Christian Denominations Tierlist (warning: BIAS)

The speaker introduces a video where they will rank Christian denominations based on their similarity to the Reformed tradition, acknowledging the bias and inviting viewers from different traditions to understand that rankings may vary. The speaker also addresses the concept of non-denominationalism, arguing that it further divides Christianity instead of unifying it, and emphasizes the importance of appreciating different denominations' contributions to God's kingdom.

The video script outlines the ranking categories, from S (Superior) to F (heretical), and places Presbyterianism in the S tier due to the speaker's alignment with it. The speaker praises Presbyterianism for its intellectualism, Scottish heritage, and unique theological stances, such as its approach to the Lord's Supper and its traditional architecture, which avoids figurative depictions of Christ.

The A tier includes the Dutch Reformed and Anglican traditions, which are recognized for their theological depth and contributions to theology and church architecture. The Dutch Reformed are noted for their Calvinist roots and theological studies, while Anglicans are appreciated for their broad spectrum of beliefs and practices, including their emphasis on the Kingdom of God and historic theologians.

The script delves into the complex relationship between Lutherans and Presbyterians, marked by historical disagreements over the Lord's Supper. Despite these differences, both traditions share many beliefs and respect each other as part of the Protestant Reformation. Lutherans are noted for their sacred music and environment, centered around the Eucharist.

Methodists are placed in the B tier for their strong focus on helping the poor and spreading the Kingdom of God. While their theology is considered sound, the speaker criticizes Methodists for being less focused on theology compared to Presbyterians and for recent splits within the denomination due to theological differences.

Baptists are placed in the C tier, with the speaker expressing concerns about their individualistic approach to Christianity, rejection of church tradition, and potential for personality cults around certain pastors. The speaker also notes that Baptist churches may not be the most intellectually stimulating environments.

The Assyrian Church of the East and Evangelicals are placed in the D tier. The Assyrian Church is recognized for its澄清 of the Nestorian heresy, while Evangelicals are critiqued for their lack of a clear definition and their roots in Baptist theology, which the speaker views as problematic due to its individualistic tendencies.

The E tier includes the Seventh-Day Adventists and the Church of Christ, both of which are seen as restorationist movements that reject creeds and confessions. This lack of adherence to traditional Christian doctrine makes it difficult to determine whether they are truly Christian, according to the speaker.

The F tier is reserved for denominations that are explicitly heretical, such as Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, and Iglesia ni Cristo. These groups are considered outside of Christianity due to their denial of essential beliefs about Jesus and God, despite potentially having good-hearted followers.

The Moravians are added to the B tier due to their origins before the Protestant Reformation and their unique contributions to Christianity. Although they are not as confessional as other Protestants, they are respected for their historical significance and near-extinction in the present day.

The speaker concludes by addressing theologically liberal denominations, which are seen as heretical due to their departure from essential Christian beliefs. These groups, including Unitarian Universalists and radically progressive churches, are criticized for prioritizing social justice over traditional religious claims and for their lack of commitment to historic Christian doctrine.