The Black Legend, Native Americans, and Spaniards: Crash Course US History #1

CrashCourse

31 Jan 201311:19

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this insightful episode of Crash Course U.S. History, John Green discusses the pre-European history of North America, highlighting the diversity and complexity of Native American societies. He challenges the notion of 'primitive' cultures, emphasizing the Eurocentric bias in historical narratives. The script also covers the devastating impact of European diseases on indigenous populations and the Spanish colonization efforts, including the Pueblo Revolt. The episode underscores the importance of considering multiple perspectives and the voices that history often overlooks.

Takeaways

🌍 The globe used in the show reflects skepticism about the legitimacy of Alaskan statehood and the moon landing.
🏴 The show, titled 'US History,' acknowledges that it will cover events outside the United States due to global interconnectedness.
🎶 The theme music introduces the beginning of U.S. history by discussing the people who lived in North America before European arrival.
🏙️ Upon European arrival, there were no 'classical style civilizations' in North America, unlike the Aztec or Inca empires.
🌾 Native North Americans had no metalwork, gunpowder, wheels, written languages, or domesticated animals, but they did have farming, complex societies, and trade networks.
🤔 The term 'primitive' is questioned as it implies a Eurocentric and contemporary-centric view of history that is not linear.
📈 Estimates of the pre-European North American population range from 2 to 10 million, with some as high as 75 million.
🦠 Native American populations were severely reduced by diseases like smallpox and influenza, with a mortality rate closer to 'oct-icimation' than 'decimation'.
🏘️ The Zuni and Hopi civilizations peaked around 1200 CE, with large family dwellings, possibly leaving due to drought and environmental degradation.
🌐 Tribal organization was based on natural resources, with west coast tribes relying on fishing and the Great Plains tribes on buffalo hunting.
📜 The Iroquois Confederacy was a loose alliance similar to NATO, and religion was vibrant with ceremonies focused on the tribe's lifestyle.
🌳 American Indians viewed land as a common resource, with village leaders assigning its use but not ownership, reflecting a different concept of property than Europeans.

Q & A

What misconception does John Green address at the beginning of the video?
-John Green addresses the misconception that the term 'United States' or 'US History' can be used to describe events and periods before the formation of the United States, emphasizing that the discussion will inevitably involve other parts of the world and not just the US.
What were the two main characteristics of Native North Americans when Europeans arrived?
-When Europeans arrived, Native North Americans had no metalwork, gunpowder, wheels, or written languages, and no domesticated animals. However, they did have farming, complex social and political structures, and widespread trade networks.
What does John Green argue against when discussing the term 'primitive' to describe pre-Columbian societies?
-John Green argues against the term 'primitive' because it implies a romanticized and infantilized view of indigenous people, suggesting they were less evolved humans. He emphasizes that the human story cannot be seen as a linear progression from primitive to civilized, and that this perspective is both Eurocentric and contemporary-centric.
What was the population estimate of Native Americans in North America before European arrival?
-The population estimates of Native Americans in North America before European arrival vary, with some estimates as high as 75 million, but within the present US borders, the guesses are between 2 and 10 million.
How did diseases impact Native American populations after European arrival?
-Diseases such as smallpox and influenza decimated Native American populations, with the death rate likely being closer to 8 in 10, or an 'oct-icimation,' which was far worse than the term 'decimation' would suggest.
What was the Iroquois Confederacy and how was it similar to NATO?
-The Iroquois Confederacy, also known as the Great League of Peace, was a loose confederation of tribal bands in upstate New York. It was similar to NATO in that it was a联盟 of different groups for mutual benefit, although without nuclear weapons or the international complexities that NATO faces.
How did Native Americans view land ownership compared to Europeans?
-Native Americans viewed land as a common resource that could be assigned for use but not owned. This contrasts with the European concept of private land ownership, where land could be bought, sold, and inherited.
What role did women play in Native American societies?
-Women in Native American societies often played significant roles, including being important religious leaders and owning dwellings and tools. In many tribes, women's premarital relationships were not taboo, and matrilineal systems were common where children belonged to their mother's family.
What was the Pueblo Revolt of 1680 and what were its consequences?
-The Pueblo Revolt of 1680 was a large-scale uprising by the Pueblo people against Spanish colonists in New Mexico. The revolt led to the deaths of 400 Spanish colonists and the expulsion of the remaining Spanish from Santa Fe. After the revolt, the Spanish became more tolerant of indigenous religion and abandoned the encomienda system of forced labor.
What is the Black Legend and how did it impact the narrative of American history?
-The Black Legend is the narrative that the Spanish inflicted unspeakable cruelty on the indigenous people of the Americas. While this narrative is true to some extent, it was later used by other settlers, particularly the English, to justify their own colonization efforts as a means to 'save' the Indians from Spanish cruelty.
What does John Green emphasize as important when studying American history?
-John Green emphasizes the importance of recognizing the point of view of historical sources, understanding the motivations behind them, and acknowledging the voices that go unheard and the reasons why they may be silent in historical narratives.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 Introduction to US History and Native American Life

The video begins with John Green introducing the Crash Course US History series, humorously addressing the name and scope of the show. He emphasizes the importance of discussing the history of the indigenous people who lived in North America before European arrival. Green highlights the diversity of Native American societies, their lack of 'classical' civilizations, metalwork, gunpowder, wheels, and written languages, but their presence of agriculture, social structures, and trade networks. He critiques the Eurocentric view of history and the notion of 'primitive' societies, arguing for a more nuanced understanding of the pre-Columbian era. The video touches on the devastating impact of diseases like smallpox on Native American populations and mentions the Zuni, Hopi, and Pueblo civilizations. It also discusses the tribal organization, the Iroquois Confederacy, and the spiritual and material culture of Native Americans, including their views on property and gender roles within tribes.

05:04

📜 European Perceptions and Early Encounters

This paragraph delves into the early European perceptions of Native Americans, which varied from viewing them as noble and innocent to seeing them as savages due to their lack of writing, sexual norms, and Christianity. The Spanish exploration of the Americas is highlighted, with figures like Juan Ponce de Leon and Alvar Nunez Cabeza de Vaca. The Spanish colonization efforts in Florida and the American Southwest, including the establishment of Santa Fe, are discussed, along with the challenges faced due to disease and cultural clashes. The paragraph also covers the Pueblo Revolt of 1680, which led to a temporary expulsion of the Spanish from Santa Fe and a shift in their treatment of indigenous peoples. The Mystery Document segment focuses on the critique of Spanish cruelty towards Native Americans, as documented by Bartolome de las Casas, and the problematic 'Black Legend' narrative used by later settlers to justify their own colonial endeavors.

10:05

📚 Reflecting on Historical Narratives and Sources

In the concluding paragraph, John Green emphasizes the importance of critically examining historical narratives and sources. He notes the advantage of the US having many written sources but cautions viewers to consider the viewpoints of those sources and the voices that may be missing from the historical record. Green encourages viewers to remember the diverse experiences of Native Americans and to question the perspectives presented throughout the series. The video ends with credits for the Crash Course team and a call to action for viewers to engage with the content and continue learning.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Pre-Columbian North America

Pre-Columbian North America refers to the time period before Christopher Columbus's voyages, which began in 1492. This era is characterized by the diverse cultures and societies of indigenous peoples who inhabited the landmass that is now known as the United States. The video discusses the absence of 'classical style civilizations' and the lack of certain technologies such as metalwork and written languages among these indigenous societies, but also highlights their complex social structures, agriculture, and trade networks.

💡European Contact and Disease

European contact with indigenous peoples led to the introduction of diseases such as smallpox and influenza, to which the native populations had no immunity. The resulting pandemics decimated indigenous populations, with estimates suggesting a mortality rate much higher than the term 'decimation' (the killing of every tenth person) would suggest, potentially closer to an 'oct-icimation' (the killing of eight in ten).

💡Zuni and Hopi Civilization

The Zuni and Hopi civilizations represent significant pre-Columbian cultures that peaked around 1200 CE. They lived in large communal dwellings in canyons, which they may have abandoned due to drought. These civilizations are used in the video to illustrate the existence of complex societies in North America before European arrival, challenging the notion that all pre-Columbian cultures were 'primitive'.

💡Iroquois Confederacy

The Iroquois Confederacy, also known as the Great League of Peace, was a political union of Native American tribes, specifically the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, and Seneca nations. The Confederacy is highlighted in the video as an example of tribal confederations that existed in North America, showcasing the political and social complexity of indigenous societies.

💡Land Ownership and Stewardship

The concept of land ownership and stewardship among Native Americans was fundamentally different from European views. To the first peoples, land was a common resource meant for communal use rather than private ownership. Village leaders could assign land for use, but not for ownership. This perspective is contrasted with the European approach to land as a commodity to be bought and sold, and it reflects a different set of values and relationships with the environment.

💡Class Distinctions and Matrilineal Societies

While the video challenges the romanticized notion of American Indians as free from social stratification, it also acknowledges the existence of class distinctions within tribes. Rulers often came from the same families, indicating a form of aristocracy. However, wealth was more evenly distributed than in Europe. Additionally, many tribes were matrilineal, meaning descent and inheritance were traced through the mother's line, and women often held significant religious and economic roles within their societies.

💡Spanish Exploration and Colonization

Spanish exploration and colonization efforts in the Americas began in the early 16th century, with explorers like Juan Ponce de Leon and Alvar Nunez Cabeza de Vaca searching for gold and new lands. The Spanish established colonies in places like Florida and Santa Fe, New Mexico, but faced significant challenges, including disease, environmental conditions, and resistance from indigenous peoples.

💡Pueblo Revolt

The Pueblo Revolt was a large-scale uprising by the indigenous Pueblo peoples against Spanish colonizers in 1680. This revolt was sparked by the harsh treatment of the Pueblos by the Spanish, including forced labor and religious persecution. The revolt resulted in the killing of hundreds of Spanish colonists and the temporary overthrow of Spanish rule in the region.

💡Bartolome de las Casas

Bartolome de las Casas was a Spanish historian and Dominican friar who advocated for the rights of indigenous peoples in the Americas. He is known for his writings that documented the atrocities committed by the Spanish against the indigenous populations, which challenged the prevailing views of the time and contributed to the critique of Spanish colonial policies.

💡Black Legend

The Black Legend is a term used to describe the negative portrayal of Spanish colonial actions in the Americas, particularly the cruelty inflicted upon indigenous peoples. This narrative was later used by other European powers, such as the English, to justify their own colonization efforts as a means to 'save' the indigenous peoples from Spanish tyranny.

💡Historical Bias and Perspective

Historical bias and perspective refer to the inherent subjectivity in the recording and interpretation of historical events. The video emphasizes the importance of recognizing the viewpoints of those who记录历史, including the motivations behind their accounts and the voices that may have been silenced or marginalized.

Highlights

John Green introduces the Crash Course U.S. History series with a humorous take on the name, reflecting on the historical context of the term 'United States'.

The series begins by discussing the indigenous people of North America before European arrival, challenging the notion of 'primitive' societies.

It is noted that Native North Americans had no metalwork, gunpowder, wheels, written languages, or domesticated animals, but they did have farming, complex social structures, and trade networks.

John Green critiques the Eurocentric view of history, emphasizing the fallacy of viewing human progress as a linear progression from 'primitive' to 'civilized'.

Estimates of the pre-European North American population range from 2 to 10 million, with some as high as 75 million.

Diseases like smallpox and influenza decimated Native American populations, with a mortality rate closer to 'oct-icimation' than 'decimation'.

The Zuni and Hopi civilizations peaked around 1200 CE, with large family dwellings, possibly abandoning them due to drought.

The Iroquois Confederacy is mentioned as an example of a tribal联盟, highlighting the diversity of pre-Columbian American experiences.

Religion among Native Americans was closely tied to their lifestyle, with a belief in a single Creator-god above other deities, but not in the monotheistic sense.

American Indians viewed land as a common resource, with village leaders assigning its use but not ownership, contrasting with European concepts of property.

Despite romanticized notions, class distinctions existed within Indian tribes, with rulers often coming from the same families.

Many tribes were matrilineal, with women owning dwellings and tools, and having significant roles in religion and society.

The idea of 'noble savages' is discussed, challenging the stereotype of Native Americans as pure and untouched by vices.

Spanish exploration is detailed, including Juan Ponce de Leon's arrival in Florida and the search for gold and the fabled fountain of youth.

The Spanish colonization of Florida and the American Southwest is discussed, including the failed missions and the Pueblo Revolt of 1680.

The Mystery Document feature is introduced, focusing on a primary source critical of Spanish treatment of the indigenous people.

Bartolome de las Casas is highlighted as a Spaniard who recognized and criticized the cruelty inflicted upon the Indians by his countrymen.

The Black Legend is discussed, which portrays the Spanish as uniquely cruel, and its use by later settlers to justify their own colonization efforts.

The importance of considering multiple perspectives and the need to recognize which voices are unheard in historical accounts is emphasized.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

War and Nation Building in Latin America: Crash Course World History 225

The Natives and the English - Crash Course US History #3

APUSH Unit 1 in 10 Minutes with Tom Richey

The Rise of the West and Historical Methodology: Crash Course World History #212

Expansion and Consequences: Crash Course European History #5

Slavery - Crash Course US History #13

The Black Legend, Native Americans, and Spaniards: Crash Course US History #1

Takeaways

Q & A

What misconception does John Green address at the beginning of the video?

What were the two main characteristics of Native North Americans when Europeans arrived?

What does John Green argue against when discussing the term 'primitive' to describe pre-Columbian societies?

What was the population estimate of Native Americans in North America before European arrival?

How did diseases impact Native American populations after European arrival?

What was the Iroquois Confederacy and how was it similar to NATO?

How did Native Americans view land ownership compared to Europeans?

What role did women play in Native American societies?

What was the Pueblo Revolt of 1680 and what were its consequences?

What is the Black Legend and how did it impact the narrative of American history?

What does John Green emphasize as important when studying American history?