Why Be Catholic and Not Just Christian?

Father Mike Schmitz
7 Jun 201708:59
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRFather Mike Schmitz from Ascension Presents discusses the unique authority of the Catholic Church, distinguishing it from other Christian denominations. He emphasizes the Church's ability to teach and establish doctrine authoritatively, as founded by Jesus Christ himself. Schmitz uses the Acts of the Apostles and Church Councils to illustrate the Church's role in interpreting Scripture and defining Christian doctrine, such as the Trinity and Jesus' dual nature. He argues that an infallible Bible requires an infallible interpreter to prevent misinterpretation and the proliferation of conflicting beliefs.

Takeaways
  • 🛕 The main difference between the Catholic Church and other denominations is the concept of authority in teaching and establishing doctrine.
  • 🗣️ Fr. Mike Schmitz emphasizes that the Catholic Church teaches with authority, in the name of Jesus, the Holy Spirit, and God the Father.
  • 🏰 Jesus founded the Church and gave Peter 'the keys to the kingdom of heaven,' establishing a visible structure and hierarchy within the Church.
  • 📜 The Church's authority is demonstrated in Acts 15, where the apostles convened to decide on the necessity of circumcision for Gentile converts, concluding it was not required for salvation.
  • 📖 The issue of 'Sola Scriptura' or 'Bible Alone' is highlighted, questioning how to interpret the Bible when it doesn't directly address certain matters.
  • 🔑 The Church's role as an interpreter of the Bible is crucial, as seen in historical councils like Nicaea, which defined the nature of Jesus as both fully human and fully divine.
  • ✝️ The belief in the Trinity and the dual nature of Jesus is attributed to the authority of the Catholic Church, which has shaped the beliefs of Christians worldwide.
  • 🤔 Fr. Mike challenges the listener to consider the importance of an infallible interpreter for the infallible book of the Bible, to prevent misinterpretation and the formation of numerous Christian denominations.
  • 💭 A hypothetical scenario is presented where God, wanting to be truly understood, would not leave the interpretation of divine truth to individual whims but would provide an authoritative guide.
  • 📝 The compilation of the Bible through fallible people is contrasted with the need for an infallible interpretation to ensure the accurate understanding of its teachings.
  • 🗣️ G.K. Chesterton's quote is cited to illustrate the value of the Church's role in correcting beliefs rather than merely affirming them.
Q & A

  • What is the main difference between the Catholic Church and other non-Catholic Christian denominations according to Fr. Mike Schmitz?

    -The main difference is the concept of 'authority'. The Catholic Church claims the ability to teach authoritatively and establish doctrine in the name of Jesus, the Holy Spirit, and God the Father.

  • How does Fr. Mike Schmitz explain the Church's authority to teach?

    -He explains that the Church's authority to teach is based on the belief that it has been given this ability by Jesus himself, as illustrated in Matthew chapter 16 where Jesus gives Peter the keys to the kingdom of heaven and the role of overseer.

  • What biblical reference does Fr. Mike Schmitz use to illustrate the role of Peter in the Church?

    -He references Matthew chapter 16, where Jesus renames Simon as Peter, the 'rock', and promises to build the Church upon him, giving him the keys to the kingdom of heaven.

  • What role does the 'prime minister' or overseer have in the kingdom according to Isaiah?

    -The 'prime minister' or overseer acts as the one in charge when the king is absent, holding the king's authority, as described in Isaiah chapter 22.

  • What event in the Acts of the Apostles demonstrates the Church's ability to make definitive decisions?

    -The event in Acts chapter 15, where the apostles gathered to decide whether Gentile converts needed to be circumcised before baptism, demonstrates the Church's ability to make definitive decisions under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.

  • What is the problem with the 'Sola Scriptura' or 'Bible Alone' approach according to Fr. Mike Schmitz?

    -The problem with 'Sola Scriptura' is that it does not provide guidance on matters not explicitly addressed in the Bible, leading to various interpretations and the formation of many Christian denominations.

  • How does Fr. Mike Schmitz describe the importance of the Church's role in interpreting the Bible?

    -He describes it as essential because an infallible book like the Bible needs an infallible interpreter to prevent misinterpretation and the formation of numerous denominations based on individual understanding.

  • What heresy did the early Church councils address regarding the nature of Jesus Christ?

    -The early Church councils addressed heresies such as Docetism and Arianism, clarifying that Jesus is fully God and fully man, with two natures in one divine person.

  • Why does Fr. Mike Schmitz believe that all Christians, even those not part of the Catholic Church, recognize its authority?

    -He believes this because most Christians accept doctrines such as the Trinity and the dual nature of Jesus Christ, which were defined by the Catholic Church through its councils.

  • What does Fr. Mike Schmitz suggest is the role of the Holy Spirit in guiding the Church's teachings and interpretations?

    -He suggests that the Holy Spirit guides the Church in its teachings and interpretations to ensure they align with the truth and to prevent the Church from getting God wrong.

  • What does Fr. Mike Schmitz emphasize as the importance of having an authoritative Church?

    -He emphasizes that having an authoritative Church is crucial for providing definitive answers to theological questions and preventing the spread of heresies and misinterpretations of the Bible.

Outlines
00:00
🏛 The Authority of the Catholic Church

Father Mike Schmitz discusses the concept of authority in the Catholic Church, distinguishing it from other denominations. He emphasizes that the Church has the divine ability to teach and establish doctrine authoritatively, as founded by Jesus Christ in Matthew 16. The scriptural reference to Peter being given the 'keys to the kingdom of heaven' is highlighted, indicating a visible structure and hierarchy within the Church. The Acts of the Apostles chapter 15 is cited as an example where the Church, through its governance, made a definitive decision on whether Gentiles needed to be circumcised before baptism, thus demonstrating the Church's role in interpreting and teaching scripture.

05:07
🌟 The Necessity of an Infallible Interpreter

In the second paragraph, Father Mike Schmitz explores the importance of an infallible interpreter for the infallible book of the Bible. He argues that while the Bible is divinely inspired and without error in its spiritual message, it requires guidance to be correctly understood. This is exemplified by the Church's role in clarifying theological misunderstandings and heresies, such as the nature of Jesus Christ during the Council of Nicaea. The necessity of the Church's authority is further underscored by the diversity of Christian denominations, which he attributes to the lack of a unified interpretative authority. Schmitz concludes by quoting G.K. Chesterton, who valued the Church's ability to correct errors in belief, rather than merely affirming correct ones.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Authority
In the context of the video, 'authority' refers to the legitimate power or right to give orders, make decisions, and enforce obedience. It is central to the theme as it discusses the Catholic Church's unique claim to authority in matters of faith and doctrine. The video emphasizes that the Church's authority is rooted in Jesus' appointment of Peter as the leader of the Church, as mentioned in Matthew 16, and the Church's ability to teach and establish doctrine authoritatively.
💡Catholic Church
The 'Catholic Church' is the largest Christian denomination, with a hierarchical structure headed by the Pope. The video script highlights the Catholic Church's distinctive approach to authority and doctrine, contrasting it with Protestant denominations and other non-Catholic churches. It underscores the Church's historical role in defining Christian beliefs through councils and its claim to be the visible, structured body founded by Jesus Christ.
💡Protestant Denominations
These are Christian denominations that originated from the Protestant Reformation and reject the Catholic Church's authority. The script contrasts the Catholic view of authority with that of Protestant denominations, which generally emphasize the 'Sola Scriptura' principle, meaning the Bible as the only source of religious authority, without the need for a centralized religious hierarchy.
💡Sola Scriptura
'Sola Scriptura' is a Latin term meaning 'Scripture Alone' and is a core principle of Protestantism. It posits that the Bible is the only necessary guide for faith and practice. The video discusses the limitations of this principle, especially when the Bible does not provide explicit answers to certain questions, as seen in the example of whether Gentiles needed to be circumcised before baptism.
💡Peter
Peter, also known as Simon Peter, is considered the first leader of the early Christian Church and is often referred to as the first pope. In the script, Peter's role is highlighted when Jesus renames him and gives him 'the keys to the kingdom of heaven,' symbolizing his authority to lead and teach in Jesus' name, as per Matthew 16.
💡Keys to the Kingdom
The 'keys to the kingdom of heaven' is a metaphorical term used by Jesus in the Bible to denote the authority to bind and loose, or in other words, to make decisions with divine backing. In the video, this term is used to illustrate the authority given to Peter and, by extension, the Catholic Church to teach and govern in matters of faith.
💡Apostles
The 'apostles' were the twelve main disciples chosen by Jesus, who were given the task of spreading his teachings after his death. The video mentions the apostles in the context of the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15), where they convened to make a definitive decision on the necessity of circumcision for Gentile converts, demonstrating the Church's authority to interpret and apply scripture.
💡Council of Nicaea
The 'Council of Nicaea' was the first ecumenical council of the Christian Church held in 325 AD, which addressed the Arian heresy and affirmed the doctrine of the Trinity. The video uses this historical event to illustrate the Church's role in defining and preserving orthodox Christian beliefs through authoritative councils.
💡Trinity
The 'Trinity' is the belief in Christianity that God exists in three persons: the Father, the Son (Jesus Christ), and the Holy Spirit. The video mentions the Trinity as an example of a doctrine established by the Catholic Church's authority, which is universally accepted among Christians, regardless of denomination.
💡Infallibility
Infallibility, in a religious context, refers to the belief that certain teachings or interpretations are free from error and are divinely guided. The video discusses the concept of infallibility in relation to the Bible and the Church's interpretation of it, arguing that an infallible book requires an infallible interpreter to prevent misinterpretation and the proliferation of conflicting beliefs.
💡Gentiles
In the context of early Christianity, 'Gentiles' referred to non-Jewish people. The video uses the term to discuss the early Church's decision regarding the necessity of circumcision for Gentile converts, which was a pivotal moment demonstrating the Church's authority to interpret and apply scriptural teachings.
Highlights

Fr. Mike Schmitz discusses the main difference between the Catholic Church and other denominations as being the concept of authority.

The Catholic Church is said to have the ability to teach authoritatively, establishing doctrine in the name of Jesus, the Holy Spirit, and God the Father.

Jesus founded the Church as described in Matthew 16, giving Peter the 'keys to the kingdom of heaven', signifying a visible structure and hierarchy.

The role of the 'prime minister' or overseer in the kingdom, as referenced in Isaiah, is likened to Peter's role in the Church's hierarchy.

The Acts of the Apostles chapter 15 describes a crisis in the early Church regarding the necessity of circumcision for Gentile converts, highlighting the need for Church authority in doctrinal matters.

The problem of 'Sola Scriptura' or 'Bible Alone' is presented, where the Bible does not provide answers to all questions, necessitating Church authority for interpretation.

The Church's authority is demonstrated through historical examples such as the Council of Nicaea, which defined the nature of Jesus as both fully God and fully man.

The importance of the Church's role in preserving and interpreting the Bible is emphasized, as an infallible book requires an infallible interpreter.

Fr. Mike suggests that the Catholic Church's authority is recognized by all Christians, even if they do not admit it, through their belief in doctrines such as the Trinity.

The necessity of a visible and structured Church to guide the faithful in understanding and living out their faith is underscored.

A hypothetical scenario is presented where God, wanting to be truly known by humanity, would logically provide an infallible guide to interpret the infallible book of the Bible.

The diversity of Christian denominations is attributed to the lack of a unified, authoritative interpreter of the Bible.

G.K. Chesterton's quote is shared, emphasizing the need for a Church that can correct errors in belief, not just affirm correct ones.

The transcript concludes by reiterating the central theme of authority as the key distinction between the Catholic Church and other Christian denominations.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Did Jesus Found the Roman Catholic Church?

Did Jesus Found the Catholic Church?

Catholicism 101: Go Back to Seminary with Fr. Chris Alar - Explaining the Faith

Why Catholics Have a Pope

Why Catholics Use Scripture and Tradition

The Early Church was 100% Catholic. Here's Why... w/ Joe Heschmeyer

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Catholic ChurchScripture InterpretationAuthorityChristianityJesus ChristPeterApostlesChurch CouncilsReligious DebateSpiritual GuidanceFaith Clarification