What If Alien Life Were Silicon-Based?

PBS Space Time

26 Jan 202321:56

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script explores the possibility of silicon-based life forms in the universe, contrasting them with the carbon-based life we are familiar with on Earth. It delves into the chemical properties of carbon that make it the backbone of life as we know it, including its ability to form diverse and stable covalent bonds. Silicon, while chemically similar and more abundant on many planets, faces challenges such as instability in water and a strong affinity for oxygen bonds, which may limit its potential as a basis for life. The script also touches on the role of water as a universal solvent and the potential for silicon-based life in specialized environments like liquid hydrocarbons or sulfuric acid. It concludes by suggesting that while silicon-based life may be less common than carbon-based life, it could still exist in unique conditions, and highlights the existence of diatoms as an example of silicon being incorporated into a component of life on Earth.

Takeaways

🌌 Life on Earth is carbon-based, but there's speculation about the possibility of silicon-based life due to silicon's abundance and chemical similarity to carbon.
🔬 The biochemistry of life relies on carbon's unique ability to form diverse molecular structures, including chains and rings that serve as the scaffolding for life's machinery.
⚙️ Carbon's versatility comes from its valency, allowing it to form a balance between reactivity and stability, which is crucial for life's ongoing chemical reactions.
❌ While silicon can form complex molecules, silicon-based life is less likely on Earth because silicon compounds are highly reactive with water, which is essential for life as we know it.
🚫 Silicon's strong affinity for oxygen makes it form very stable bonds that are difficult to break, which is not conducive to the dynamic chemical processes of life.
🌟 Despite silicon's limitations, certain conditions might allow for silicon-based life, especially in environments where water is not the primary solvent.
🌍 Earth's carbon is more accessible to life through the atmosphere, whereas silicon is largely locked up in rocks, making carbon more favorable for life's development.
🔑 The strength of silicon-oxygen bonds could theoretically be useful for energy generation, but the byproduct of such a process would be sand, which is not conducive to biological systems.
💠 Diatoms are an example of life incorporating silicon into their cell walls, showing that silicon can be a component of life, even if the internal biochemistry remains carbon-based.
📚 The concept of silicon-based life is more common in science fiction than in scientific reality, suggesting that carbon-based life is more likely given our current understanding.
🌟 The search for extraterrestrial life should not discount unusual environments, as they might harbor life forms with biochemistries different from those on Earth.

Q & A

Why is carbon the basis for life as we know it?
-Carbon is the basis for life as we know it because it forms strong bonds with itself and other elements, creating a variety of structures that enable the molecular machinery of life. It is also abundant and provides a balance of reactivity and stability, which is crucial for life's ongoing chemical reactions.
Why are science fiction writers interested in silicon-based life?
-Science fiction writers are interested in silicon-based life because silicon shares chemical similarities with carbon, making it a promising non-carbon alternative. Additionally, silicon is more abundant on Earth than carbon, which sparks curiosity about the potential for silicon-based life forms.
What is the role of water in the context of life's chemistry?
-Water serves as an ideal solvent for life, allowing molecular machinery to move around and interact. Its thermal stability, solvent power, and abundance make it the best candidate for the base solvent for life, which is crucial for the stability and reactivity of biological molecules.
Why is silicon less favored for life on Earth despite its abundance?
-Silicon is less favored for life on Earth because silicon-based molecules tend to be more reactive with water, leading to instability. Additionally, silicon forms stronger bonds with oxygen, which can be problematic for life processes that require a balance of reactivity and stability.
What are the conditions that might support silicon-based life?
-Silicon-based life might be possible in environments where silicon molecules are stable, such as in liquid hydrocarbons found on the moons of gas giants or in sulfuric acid-rich environments like Venus's atmosphere. However, these conditions are less ideal than those supporting carbon-based life.
How do covalent bonds contribute to the complexity of life?
-Covalent bonds allow atoms to share electrons, enabling the formation of complex and diverse molecular structures. This electron sharing is the key to the complex and resilient molecular scaffolds necessary for life, as seen in carbon-based biochemistry.
Why do ionic and metallic bonds not support the chemical variety needed for life?
-Ionic bonds are too unstable, and metallic bonds result in repeating crystal structures, which lack the chemical variety and complexity necessary for the diverse molecular machinery of life.
What is the significance of Diatoms in the context of silicon in biology?
-Diatoms are single-celled organisms that incorporate silicon into their cell walls, essentially forming silica crystals. While not silicon-based life, they demonstrate that a significant component of life, the cell wall, can be made from silicon.
How does the strength of silicon-oxygen bonds impact the potential for silicon-based life?
-The strength of silicon-oxygen bonds makes silicon-based molecules easily broken by oxygen and the resulting bonds hard to break. This leads to reactions that tend to be unidirectional, which is not favorable for the reversible reactions often needed in life processes.
Why might silicon-based life forms be less common in the universe than carbon-based life?
-Silicon-based life forms might be less common because the conditions that support their existence are more specialized and less ideal than those for carbon-based life. Carbon's ability to form a wide range of stable, complex molecules in water makes it a more versatile and likely candidate for life across the universe.
What is the role of the element phosphorus in Earth's biochemistry?
-Phosphorus, along with hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen, is considered a fundamental building block of life on Earth. It plays a critical role in the formation of ATP, the energy currency of the cell, and is a component of DNA and RNA.

Outlines

00:00

🤔 The Possibility of Silicon-Based Life

This paragraph explores the concept of life beyond carbon-based organisms, focusing on silicon as a potential alternative. It discusses silicon's chemical similarities to carbon, its abundance on other planets, and its portrayal in science fiction. The paragraph delves into the reasons why carbon is favored for life's molecular machinery, including its ability to form diverse and stable covalent bonds. It also questions whether carbon's dominance is a result of evolutionary chance or a necessity for life and touches on the types of bonds that could support life, concluding that covalent bonds are the most viable option.

05:06

🚫 Silicon's Limitations in Supporting Life

The second paragraph examines why silicon, despite its chemical similarities to carbon, is not the basis for life on Earth. It rules out various elements based on their bond types and reactivity, leaving a shortlist of elements that could theoretically support life. Silicon's tendency to form stable bonds with oxygen is highlighted as a significant drawback, as silicon-based molecules are often unstable in water. The paragraph also discusses alternative solvents to water and the potential for silicon to be used in specialized environments, such as on other planets with different conditions. It concludes by noting that carbon's versatility and the accessibility of carbon in the form of CO2 make it a more favorable element for life as we know it.

10:10

🌌 Silicon-Based Life in Unusual Environments

This paragraph further explores the potential for silicon-based life, particularly in environments different from Earth's. It suggests that silicon could theoretically support life in specific conditions, such as in liquid hydrocarbons or sulfuric acid, although these environments present their own challenges. The discussion touches on the concept of life using silicon in combination with carbon or oxygen for structural molecules and the energy generation possibilities through the conversion of oxygen into silicon dioxide. The paragraph also points out the practical issues with silicon-based life, such as the accumulation of sand as a byproduct, and concludes by summarizing that while silicon has potential, carbon is a more efficient and convenient choice for life's chemistry.

15:14

🌐 Carbon's Superiority and Speculations on Alien Life

The fourth paragraph summarizes the discussion on silicon-based life and reiterates carbon's advantages for life's chemistry. It suggests that life is likely to be carbon-based if the conditions are right, but does not completely rule out the possibility of silicon-based life in highly unusual environments. The paragraph also touches on the portrayal of silicon-based life in science fiction and introduces diatoms as an example of silicon being incorporated into a living organism, albeit not as the basis for life itself. It concludes by suggesting that while alien life is likely to be more similar than different to life on Earth, there may be unique forms of life in environments like Titan's hydrocarbon lakes or Venus's acidic atmosphere.

20:18

📚 Comment Responses and Corrections

The final paragraph shifts the focus to addressing comments and making corrections from previous episodes. It discusses the mathematical universe hypothesis, the possibility of Theia's material in Earth's mantle, and the Fermi paradox. The paragraph also corrects a mistake regarding Neptune's moon, Triton, which was mistakenly referred to as Titan, a moon of Saturn. It ends with a humorous note about the speaker's Australian accent and a playful jab at the distinctiveness of Australian birds.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Carbon-based life

Carbon-based life refers to organisms that rely on carbon as the fundamental element for the molecular structures that make up their cells and tissues. In the video, it is mentioned that all known life on Earth is carbon-based, with carbon chains and rings forming the scaffolding for a variety of molecules essential for life, such as DNA, RNA, amino acids, and proteins.

💡Silicon

Silicon is an element that shares some chemical properties with carbon and is more abundant on many planets. The video explores the possibility of silicon-based life, contrasting it with carbon-based life. Silicon is discussed as a potential alternative to carbon for the scaffolding of life's molecular machinery, although it is less favored due to its reactivity with water and preference for bonding with oxygen.

💡Biochemistry

Biochemistry is the study of the chemical processes and substances occurring within living organisms. It is intrinsically tied to the video's theme as it focuses on the chemistry of life, particularly how carbon forms the basis of all known biochemistry. The video mentions that biochemists often omit carbon in their formulas due to its ubiquitous role.

💡Covalent bonds

Covalent bonds are a type of chemical bond where atoms share electrons, allowing them to achieve stability by filling their outer electron shells. The video emphasizes covalent bonds as crucial for the complex molecular structures necessary for life, noting that carbon's ability to form diverse covalent bonds contributes to its role in biological systems.

💡Ionic and metallic bonds

Ionic and metallic bonds are types of chemical bonds that are less suitable for life as described in the video. Ionic bonds are considered too unstable, while metallic bonds result in repeating structures like crystals that lack the chemical variety needed for life. These bonds are contrasted with covalent bonds, which are more versatile and central to life's chemistry.

💡Noble Gases and Halogens

Noble gases and halogens are elements that are not considered fundamental building blocks of life due to their chemical properties. Noble gases are inert and barely reactive, while halogens are too reactive and form explosive compounds when they react with other elements. The video uses these elements to illustrate which types of elements are unsuitable for the chemistry of life.

💡Building blocks of life

The building blocks of life refer to the essential elements and molecules that form the structures and processes of living organisms. The video identifies hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, phosphorus, and sulfur as the main building blocks of life on Earth, with carbon being the most critical due to its ability to form complex structures.

💡Diatoms

Diatoms are single-celled organisms that incorporate silicon into their cell walls, making them rigid and essentially silica crystals. The video uses diatoms as an example of how silicon can be a part of life, even though they are not entirely silicon-based. This serves as a proof of concept that components of life, such as cell walls, can be made from silicon.

💡Silicon-based life

Silicon-based life is a hypothetical form of life that uses silicon instead of carbon as the primary element for its molecular structures. The video discusses the challenges and conditions that silicon-based life would face, especially on a water-rich planet like Earth, and explores the possibility of silicon-based life in environments with different solvents, such as liquid hydrocarbons or sulfuric acid.

💡Energy generation

Energy generation in the context of the video refers to the process by which living organisms produce and store energy. It discusses the possibility of silicon-based life generating energy through the conversion of oxygen molecules into silicon dioxide (silica), comparing it to how carbon-based life forms generate energy through the conversion of oxygen into carbon dioxide.

💡Quantum Objects

Quantum Objects is a course mentioned in the video that explores the principles of quantum mechanics. While not directly related to the main theme of the video, it is used as an example of the type of advanced and complex topics that can be studied on Brilliant.org, an online learning platform for STEM subjects.

Highlights

Life as we know it is carbon-based, but there's a possibility of silicon-based life due to silicon's abundance and chemical similarity to carbon.

Silicon, like carbon, has four valence electrons and can form complex covalent bonds, making it a promising non-carbon alternative.

Carbon is favored in life due to its ability to form a balance of reactivity and stability, which is crucial for life's ongoing chemical reactions.

Nature seeks the lowest energy state, which is significant for understanding the directionality of life's chemical processes.

Covalent bonds are the key to the complex molecular structures needed for life, and carbon is particularly adept at forming these bonds.

Silicon-based life might be possible in environments where silicon is stable, such as in liquid hydrocarbons or sulfuric acid.

Silicon-based molecules are generally more reactive with water, which could be problematic for life as we know it on Earth.

Diatoms are an example of life incorporating silicon into their cell walls, although their internal biochemistry is still carbon-based.

The strength of silicon-oxygen bonds could potentially be useful for energy generation in silicon-based life forms.

Silicon-based life is less likely than carbon-based life due to the latter's superior versatility and accessibility.

The concept of silicon-based life has been popularized in science fiction, despite its rarity in reality.

Brilliant.org is an online learning platform for STEM that offers interactive lessons and problem-solving activities.

The course 'Quantum Objects' on Brilliant.org explores quantum mechanics and its role in modern technologies.

The mathematical universe hypothesis posits that our physical reality emerges from a more fundamental mathematical structure.

Sir Rodger Penrose's three worlds ontology describes the emergence of reality from the platonic mathematical world to the mental world.

The possibility that remnants of Theia, the planet that collided with Earth to form the Moon, may still exist within Earth's mantle.

The Fermi paradox and the potential role of Earth's large moon as one of several hard filters for the development of life.

Correction and clarification regarding the previous discussion on animals that can 'swim' in gas and the pronunciation of Neptune's moon Triton.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

the aliens will not be silicon

Why is All Life Carbon Based, Not Silicon? Three Startling Reasons!

LIFE BEYOND: Chapter 1. Alien life, deep time, and our place in cosmic history (4K)

Properties of Water

Ancient Life as Old as the Universe

What Are Covalent Bonds | Properties of Matter | Chemistry | FuseSchool