The consciousness gap in education - an equity imperative | Dorinda Carter Andrews | TEDxLansingED

TEDx Talks
10 Mar 201415:06
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe speaker addresses the undercurrents of racial and socio-economic inequities in education, highlighting the systemic issues of power, privilege, and oppression. They share a personal story to illustrate the impact of biased teaching and advocate for critical self-reflection among educators. The talk emphasizes the need for educators to recognize and challenge the inherent inequalities in the system, promoting a more equitable approach to teaching that acknowledges and addresses cultural differences and biases.

Takeaways
  • 😶 Society often avoids discussing topics like white supremacy and racial inequities, which are crucial for understanding and addressing systemic issues.
  • 🏫 Schools are not adequately preparing students to respect and understand cultural differences, which perpetuates racial and socio-economic disparities.
  • 📚 Racism and other forms of oppression are significant barriers to academic success for students of color and economically disadvantaged students.
  • 👧 The speaker's personal story illustrates how educators' biases and lack of understanding can mislabel and misguide students, hindering their true potential.
  • 🤔 The speaker emphasizes the importance of critical self-reflection among educators to recognize and address their own biases and the impact on their teaching.
  • 🔄 There is a need to move beyond one-off diversity workshops and instead integrate continuous critical self-reflection into the professional lives of educators.
  • 🌐 Understanding one's social location and its influence on teaching practices is essential for educators aiming to be more critically conscious.
  • 💡 Educators must recognize the systemic and cultural power structures that oppress and work to dismantle these within the educational system.
  • 👁️ Being color blind is not a solution; educators must acknowledge and actively address the cultural mismatch and inequalities in the classroom.
  • 🚫 The concept of meritocracy is debunked as a myth, highlighting the need to consider systemic barriers to equal opportunity and success.
  • 🌟 Embracing a critical love and commitment to equity is necessary for educators to create a more inclusive and just educational environment.
Q & A

  • What is the main issue the speaker addresses in the script?

    -The speaker addresses the issue of racial and socio-economic inequities in the educational system, and how these inequities are perpetuated by societal norms and the lack of critical awareness among educators.

  • Why does the speaker believe that racism and other forms of oppression are still major impediments to academic performance for students of color and poor students?

    -The speaker believes that these issues are impediments because they are not adequately addressed or named as fundamental to the racial and cultural divide in the country, which in turn affects the academic performance of the affected students.

  • What personal experience does the speaker share to illustrate the impact of educators' biases on students?

    -The speaker shares a personal story from their childhood where a teacher mislabeled them as needing special education due to their Southern drawl and acting out in class, rather than recognizing their academic potential and providing appropriate challenges.

  • What does the speaker suggest is the root cause of the teacher's inability to recognize the speaker's academic potential?

    -The speaker suggests that the teacher's inability was rooted in a lack of preparation in her teacher education program and professional development to deal with issues of race, culture, and power in teaching and learning.

  • What are the three key questions the speaker asks educators to consider in their process of critical self-reflection?

    -The three key questions are: 1) How does the educator's own social location shape their mindset and practices? 2) What more do they need to know about culture, power, and difference, and where can they learn it? 3) How can they be a more critically conscious leader and instructor?

  • What is the speaker's view on the effectiveness of diversity workshops for educators?

    -The speaker believes that one-time diversity workshops are insufficient. Instead, they advocate for an embedded, continual process of critical self-reflection throughout the professional work of educators.

  • What are the three big ideas the speaker introduces to help educators engage in critical race consciousness?

    -The three big ideas are: 1) Understanding the system and culture of power that oppresses other cultures. 2) Recognizing that educators cannot be color blind or color mute in a diverse student population. 3) Dispelling the myth of meritocracy and acknowledging the barriers faced by students of color and those living in poverty.

  • Why does the speaker argue that the idea of meritocracy is a myth?

    -The speaker argues that meritocracy is a myth because it fails to consider issues of racism, classism, and other forms of oppression as potential barriers for students from disadvantaged backgrounds, leading to unequal outcomes.

  • What does the speaker suggest is necessary for educators to truly embody the idea that all kids can learn?

    -The speaker suggests that educators need to provide spaces for critical self-reflection and learning within their regular school day and professional development, and to commit to an equity pedagogy that helps diverse youth navigate and change the system.

  • What does the speaker mean by 'embodiment of a critical love' in the context of education?

    -The speaker refers to 'critical love' as a form of love that involves knowing one another better, which in turn allows educators to work and respect each other across cultural differences, fostering a more equitable educational environment.

  • What is the speaker's call to action for the audience regarding racial inequity in education?

    -The speaker's call to action is for the audience to raise their critical awareness and to have conversations about racial inequity in education, challenge the system of white supremacy and whiteness as a cultural norm, and take concrete action to change issues of power, privilege, and oppression in education and society.

Outlines
00:00
😔 Societal Blindness to Systemic Racism

The speaker begins by humorously highlighting the lack of discussion on critical issues such as white supremacy and cultural norms of power and privilege in everyday life. They emphasize the societal conditioning that avoids these topics, which perpetuates racial and socio-economic inequities. The speaker, with experience as a student, teacher, and researcher, points out the ongoing challenges of racism and oppression in education, particularly for students of color and low-income students. They share a personal story of being mislabeled in school due to a lack of understanding from educators about racial and cultural biases, and stress the importance of addressing power dynamics to improve educational outcomes.

05:03
🤔 Critical Self-Reflection for Educators

This paragraph delves into the importance of educators engaging in critical self-reflection regarding their own social location and its impact on their teaching practices. The speaker prompts educators to consider their knowledge gaps in cultural power and difference and to seek continuous learning. They introduce the concept of critical race consciousness, emphasizing the existence of oppressive systems rooted in racial and social class hierarchies. The speaker challenges the notion of color blindness in education, arguing for the recognition of inherent inequalities and the need for educators to actively work towards equity. They also debunk the myth of meritocracy, suggesting that hard work alone is insufficient due to systemic barriers faced by marginalized students.

10:04
🌟 Embracing Critical Love for Equitable Education

In the concluding paragraph, the speaker calls for a cycle of critical self-reflection to address the systemic issues in education. They reference statistics on child poverty among different racial groups to highlight the disparities in the system. The speaker advocates for educators to develop skills to navigate and change the system, drawing on the ideas of equity pedagogy and the need to operate within and transform the system. They encourage embracing a critical love that fosters understanding and respect across cultural differences. The speaker ends with a call to action, urging the audience to consider their role in addressing racial inequity in education and society, and to take concrete steps towards creating a more equitable environment.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡White Supremacy
White supremacy is a concept that posits white people as superior to people of other races, often used to justify discrimination and oppression. In the video, it is discussed as a cultural norm and a system that perpetuates racial and socio-economic inequities in society and education. The speaker uses the term to highlight the inherent bias in the educational system that disadvantages students of color and poor students.
💡Cultural Norm
A cultural norm refers to the typical or expected standards and behaviors in a society. The video mentions 'whiteness as a cultural norm' to describe how whiteness is often seen as the standard or default in society, which can marginalize other cultures and contribute to racial inequities.
💡Power Privilege
Power privilege refers to the advantages or rights that some individuals or groups have over others due to their social status or position. The script discusses power privilege in the context of how it exacerbates racial and socio-economic disparities and how it is often overlooked in discussions about education, leading to a lack of understanding and action to address these disparities.
💡Oppression
Oppression is the unjust treatment or control of a group of people, often based on their race, class, or other factors. In the video, the speaker discusses oppression as a major impediment to academic performance for students of color and low-income students, illustrating the systemic barriers they face in education.
💡Racial Inequities
Racial inequities refer to the unfair or unequal treatment of individuals based on their race. The video emphasizes the role of racial inequities in perpetuating disparities in educational outcomes and opportunities, highlighting the need for educators to be aware of and address these inequities.
💡Cultural Bias
Cultural bias is a preference or inclination towards the values, customs, and beliefs of one's own culture, often leading to discrimination against other cultures. The speaker in the video describes how cultural bias can undermine the academic performance of students of color by creating an educational environment that is not inclusive or responsive to their needs.
💡Critical Self-Reflection
Critical self-reflection is the process of deeply examining one's own beliefs, attitudes, and actions, particularly in relation to issues of power, privilege, and oppression. The video encourages educators to engage in critical self-reflection to better understand their role in perpetuating or mitigating racial and socio-economic disparities in education.
💡Equity Imperatives
Equity imperatives are the essential actions or measures needed to achieve fairness and justice, especially in the context of education. The speaker identifies the gap in consciousness about issues of race, culture, and power as an equity imperative, emphasizing the need for educators to address these issues to create a more equitable educational system.
💡Meritocracy
Meritocracy is the belief that success and advancement are based on individual ability and talent, rather than factors such as social class or race. The video challenges the notion of meritocracy as a myth, arguing that it overlooks systemic barriers like racism and classism that prevent equal opportunities for all students.
💡Color Blindness
Color blindness in the context of the video refers to the approach of ignoring racial differences and treating all students the same, regardless of their racial or cultural backgrounds. The speaker argues against color blindness, stating that it fails to recognize and address the unique needs and experiences of students of color, thereby perpetuating inequities.
💡Systemic Barriers
Systemic barriers are the institutionalized practices and policies that create disadvantages for certain groups of people. In the video, the speaker discusses systemic barriers such as racism and classism that impede the academic success of students of color and low-income students, emphasizing the need for educators to recognize and dismantle these barriers.
Highlights

The speaker humorously points out that societal norms often prevent discussions on white supremacy and cultural norms of whiteness, which are crucial for understanding racial and socio-economic inequities.

The speaker emphasizes the lack of preparation in schools to teach respect across cultural differences and the persistence of racism as a barrier to academic performance for students of color and the poor.

Personal story shared about being mislabeled by a teacher due to cultural bias, highlighting the importance of recognizing and challenging stereotypes in education.

The speaker calls for a shift from diversity workshops to continuous critical self-reflection for educators to better understand and address racial and socio-economic disparities.

Three key questions proposed for educators to reflect on their social location, knowledge gaps, and continuous improvement towards critical consciousness in teaching.

The concept of a system of power that oppresses to maintain itself, rooted in racial and social class hierarchy, is introduced as a fundamental understanding for educators.

The speaker refutes the idea of color blindness in education, arguing for the recognition of cultural differences and the need for educators to work towards equity.

The myth of meritocracy is debunked, with the speaker explaining how hard work alone does not account for systemic barriers faced by students of color and the poor.

The importance of educators situating themselves within the system of privilege and considering how they can use their position to support or harm students is discussed.

The analogy of 'boots' is used to illustrate the varying levels of resources and support students bring to their academic journey, emphasizing the need for equity in education.

The speaker calls for educators to commit to equity pedagogy, helping diverse youth navigate and change the system to make it more humane.

The necessity for educators to embody a critical love, fostering understanding and respect across cultural differences, is highlighted.

The speaker challenges the audience to consider when they will next discuss racial inequity in education and take action to transform the system.

A call to action for the audience to give up some privileges for the sake of equity in schools and society, emphasizing collective engagement in this endeavor.

The presentation concludes with an urgent call for immediate action, emphasizing that there is no time like the present to address and transform educational inequities.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Visible Learning - what are effect sizes and what do they mean for learning?

Math teacher interview questions and answers | Math interview questions | Math teacher interview

Together against school bullying (long version)

Interview questions for a physics teacher | Physics teacher interview | Physics teacher job

How to triple your memory by using this trick | Ricardo Lieuw On | TEDxHaarlem

Implicit Bias -- how it effects us and how we push through | Melanie Funchess | TEDxFlourCity

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Racial EquityEducational SystemCultural BiasCritical AwarenessSocial InequityTeacher TrainingSystemic OppressionCultural MismatchMeritocracy MythEquity Pedagogy