Malcolm Gladwell Answers Research Questions From Twitter | Tech Support | WIRED

WIRED
16 Sept 202217:38
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn 'Research Support,' Malcolm Gladwell addresses various aspects of research and knowledge acquisition. He discusses the reliability of Wikipedia as a starting point for research, the enduring value of libraries for serendipitous discovery, and the significance of the 10,000-hour rule in achieving expertise. Gladwell also touches on topics like McDonald's fries recipe change, the nature of 'bad science,' overcoming confirmation bias, and the role of social skills and luck in success. He emphasizes the importance of in-depth research, skepticism towards internet information, and the iterative process of writing. The video is a treasure trove of insights for anyone interested in research methodologies and critical thinking.

Takeaways
  • 🔎 Malcolm Gladwell emphasizes the importance of the nature of open tabs over the quantity, suggesting that having many interesting tabs is preferable to irrelevant ones.
  • 📚 He highlights the value of libraries for research, stating that the internet only covers a fraction of the world's knowledge and that libraries are great for serendipitous discovery.
  • 🌐 Gladwell points out that while the internet excels at directed searches, libraries, with the help of librarians, provide a more comprehensive and expert-guided experience.
  • 🍟 Regarding McDonald's fries, Gladwell explains that the change in cooking oil from beef tallow to vegetable oil in the 1980s not only altered the taste but potentially made the fries less healthy.
  • 🎓 The '10,000-hour rule' is confirmed as a real concept, where approximately a decade of practice is needed to achieve expertise in complex fields, as discussed in Gladwell's book 'Outliers'.
  • 🧐 He criticizes the superficial nature of quick Google searches, advocating for more in-depth and skeptical research methods to avoid misinformation.
  • 💡 Success, according to Gladwell, is not determined by a single factor but is influenced by a combination of luck, social skills, and support from others.
  • ✍️ Nonfiction writers should not stop working on a piece when they think it's done; instead, they should continue refining, as suggested by Gladwell's observation of serious writers.
  • 🤔 Gladwell suggests that smart people sometimes make poor decisions due to a desire to avoid looking foolish, using Wilt Chamberlain's free-throw shooting as an example.
  • 🔍 To determine the quality of scientific research, Gladwell recommends replication as the gold standard, where independent researchers can verify the findings.
  • 🎵 He touches on the emotional impact of country music, attributing its effectiveness to the specificity and complexity of its lyrics, as explored in his podcast 'Revisionist History'.
Q & A
  • How does Malcolm Gladwell view the reliability of Wikipedia?

    -Gladwell suggests that Wikipedia is not bad as a starting point for research. It has a mix of real experts and people who just want to participate. While there can be inaccuracies, it serves as a good gateway to further research.

  • What does Gladwell think about the importance of libraries in the digital age?

    -Gladwell emphasizes the continued importance of libraries, as they house a vast amount of knowledge not available on the internet. He also highlights the value of serendipitous search and the expertise of librarians.

  • Why did McDonald's change their fries recipe in the 1980s according to Gladwell?

    -McDonald's changed their fries recipe from using beef tallow to vegetable oil in response to research suggesting the former was bad for the heart. However, later research indicates that vegetable oil might actually be worse.

  • What is the 10,000-hour rule that Gladwell wrote about in 'Outliers'?

    -The 10,000-hour rule posits that it takes approximately 10 years of practice for someone to become an expert in a cognitively complex field. This is based on the idea that mastery requires a significant amount of time and effort.

  • What does Gladwell believe is the biggest predictor of success?

    -Gladwell suggests that having a rich parent is probably the biggest predictor of success. He also mentions that success is more related to luck, good fortune, and having supportive people around rather than just individual effort or IQ.

  • How does Gladwell view the practice of nonfiction writers in terms of drafts and revisions?

    -Gladwell believes that most people work too little on their pieces. He suggests that serious writers do many more drafts and spend much longer on their writing, implying that if one thinks they should stop, they probably need to do another draft.

  • What is Gladwell's perspective on why smart people sometimes do dumb things?

    -Gladwell offers the example of Wilt Chamberlain to illustrate that smart people might do dumb things because they don't want to look like an idiot, even if it means not achieving their full potential.

  • How does Gladwell define 'bad science'?

    -Gladwell defines bad science as being committed by people who think they know the answer before they start. He emphasizes the importance of replicability as a gold standard for determining the quality of scientific research.

  • What is Gladwell's advice for overcoming confirmation bias?

    -Gladwell suggests being aware of confirmation bias and not relying solely on personal anecdotal experiences. He advises looking at the bigger picture and considering the vast majority of evidence rather than focusing on isolated incidents.

  • How does Gladwell describe the process of researching paranormal phenomena?

    -Gladwell suggests that researching paranormal phenomena is challenging because it often relies on anecdotes rather than scientific studies. He recommends conducting firsthand research, such as interviewing people who claim to have had paranormal experiences.

  • What is the correlation between CEOs playing golf and their company's performance according to Gladwell?

    -Gladwell cites a study showing a correlation between the amount of golf CEOs play and their company's performance, suggesting that the more golf a CEO plays, the worse their company is likely doing.

  • What does Gladwell suggest as a potential interview question to gauge a person's interests?

    -Gladwell suggests asking an interviewee to show how many tabs they have open on their browser as a way to get a sense of their interests and what they are like.

  • How does Gladwell describe the action of digging out more sources rather than writing as a form of procrastination?

    -Gladwell refers to this behavior as getting lost in tangents. He doesn't necessarily view it as a bad thing if one is enjoying the process of discovery.

Outlines
00:00
🔍 Research Perspectives and Wikipedia's Reliability

In this segment, Malcolm Gladwell discusses the nature of research and the reliability of Wikipedia. He compares Wikipedia's collaborative approach, which includes both experts and enthusiasts, to the more traditional expert-driven entries found in Encyclopedia Britannica. Gladwell acknowledges inaccuracies on his own Wikipedia page but praises the platform for its usefulness as a starting point for research. He also addresses the continued relevance of libraries, emphasizing their role in serendipitous discovery and the expertise of librarians, which contrasts with the more directed search capabilities of the internet. Additionally, Gladwell touches on the nostalgia associated with McDonald's fries, explaining how a change in cooking oil in the 1980s altered both taste and health implications, and he delves into the '10,000-hour rule' from his book 'Outliers,' which posits that significant practice is necessary to achieve expertise in complex fields.

05:00
🧐 Skepticism in Research and the Role of Social Skills

This paragraph delves into the importance of skepticism when conducting research online and the challenges of verifying information. Gladwell suggests that while Google is effective for straightforward factual queries, more complex questions require deeper investigation. He also discusses the difficulty of checking facts when the source used for verification may not be trustworthy. Moving on, he addresses the question of what predicts success, suggesting that having a rich parent is a significant factor, but also acknowledges the multifaceted nature of success, which includes luck, good fortune, and social support. The paragraph includes insights into the writing process, with Gladwell recommending persistence beyond initial boredom and the importance of multiple drafts for refining written work. He also explores the reasons behind smart people making poor decisions, often tied to a desire to avoid appearing foolish, and defines 'bad science' as research conducted by individuals with a predetermined outcome in mind, using John Lott's gun research as an example. Lastly, he touches on overcoming confirmation bias and the importance of considering a broader range of data.

10:04
🎵 The Emotional Power of Country Music and Research Methods Pre-Internet

Gladwell begins this segment by discussing a podcast episode that examined why country music tends to be emotionally evocative, attributing it to the specificity and complexity of its lyrics. He then shifts to the topic of research methods before the advent of the internet, advocating for the use of libraries and direct communication with knowledgeable individuals as effective strategies. Responding to a question about intelligence failures, Gladwell uses the example of 9/11 to illustrate how crucial information can be overlooked amidst a vast amount of data. He also defends Philip Zimbardo's Stanford prison experiment against accusations of fakery, explaining its purpose and the controversy surrounding it. Additionally, he discusses the concept of 'broken windows' policing and its role in maintaining order. The segment concludes with advice for a listener struggling to find primary sources on paranormal phenomena, suggesting that firsthand research and personal accounts are the most viable approaches in such a niche area.

15:05
🏌️‍♂️ Golf and Wealth, Tab Management, and Research Tangents

In this final paragraph, Gladwell references his 'Revisionist History' episode 'A Good Walk Spoiled,' which discussed a study finding a correlation between CEOs' golf playing and their companies' performance, suggesting that excessive golfing may indicate a lack of focus on business. He also responds to a question about having numerous tabs open on a computer, sharing his personal habit of keeping between 10 to 15 tabs and the idea of using tab count as an interview question to gauge a candidate's interests. Lastly, he addresses the behavior of going down research tangents instead of writing, likening it to enjoying oneself and not necessarily viewing it as a negative, as long as it contributes to the overall research process.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Research
Research refers to the systematic investigation and study of materials and sources to establish facts and reach conclusions. In the video's theme, research is central to understanding the various topics discussed, such as the reliability of Wikipedia, the value of libraries, and the process of becoming an expert in a field. For instance, Malcolm Gladwell emphasizes the importance of research in his work, using it to explore and explain complex ideas and phenomena.
💡Wikipedia
Wikipedia is a free, collaborative, multilingual online encyclopedia that is written and maintained by a community of volunteers. In the script, Gladwell compares Wikipedia to traditional encyclopedias like Encyclopedia Britannica, highlighting the differences in their approach to expertise and the reliability of the information they provide. He suggests using Wikipedia as a starting point for research but also cautions about its limitations due to a mixture of expert and non-expert contributors.
💡Libraries
Libraries are institutions that provide access to a wide range of information resources, including books, periodicals, and digital media. In the video, Gladwell defends the continued relevance of libraries in the digital age, arguing that they offer unique value for 'serendipitous search' and as a source of expert help through librarians. He contrasts this with the internet's strength in 'directed search'.
💡Serendipitous Search
Serendipitous search refers to the process of discovering valuable information by chance, often through unexpected connections or encounters. In the context of the video, Gladwell describes how libraries facilitate this type of search by allowing readers to stumble upon books or ideas that they might not have found through a targeted internet search.
💡Expertise
Expertise is the advanced knowledge or skill acquired through experience, education, or training in a particular field. The script discusses the importance of expertise in the context of both Wikipedia and libraries. Gladwell points out that while Wikipedia may include contributions from both experts and non-experts, libraries provide access to materials written by recognized authorities and offer the guidance of librarians who are experts in information retrieval.
💡10,000 Hour Rule
The 10,000 Hour Rule is a concept popularized by Gladwell in his book 'Outliers,' suggesting that it takes approximately 10,000 hours of practice to achieve mastery in a field. In the video, he explains that this rule is based on research showing that individuals in cognitively complex fields generally require a significant amount of practice to reach expert status, such as chess players or elite athletes.
💡Confirmation Bias
Confirmation bias is the tendency to search for, interpret, favor, and recall information in a way that confirms one's preexisting beliefs or hypotheses. In the script, Gladwell uses the example of the COVID vaccine to illustrate how confirmation bias can lead individuals to focus on anecdotal evidence that supports their negative beliefs while ignoring the broader statistical evidence of safety and efficacy.
💡Intelligence Failure
Intelligence failure refers to the inability to correctly assess and respond to critical information, often leading to significant consequences. Gladwell cites the 9/11 attacks as an example of an intelligence failure, where the relevant clues were not identified and acted upon in time. He suggests that such failures can occur when important information is obscured by a vast amount of irrelevant data.
💡Broken Windows Policing
Broken windows policing is a strategy that suggests that maintaining order and addressing minor offenses can prevent more serious crimes. Gladwell discusses this concept in relation to the work of researcher George Kelling and how it has been applied and sometimes misapplied in law enforcement practices.
💡Anecdotal Evidence
Anecdotal evidence consists of accounts or evidence drawn from personal experience or individual instances, rather than from systematic research or scientific investigation. In the video, Gladwell mentions anecdotes when discussing paranormal research, noting that in areas outside the mainstream, such as ghost sightings, one often has to rely on personal stories rather than empirical data.
💡Tangents
Tangents refer to diverging from the main subject or topic to pursue a related but separate idea or interest. In the context of the video, Gladwell suggests that getting lost in tangents, or pursuing additional sources of information, can be a natural part of the research process and may not necessarily be a negative aspect, especially if it leads to a deeper understanding or enjoyment of the subject.
Highlights

Malcolm Gladwell emphasizes the importance of the nature of open tabs over the quantity, suggesting that having numerous interesting tabs is preferable to inappropriate content.

Gladwell compares Wikipedia's collaborative approach to Encyclopedia Britannica's expert-based model, noting Wikipedia's mixture of experts and enthusiasts.

He acknowledges inaccuracies on his own Wikipedia page but appreciates its utility as a starting point for research.

Libraries remain relevant despite the internet's prevalence, as they house a vast amount of knowledge not available online.

Gladwell criticizes those who neglect pre-2000 or 2010 knowledge, advocating for the importance of historical understanding.

The internet is praised for directed search, while libraries excel in serendipitous discovery, fostering new ideas.

Librarians are highlighted as valuable experts in libraries, unlike the anonymity of online search assistance.

McDonald's fries' taste change in the 1980s is discussed, attributing it to a shift from beef tallow to vegetable oil, impacting both taste and health.

The 10,000-hour rule from 'Outliers' is defended as a real concept, illustrating the time required to achieve expertise.

Gladwell agrees that the term 'research' has been diluted, urging for skepticism and deeper investigation beyond Google searches.

The biggest predictor of success, according to Gladwell, is likely having a rich parent, emphasizing the role of external factors.

Nonfiction writers should continue revising beyond their initial belief they should stop, as indicated by Gladwell's experience.

Smart people may make poor decisions to avoid appearing foolish, as illustrated by Wilt Chamberlain's free-throw shooting choice.

Bad science is characterized by preconceived notions and lack of replicability, as critiqued in the work of John Lott.

Confirmation bias is identified as a significant error in interpreting data, with the COVID vaccine as an example.

To overcome boredom in writing, Gladwell suggests delving deeper, as everything becomes interesting with sufficient exploration.

Country music's emotional impact is linked to the specificity of its lyrics, as discussed in the 'King of Tears' podcast episode.

Pre-internet research involved libraries and phone calls, methods Gladwell still endorses for profound learning.

Intelligence failures, such as 9/11, are attributed to the challenge of identifying relevant data among a vast amount of information.

Gladwell defends Zimbardo's Stanford prison experiment against accusations of being faked, discussing its complexity and controversy.

The broken windows theory is explained, highlighting its role in maintaining order and preventing larger acts of disorder.

Paranormal research is suggested to rely on firsthand accounts and personal investigation due to the lack of mainstream scientific study.

Wealthy individuals' preference for golf is linked to its cost, time commitment, and potential neglect of company management.

Gladwell discusses the idea of using open tabs as an interview question to gauge a candidate's interests and personality.

The concept of getting lost in tangents during research is presented as potentially beneficial if it leads to enjoyment and discovery.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: