Lec 14: Non-independent variables | MIT 18.02 Multivariable Calculus, Fall 2007
TLDRThis lecture explores the concept of non-independent variables and their implications in mathematical functions, particularly focusing on partial derivatives. The instructor uses the example of a function related to pressure, volume, and temperature, constrained by the equation PV=nRT, to illustrate the process of finding rates of change without solving the equation explicitly. The lecture delves into the calculation of partial derivatives through differentials, the chain rule, and the importance of specifying what variables are being held constant. It also addresses common notational pitfalls and provides a geometric example involving the area of a right triangle to demonstrate the application of these concepts.
Takeaways
- ๐ The lecture discusses the concept of non-independent variables and their implications in mathematical functions, particularly in the context of partial derivatives.
- ๐ The use of Lagrange multipliers is introduced to find extrema of functions with variables that are not independent, as previously discussed in a previous session.
- ๐ An example from physics is given to illustrate the concept, where pressure, volume, and temperature are related by the equation PV=nRT, necessitating the understanding of partial derivatives.
- ๐งฉ The lecturer explains how to find rates of change between related variables without explicitly solving for one variable in terms of the others, using the example of a constraint equation x^2yz^3=8.
- ๐ The differential of the constraint equation is used to express the relationship between changes in variables, allowing for the calculation of partial derivatives without solving the constraint.
- ๐ The importance of understanding what is being held constant when calculating partial derivatives is highlighted, with a detailed explanation of how to interpret these derivatives correctly.
- ๐ข A geometric example involving the area of a right triangle is presented to demonstrate how to calculate the rate of change of an area with respect to an angle while keeping other variables constant.
- ๐ค The script explores different interpretations of the rate of change of an area with respect to an angle in a right triangle, considering various scenarios of what variables are held constant.
- ๐ The method of using differentials to compute partial derivatives is explained, with a step-by-step guide on how to apply this method to the area of a triangle example.
- ๐ The chain rule is also discussed as an alternative method to calculate partial derivatives, with an emphasis on understanding the dependency of variables when applying the rule.
- ๐ The lecturer emphasizes the importance of clear notation and the explicit mention of what variables are being held constant to avoid confusion when dealing with related variables.
Q & A
What is the main topic discussed in the script?
-The main topic discussed in the script is the concept of non-independent variables and how to handle functions that depend on several variables when they are related, with a focus on partial derivatives and Lagrange multipliers.
Why do we need to consider non-independent variables in mathematical problems?
-We need to consider non-independent variables when the variables are related by some equation or constraint, which affects how we compute rates of change and find minima or maxima of functions involving these variables.
What is the example given in the script to illustrate the concept of non-independent variables?
-The example given is a physics scenario where pressure, volume, and temperature are related by the equation PV = nRT, showing that these variables are not independent.
How does the script explain the process of finding partial derivatives when variables are related?
-The script explains the process by using the differential of a constraint equation, setting it equal to zero, and then solving for the rate of change of one variable with respect to another while keeping other variables constant.
What is the significance of the differential 'dg' in the script?
-The differential 'dg' represents the variation of the constraint quantity 'g'. By setting 'dg' to zero, we can find the relationships between the changes in the variables, which helps in determining partial derivatives without explicitly solving for one variable in terms of the others.
Can you explain the example of the relation x^2 yz z^3 = 8 used in the script?
-The example demonstrates how to find the rate of change of one variable with respect to others near a given point without solving for the dependent variable explicitly. It uses the differential of the constraint equation to express the rate of change of 'z' in terms of 'x' and 'y'.
What is the geometric example discussed in the script involving a triangle?
-The geometric example involves the area of a right triangle with sides 'a' and 'b' and angle 'theta'. The constraint is that 'b' equals sine of 'theta', and the goal is to understand how the area of the triangle depends on 'theta'.
Why are there different notations for partial derivatives when variables are related?
-Different notations are necessary to explicitly indicate what variables are being held constant during the differentiation process, which is crucial when dealing with related variables to avoid confusion and ensure clarity.
How does the script address the issue of notation when dealing with related variables?
-The script introduces a new notation that uses subscripts to indicate what is being held constant during the differentiation process, which helps to clarify the meaning of the partial derivatives in the context of related variables.
What are the three different answers that could be derived for the rate of change of the area of the triangle with respect to theta, as mentioned in the script?
-The three different answers correspond to different scenarios: changing theta while keeping 'a' and 'b' constant (ignoring the right triangle constraint), changing theta while keeping 'a' constant and allowing 'b' to change to maintain the right triangle, and changing theta while keeping 'b' constant and allowing 'a' to change to maintain the right triangle.
Outlines
๐ Introduction to Non-Independent Variables
The script begins with an introduction to the topic of non-independent variables, emphasizing the importance of understanding the relationships between variables in mathematical functions. It mentions the use of Lagrange multipliers to find extrema and introduces the concept of partial derivatives in the context of related variables, such as pressure, volume, and temperature in physics. The script also humorously addresses a student named Jason, instructing him to claim his package after the lecture.
๐ Exploring Partial Derivatives with Constraints
This paragraph delves into the specifics of partial derivatives when variables are related by an equation, using the example of a function of three variables x, y, z constrained by g(x, y, z) = constant. The script explains how to find rates of change for one variable with respect to another while keeping others constant, even when an explicit solution for one variable in terms of the others is not available. An example using the relation x^2 yz z^3 = 8 near the point (2, 3, 1) is provided to illustrate this concept.
๐ Differentials and Implicit Differentiation
The script explains how to use differentials to find the rates of change for constrained variables without explicitly solving for one variable in terms of the others. It demonstrates this with the example from the previous paragraph, showing how to compute the differential of the constraint equation and set it to zero to find the relationship between the changes in x, y, and z. The paragraph also clarifies how to express dz in terms of dx and dy, and vice versa, to understand the dependencies between variables.
๐ค Clarifying Partial Derivatives Notation
This section addresses potential confusion with the notation used for partial derivatives, especially in the context of change of variables. The script uses a simple example of a function f(x, y) = xy and a change of variables x = u, y = uv to illustrate how partial derivatives with respect to different variables can yield different results, highlighting the importance of specifying what is being held constant during the differentiation process.
๐ Revisiting Notation for Clarity
The script introduces a new notation to explicitly indicate what is being held constant when taking partial derivatives. This is particularly important when dealing with related variables, as it avoids the contradiction that can arise from changing variables without considering the constraints. The new notation uses subscripts to denote the variables that are kept constant, providing a clearer understanding of the differentiation process.
๐๏ธ Applying Concepts to a Geometric Example
The script presents a geometric example involving the area of a triangle with sides a and b and an angle theta. It introduces a constraint that the triangle is a right triangle, with b as the hypotenuse and relates a, b, and theta through the equation b = a * tan(theta). The paragraph explores different interpretations of how the area of the triangle depends on theta, considering various scenarios where either a or b is held constant while the other varies.
๐ Computing Rates of Change with Constraints
This paragraph focuses on computing the rate of change of the area of the right triangle with respect to theta, considering the constraints of the problem. It discusses three different scenarios: changing theta while keeping a and b fixed, changing theta while keeping a constant and allowing b to vary, and changing theta while keeping b constant and allowing a to vary. The script outlines the process of using differentials to find these rates of change, emphasizing the importance of considering the constraint in the calculations.
๐ Differentiating Constraints and Using Chain Rule
The script provides a detailed explanation of how to use differentials and the chain rule to find the rate of change of the area of the triangle with respect to theta, given the constraint that it is a right triangle. It shows how to differentiate the constraint equation to find the relationship between the differentials of a, b, and theta, and then how to substitute this relationship into the expression for the differential of the area to find the desired partial derivatives.
๐ Review and Preparation for the Test
The final paragraph wraps up the discussion and mentions a review session for an upcoming test. It summarizes the methods covered for dealing with partial derivatives of functions with related variables and hints at further exploration of these concepts during the review session. The script encourages students to be familiar with both methods discussed, as they may be applicable to different problems or test questions.
Mindmap
Keywords
๐กLagrange multipliers
๐กNon-independent variables
๐กPartial derivatives
๐กConstraint
๐กDifferential
๐กRate of change
๐กCreative Commons license
๐กMIT OpenCourseWare
๐กGeometric example
๐กRight triangle
Highlights
Introduction to the concept of non-independent variables in mathematical functions and their implications.
Explanation of using Lagrange multipliers for optimization problems with dependent variables.
Illustration of the relationship between physical quantities like pressure, volume, and temperature with the example of PV=nRT.
Introduction to partial derivatives and their significance in functions with related variables.
The method of implicit differentiation to find rates of change without explicitly solving for a variable.
A step-by-step example using the equation x^2 yz z^3=8 to demonstrate how to work with constrained variables.
Clarification on the meaning of partial derivatives and how they relate to changes in variables while keeping others constant.
The differential of a constraint and its use in understanding the relationship between changes in variables.
A detailed walkthrough of expressing dz in terms of dx and dy using the relationship between variables.
Discussion on the importance of specifying what is being held constant when taking partial derivatives.
The problem of notation and the introduction of a new notation to clarify what variables are being held constant.
An example using a geometric scenario of a triangle to explore the dependencies between sides and angles.
Differentiating the area of a triangle with respect to one of its angles while keeping other variables constant in various ways.
The use of differentials to compute partial derivatives in a systematic way without solving for dependent variables.
Application of the chain rule to dependent variables to find the rate of change of a function with respect to one variable.
Review and summary of methods for handling partial derivatives of functions with related variables, preparing for an upcoming test.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: