renowned mathematician Dmitry Fuchs and the publication of groundbreaking papers in the field of Langlands program caught the attention of the academic community. Frenkel's journey from a provincial town in the Soviet Union to the halls of Harvard is a testament to his intellectual prowess and the impact of supportive mentors. His story highlights the transformative power of education and the importance of seizing opportunities, even in the face of adversity.

30:06
๐ŸŽฌ Frenkel's Foray into Film: 'Rights of Love and Math'

Frenkel discusses his artistic endeavor, a film titled 'Rights of Love and Math,' which he co-directed with French filmmaker Ren Graf. The film is a homage to Yuki Himishima's 'Rights of Love and Death,' incorporating elements of Japanese no theater and a narrative centered around a mathematician's discovery of a formula for love. The film explores themes of passion, obsession, and the potential misuse of mathematical knowledge. Frenkel's involvement in the project reflects his desire to break out of traditional academic constraints and express his creativity in unconventional ways.

35:07
๐Ÿ“š The Intersection of Mathematics and Personal Growth

Frenkel reflects on the personal growth he experienced through his mathematical journey, particularly in his book that intertwines his biographical story with the beauty of mathematics. He discusses the process of writing the book as a means of connecting with his younger self and understanding the pain and challenges he faced. The narrative delves into the universality of personal struggles and the power of mathematics as a unifying language. Frenkel's story emphasizes the importance of embracing one's passions and the transformative potential of facing and overcoming adversity.

40:10
๐Ÿค” The Future of Mathematics and Frenkel's Ongoing Pursuits

In the final paragraph, Frenkel contemplates his ongoing work in mathematics, particularly his involvement in a new strand of the Langlands program. He expresses hope that his best work is still ahead of him and reflects on the importance of following one's passion, regardless of the field. Frenkel's current projects, collaborations, and his approach to mathematics highlight his enduring commitment to the subject and his desire to contribute meaningfully to the field. His story serves as an inspiration for aspiring mathematicians and those who face challenges in their pursuit of knowledge.

Mindmap
Keywords
๐Ÿ’กMathematics
Mathematics is the abstract science of number, quantity, and space, either as abstract concepts, or by embodying them in physical entities such as lines and points. In the video, the guest, Edward Frenkel, expresses his deep-seated passion for mathematics, particularly theoretical aspects that are not directly applied to real-world problems. His journey from a young boy in Russia to a respected mathematician in the United States is intertwined with his love for the subject, which he views as a beautiful and fundamental structure of the universe.
๐Ÿ’กSoviet Union
The Soviet Union, or the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR), was a socialist state that existed from 1922 to 1991, covering a large part of Eurasia. In the script, the guest discusses the cultural and educational environment of the Soviet Union during his upbringing, highlighting the high regard for science and the challenges faced by those interested in fields such as mathematics and physics, especially in terms of political and ideological constraints.
๐Ÿ’กQuantum Physics
Quantum physics is a fundamental theory in physics that describes nature at the smallest scales of energy levels of atoms and subatomic particles. Edward Frenkel was initially fascinated by quantum physics, particularly the concepts of elementary particles and forces of nature, which led him to explore deeper into the theoretical foundations of the universe. His interest in quantum physics was a precursor to his eventual focus on mathematics.
๐Ÿ’กRepresentation Theory
Representation theory is a branch of mathematics that studies abstract algebraic structures by representing their elements as linear transformations of vector spaces. In the video, Frenkel mentions the representation theory of SU(3), a specific type of group representation, which is crucial for understanding the structure of particles like quarks in quantum physics. This theory was pivotal in his transition from an interest in physics to a deep appreciation for the complexities of mathematics.
๐Ÿ’กDiscrimination
Discrimination refers to unfair treatment of a person or group based on their membership in a certain category, such as ethnicity, religion, or nationality. The script describes how Frenkel faced anti-Semitic discrimination during his university admission process in Moscow, which highlights the social and political challenges that can impede academic and personal growth.
๐Ÿ’กLanglands Program
The Langlands Program is a grand unified vision in mathematics that connects number theory, algebraic geometry, and harmonic analysis. Named after Canadian mathematician Robert Langlands, it has become a significant area of research. Frenkel's research is deeply connected to this program, and his work has contributed to the understanding of its implications in various mathematical fields.
๐Ÿ’กHarvard University
Harvard University is a prestigious Ivy League institution located in Cambridge, Massachusetts, known for its rigorous academic programs and research. In the script, Frenkel recounts his invitation to Harvard as a visiting professor, which was a significant milestone in his career, reflecting his growing reputation in the field of mathematics.
๐Ÿ’กNumberphile
Numberphile is a YouTube channel that produces videos about various topics in mathematics, often featuring interviews with mathematicians. The podcast in the script is associated with Numberphile, and it serves as a platform for Frenkel to share his experiences and insights into the world of mathematics, making the subject accessible to a broader audience.
๐Ÿ’กPeriodic Numbers
Periodic numbers, also known as p-adic numbers, are a type of number system that extends the real numbers with a different notion of distance and convergence. Frenkel discusses his fascination with periodic numbers, which challenged his intuitions and sparked his curiosity about the hidden depths of mathematical concepts.
๐Ÿ’กFilm
In the script, Frenkel mentions his involvement in a film project titled 'Rights of Love and Math,' which was an artistic endeavor to represent mathematics in a unique and unconventional way. The film used symbolism, such as a mathematical formula tattooed on a body, to convey the deep and personal connection between mathematics and human experience.
๐Ÿ’กBook
Frenkel authored a book that intertwines his personal story of overcoming obstacles with his passion for mathematics. The book serves as both an autobiography and an exposition on the beauty of mathematics, aiming to demystify the subject and reveal its elegance to a wider readership. It also reflects his journey from Russia to the United States and his experiences with discrimination and academic success.
Highlights

Edward Frenkel's journey from sneaking into math lectures in Moscow to becoming a respected mathematician at Berkeley.

Frenkel's early fascination with quantum physics and the influence of Soviet-era science culture on his interest in theoretical science.

The unique educational environment in the Soviet Union where science was highly respected and promoted, contrasting with the censorship in other fields.

Frenkel's initial disdain for school mathematics and his later revelation of the beauty and depth of higher mathematics through his mentor, Evgeny.

The pivotal encounter with his mentor Evgeny, who introduced Frenkel to the advanced and exciting world of 'real' mathematics.

Frenkel's experience of the Soviet Union's discrimination against Jewish individuals in academia and his personal challenges.

How the adversity faced during university admissions in the Soviet Union fueled Frenkel's determination to prove his capabilities.

Frenkel's transition from physics to pure mathematics and the profound impact of his mentor's guidance.

The concept of p-adic numbers as a significant mathematical revelation for Frenkel, illustrating the counter-intuitive nature of higher mathematics.

Frenkel's experience of self-education and overcoming the limitations of his academic environment to pursue his passion for mathematics.

His collaboration with Dmitry Fuchs, a renowned mathematician, which marked a turning point in Frenkel's career and led to his first paper at 18.

Frenkel's invitation to Harvard as a visiting professor at the age of 21, highlighting his rapid ascent in the academic world.

The role of Langlands Program in shaping Frenkel's research and his contribution to the interface of mathematics and quantum physics.

Frenkel's reflections on the importance of perseverance, curiosity, and the love for the subject as key motivators in his mathematical journey.

The personal and artistic side of Edward Frenkel, including his book and film, which explore the beauty of mathematics and his own identity.

Frenkel's current work on a new strand of the Langlands Program, demonstrating his ongoing passion and dedication to mathematical research.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: