Is MSG Bad for You?

Reactions
25 Aug 201403:01
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script debunks the myth surrounding monosodium glutamate (MSG), a flavor enhancer that has been unfairly labeled as toxic and harmful. Despite its common presence in various foods and even in our bodies, misconceptions about MSG originated from a 1968 letter to the New England Journal of Medicine that described adverse effects after consuming Chinese food, which was later attributed to MSG. However, scientific consensus indicates that MSG is safe for most people, with only a temporary effect on a select few when consumed in large amounts on an empty stomach. The video emphasizes that glutamate, the key component of MSG, is a natural amino acid found in many protein-rich foods and is produced by our bodies. It also highlights the irony of avoiding MSG while consuming soy sauce, which is rich in glutamate. The World Health Organization and the FDA have declared glutamate safe for consumption in moderation. The video encourages viewers to question claims without evidence and to seek the truth through research.

Takeaways
  • 🍽️ MSG (monosodium glutamate) is a flavor enhancer that boosts the umami taste on our tongues.
  • 🧬 Umami is a savory flavor, named after the Japanese word for delicious, and is naturally present in many foods.
  • 🧪 MSG was discovered in 1908 by Kikunae Ikeda, who found the flavor enhancement in seaweed, which contains L-glutamate.
  • 🥩 L-glutamate is an amino acid found in a variety of protein-rich foods, including meats, dairy, and vegetables.
  • 💪 Our bodies also produce glutamate naturally through the krebs cycle when metabolizing food.
  • 🧂 MSG is a sodium salt form of glutamic acid, making it easy to sprinkle on dishes.
  • ❓ The negative perception of MSG began with a 1968 letter to The New England Journal of Medicine describing symptoms after eating Chinese food.
  • 🔍 Scientific consensus indicates that MSG is safe for most people, with only a temporary effect on a select few when consumed in large amounts on an empty stomach.
  • 🏷 Despite its safety, MSG's bad reputation persists, with some restaurants advertising 'no MSG' despite the presence of glutamate in other ingredients like soy sauce.
  • 🌐 L-glutamate is one of 20 amino acids in natural proteins and is recognized as safe to eat by the World Health Organization and FDA.
  • 🕵️‍♂️ It's important to question and investigate claims about food safety, rather than accepting them without evidence.
Q & A

  • What is MSG and what does it stand for?

    -MSG stands for monosodium glutamate. It is a flavor enhancer that is responsible for enhancing the umami flavors on our tongue.

  • What is the savory flavor associated with MSG known as?

    -The savory flavor associated with MSG is known as 'umami,' which is derived from the Japanese word 'Umai,' meaning delicious.

  • Who discovered the effects of MSG and what year did this discovery take place?

    -The effects of MSG were first discovered in 1908 by the chemist Kikunae Ikeda.

  • What is L-glutamate and where is it found?

    -L-glutamate is an amino acid that contributes to the flavor enhancement in food. It is found in many common protein-rich foods such as meats, dairy products, and vegetables.

  • How does our body produce glutamate?

    -Our bodies produce glutamate through the Krebs cycle when metabolizing food.

  • What is the term used to describe the unpleasant after effects felt after eating Chinese food, as mentioned in the 1968 letter to The New England Journal of Medicine?

    -The term used is 'Chinese restaurant syndrome,' which describes symptoms like numbness in the back of the neck and general weakness.

  • What has the scientific consensus determined about the safety of MSG for most people?

    -The scientific consensus is that MSG can temporarily affect a select few when consumed in large quantities on an empty stomach, but it is safe for the vast majority of people.

  • Why do some food labels at Chinese restaurants say 'no MSG added'?

    -The labels say 'no MSG added' to cater to the misconception that MSG is harmful, even though many other ingredients like soy sauce contain high levels of glutamate.

  • What is the status of L-glutamate according to the World Health Organization and the FDA?

    -L-glutamate, being one of the 20 amino acids that make up natural proteins, has been declared completely safe to ingest by both the World Health Organization and the FDA.

  • What is the fundamental lesson that the script suggests we should take away from the MSG myth?

    -The fundamental lesson is to not accept something as truth without proper evidence. If something is claimed to be harmful without a definitive reason, it's important to investigate and find out for oneself.

  • What is the role of umami in the context of MSG?

    -Umami is the savory flavor that MSG enhances. It is one of the basic tastes that people can experience, and MSG helps to make food taste more delicious by intensifying this umami flavor.

  • Why is it a myth that MSG is toxic or harmful to health when it is so common in our diet?

    -The myth likely stems from a lack of understanding and misinformation. Since glutamate is a natural component of many foods and is even produced by our bodies, the idea that it is toxic is not supported by scientific evidence. The negative reputation persists due to historical anecdotes and a lack of public education on the subject.

Outlines
00:00
🍽️ MSG Myths and Truths

The video script addresses the widespread misconceptions about MSG (monosodium glutamate), a flavor enhancer that is often unfairly associated with negative health effects. MSG is derived from the amino acid L-glutamate, which is naturally found in a variety of common foods and even produced by our bodies. The script explains that the negative reputation of MSG stems from a 1968 letter to The New England Journal of Medicine, which described symptoms dubbed 'Chinese restaurant syndrome' after consuming Chinese food. However, the scientific consensus indicates that MSG is safe for most people unless consumed in extremely large quantities on an empty stomach. The video emphasizes the importance of questioning food myths and seeking scientific evidence before accepting something as truth.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡MSG
MSG, or monosodium glutamate, is a flavor enhancer that is widely used to intensify the umami taste in food. It is a sodium salt form of glutamic acid, which is naturally found in many foods and is also produced by the human body. The video discusses the misconceptions around MSG being harmful, which originated from a letter to The New England Journal of Medicine in 1968. The term 'MSG' is central to the video's theme of debunking food myths and emphasizes the importance of scientific evidence over anecdotal claims.
💡Umami
Umami is a savory flavor that is often described as 'delicious' in Japanese. It is one of the basic tastes and is associated with the presence of glutamate, an amino acid. In the video, umami is linked to the natural occurrence of glutamate in food and is used to explain why MSG, which enhances this taste, is not inherently harmful. The concept of umami is integral to understanding the role of MSG as a flavor enhancer.
💡Glutamate
Glutamate is an amino acid that is naturally present in many protein-rich foods such as meats, dairy products, and vegetables. It is also produced by the human body during the process of metabolizing food. The video uses glutamate to explain that the components of MSG are not foreign or toxic, as they are a common part of our diet and even produced by our own bodies. This keyword is key to dispelling the myth that MSG is harmful.
💡Chinese Restaurant Syndrome
Chinese Restaurant Syndrome is a term coined after a letter to The New England Journal of Medicine in 1968 described a set of symptoms experienced after eating Chinese food, which the author attributed to MSG. The video uses this term to highlight the origin of the negative perception of MSG and to point out that subsequent scientific research has not supported these initial claims. This keyword is significant as it represents the myth that the video aims to debunk.
💡Toxicity
The term 'toxicity' refers to the degree to which a substance can cause harm. In the context of the video, it is used to describe the false perception of MSG as a toxic and harmful additive. The video counters this by presenting scientific consensus that MSG is safe for the majority of people, except in extremely large quantities on an empty stomach. Understanding the concept of toxicity is crucial for evaluating the safety of MSG.
💡Food Myths
Food myths are misconceptions or false beliefs about food and its effects on health. The video focuses on MSG as one of the biggest lingering food myths, emphasizing the need for consumers to question such myths and seek scientific evidence. The concept of food myths is central to the video's message, which encourages critical thinking and research over accepting unverified claims.
💡Scientific Consensus
The scientific consensus refers to the general agreement among scientists regarding a particular issue. In the video, it is mentioned that the scientific consensus deems MSG safe for most people, which contrasts with the public's perception of MSG as harmful. This keyword is important as it underscores the video's reliance on scientific evidence to counteract myths.
💡World Health Organization (WHO)
The World Health Organization is a specialized agency of the United Nations responsible for international public health. The video cites the WHO, along with the FDA, as having declared glutamate safe for consumption. The mention of the WHO adds credibility and authority to the video's argument that MSG is not harmful.
💡FDA
The FDA, or the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, is a government agency responsible for protecting public health through the regulation of food and drugs. The video references the FDA's approval of MSG as safe, reinforcing the point that MSG's negative reputation is not supported by regulatory bodies. The FDA's stance is significant in the context of the video as it represents official recognition of MSG's safety.
💡Moderation
Moderation, in the context of the video, refers to the idea that substances, including additives like MSG, can be safely consumed as long as they are not eaten in excessive amounts. The video emphasizes that even common ingredients can be harmful if overconsumed, and that MSG is no exception. The concept of moderation is key to understanding the video's message about the safe consumption of MSG.
💡Soy Sauce
Soy sauce is a condiment that is often used in Asian cuisine and is mentioned in the video as a source of natural glutamate. The video points out the irony that while some restaurants advertise 'no MSG added,' the use of soy sauce as a flavoring still introduces glutamate into the food. This keyword is used to illustrate the ubiquity of glutamate in the diet and to challenge the notion that MSG is uniquely harmful.
💡Critical Thinking
Critical thinking is the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment. The video encourages viewers to apply critical thinking to food claims, rather than accepting myths without question. The concept is central to the video's theme of questioning and investigating food myths, such as the one surrounding MSG.
Highlights

MSG, or monosodium glutamate, is a flavor enhancer responsible for enhancing the umami flavors on our tongue.

Umami is a savory flavor, named after the Japanese word 'Umai' meaning delicious.

MSG was discovered in 1908 by chemist Kikunae Ikeda who was studying seaweed used to improve food flavor.

The flavor enhancement from seaweed was found to come from an amino acid called L-glutamate.

Glutamate is found in many common protein-rich foods like meats, dairy products and vegetables.

Our bodies also produce glutamate naturally through the krebes cycle when metabolizing food.

MSG is a sodium salt form of glutamic acid, making it easy to sprinkle on dishes.

Despite being a common compound our bodies produce, MSG has an undeserved bad reputation.

The negative perception of MSG started with a 1968 letter to the New England Journal of Medicine describing symptoms dubbed 'Chinese restaurant syndrome'.

The scientific consensus is that MSG is safe for most people, only temporarily affecting a select few when consumed in large quantities on an empty stomach.

The bad reputation of MSG persists today, despite scientific evidence to the contrary.

Ironically, many 'MSG-free' foods at Chinese restaurants are loaded with glutamate from soy sauce.

Glutamate is one of 20 amino acids that make up natural proteins, and is deemed safe to ingest by the World Health Organization and FDA.

The MSG myth teaches us to question claims that something is bad for you without definitive evidence.

It's important to do your own research and not accept something as truth without proper evidence - that's what science is all about.

An infographic about MSG is available in the video description from Compound Interest.

Spread the word and subscribe to stay informed about food myths and scientific facts.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Why You Shouldn't Trust All Health Food Trends | SciShow Compilation

Is Aspartame Safe?

How to make your food 30x more delicious

The Science of How the Body Heals Itself with William Li, M.D.

I FINALLY understand the Maillard reaction

The Way We Think About Sugar Is Going To Change

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
MSG MythsFood SafetyUmami FlavorL-GlutamateHealth ConcernsChinese CuisineNutritional FactsScience of FoodDiet MisconceptionsWHO ApprovalFDA Standards