Henrietta Lacks, the Tuskegee Experiment, and Ethical Data Collection: Crash Course Statistics #12
TLDRThis video discusses ethical considerations in gathering and applying statistics, using five stories as examples. It covers issues like lack of informed consent and coercion of participants, highlighting harms done in early medical research. The video then relates these concepts to modern data mining, arguing we must decide how research ethics principles apply to companies profiting from our data, as terms of service often relinquish privacy rights. As technological capabilities advance, the conversation around protecting sensitive information is ongoing, and we the people will determine what policies govern our data.
Takeaways
- 🔍 Ethical considerations are crucial in statistical research, particularly regarding the voluntariness and informed consent of participants.
- 📜 The history of research ethics includes significant instances of unethical practices, such as the Tuskegee Syphilis Study and the use of Henrietta Lacks' cells.
- 🧑🔬 The case of Alexis St. Martin and Dr. Beaumont highlights the complex relationship between research progress and ethical considerations.
- 🤔 Voluntariness in research emphasizes the importance of subjects being able to refuse participation without coercion, especially in vulnerable populations.
- 📃 Informed consent is a critical aspect of ethical research, ensuring that subjects are fully aware of and understand the study's procedures and risks.
- 👥 The Nuremberg Code, established post-World War II, set foundational principles for modern research ethics, including voluntariness, informed consent, and beneficence.
- 🌐 The advent of the digital age introduces new ethical challenges in research, particularly in data privacy and informed consent in the context of internet use.
- 💻 Examples from popular culture, like 'Parks and Recreation,' illustrate the complexities of ethics in digital data collection and privacy concerns.
- 📚 Ethical research must balance scientific advancement with the rights and dignity of subjects, whether human or animal.
- 🚀 As technology advances, ongoing ethical discussions and legislation are needed to address new challenges in research practices and data privacy.
Q & A
What was the purpose of Dr. Beaumont's experiments on Alexis St. Martin?
-Dr. Beaumont used St. Martin's gastric fistula to study how the human body digests food. He made advances in understanding digestion and disproved some previously held beliefs about how the stomach works.
Why was informed consent important in the Tuskegee Syphilis Study?
-The men in the Tuskegee Study were not informed that they had syphilis or that they would not receive real medical treatment. This violated basic ethical principles of informed consent in research.
How did Henrietta Lacks' cells contribute to scientific research?
-Henrietta Lacks' HeLa cells were the first human cells successfully cloned. They have been instrumental in many areas of research including developing vaccines and studying cancer and AIDS.
What are two key tenets of the Nuremberg Code regarding research ethics?
-The Nuremberg Code emphasizes the principles of informed consent and beneficence. Researchers must adequately inform subjects of risks and expected benefits, and risks should be minimized while potential benefits are maximized.
How does Gryzzl collect data in the Parks and Recreation episode?
-Gryzzl offers free WiFi to the town of Pawnee, but in exchange they data mine information about what people do online. They use this to send personalized gifts showing they know citizens' interests.
What are some modern day examples of companies data mining like Gryzzl?
-Companies like Facebook, Google, Amazon, and Netflix collect data on users' online activities, purchases, searches etc. to customize experiences and target advertising.
What are some ethical issues around data mining?
-Issues include whether it violates privacy, if consent is really informed, if it discriminates against groups, and if companies properly secure sensitive information they collect.
How can principles like informed consent apply to internet privacy?
-Websites and apps could be required to present terms of service and privacy policies in simple language users can understand before they consent and sign up.
Who decides laws that protect internet privacy?
-Internet privacy laws are still developing. The public, technology companies, lawmakers etc. will shape future policies determining how digital data can be used.
Why might people feel pressure to use services that collect their data?
-Some argue that services like Google and social media feel mandatory to find jobs or be informed. This could coerce people to hand over privacy they'd prefer to keep.
Outlines
😯 A Fistula Leads to Medical Breakthroughs, But at What Cost?
Paragraph 1 tells the story of fur trapper Alexis St. Martin, who was accidentally shot in the stomach in 1822. This left him with a hole called a gastric fistula that gave doctor William Beaumont access to his stomach. Beaumont then conducted experiments on digestion using St. Martin without his consent. This led to advances in gastroenterology but violated ethics of voluntary participation and avoiding harm.
😠 Unethical Medical Studies Exploit Vulnerable People
Paragraph 2 discusses the importance of voluntary participation, informed consent, and avoiding coercion in medical research. It references unethical studies like the 40-year Tuskegee Syphilis study, where researchers observed disease progression in black men without their consent or providing treatment when it became available.
🤔 The Digital Age Raises New Ethical Questions About Data and Privacy
Paragraph 3 uses a fictional story about a tech company providing free WiFi in exchange for users' data to illustrate emerging ethical issues around data mining and privacy. It questions whether privacy agreements constitute informed consent and how principles like those aimed at protecting human research subjects should apply to digital spaces.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Ethics
💡Consent
💡Privacy
💡Autonomy
💡Coercion
💡Beneficence
💡Discrimination
💡Data Mining
💡Informed Consent
💡Risks
Highlights
The process of gathering and applying statistics can affect real people’s lives which means, there’s an responsibility to gather and use this data ethically.
Without this strange situation, the field of gastroenterology may have progressed more slowly.
One of the most important ethical considerations in research is whether humans who participate are able to feasibly say “no”.
Ethical research needs to be voluntary--at least in humans.
Subjects should also know what will happen to them during the study.
Subjects have the right to not only receive all the facts relevant to their decision to participate, they have the right to understand them.
One of the main tenets is beneficence, which not only requires that researchers minimize the potential for risk to subjects, but also requires that the risk should be outweighed by potential benefits.
When we use “free” internet services we’re agreeing to pay, not with money, but usually, our information.
Data is being used in ways that affect every facet of your life.
The laws that will protect your data and privacy, like the Nuremberg Code protects participants in scientific experiments, are still being written.
We also open the door for abuse of this sensitive information.
We might not be getting all the information we need to consent in an understandable way, similarly to how Henrietta Lacks was not informed why her cells were being taken or what they’d be used for.
We’re are the ones who will decide what is said. And we’re going to be the subject of those decisions.
These situations are obviously not exactly the same, and we, as a society, need to decide how to apply the principles of research ethics in these new digital spaces.
The conversation about how to handle these types of situations is still going on. We’re the ones who will decide what is said.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
PRACTICAL RESEARCH 1 - Research Ethics - EP.4 (Research Simplified)
What Is Statistics: Crash Course Statistics #1
PRACTICAL RESEARCH 1 - The Characteristics, Processes, and Ethics of Research
Is Skynet watching you already?
The beauty of data visualization | David McCandless
The Antidote to Lies, Damned Lies and Statistics | Emily Bird | TEDxFremantle
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: