(Geo)Politics of the Balkans: the Revenge of History

Diplomatische Akademie Wien
8 Feb 2023110:11
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this insightful lecture, Vuk Jeremić, former Foreign Minister of Serbia and a prominent intellectual, delves into the complex geopolitics of the Balkans, highlighting its historical significance and current challenges. Jeremić discusses Serbia's political landscape, the contentious issue of Kosovo's independence, and the broader implications for European stability. He emphasizes the importance of understanding historical and cultural forces in shaping the region's present and future, while also addressing the role of great powers and the precarious balance of national identities and borders in the Balkans.

Takeaways
  • 🌟 The speaker, Vuk Jeremić, is a prominent Serbian politician, diplomat, and intellectual who has served as Serbia's Foreign Minister and President of the UN General Assembly.
  • 🏛 Jeremić discusses the complex geopolitics of the Balkans, emphasizing the historical and ongoing conflicts shaped by the intersection of European and Middle Eastern influences.
  • 🔄 He highlights the role of religion in defining the identities of Balkan nations, with the region's geography divided among Catholic, Muslim, and Orthodox Christian majorities.
  • 📚 The speaker critiques the current state of Serbia's political and economic situation, citing issues of governance, democratic erosion, and corruption.
  • 🗳️ Jeremić expresses skepticism about the prospects of Serbia and other Western Balkan countries joining the European Union, due to the EU's requirement of consensus and the current geopolitical climate.
  • 🏡 He touches on the importance of the 'Kosovo myth' in Serbian national identity and the challenges of resolving the Kosovo issue, advocating for peaceful coexistence and mutual understanding.
  • 🚫 Jeremić strongly opposes the idea of Kosovo's independence and warns against the precedent it sets for other regions, such as Republika Srpska, potentially leading to further conflicts.
  • 🤝 He calls for responsible politics in the Balkans, balancing national interests with the need for regional stability and cooperation.
  • 🌍 The speaker reflects on the broader geopolitical landscape, suggesting the world is in a state of geopolitical recession with a potential slide towards a new Cold War.
  • ⏳ Jeremić emphasizes the need for Serbia to focus on internal reforms to become a functioning modern European state, regardless of EU membership status.
Q & A
  • Who is Vuk Jeremić and what roles has he held in the past?

    -Vuk Jeremić is a Serbian politician, diplomat, and president of the Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development. He has previously served as the Foreign Minister of Serbia, the President of the United Nations General Assembly, and was a candidate for the United Nations Secretary-General.

  • What is Jeremić's view on the current state of Serbia's governance and its impact on the Balkans?

    -Jeremić believes that Serbia's governance is in a very bad shape, particularly concerning democratic governance, human rights, and economic outlook due to corruption. He suggests that Serbia's condition significantly impacts the Balkans, as Serbia is the largest country in the region and its governance issues are a burden on finding efficient ways out of the current deadlocks.

  • What does Jeremić think about the European Union's stance on the Balkans enlargement?

    -Jeremić expresses concern that the dream of Balkan countries joining the European Union has not been fulfilled, largely due to geopolitical developments and mistakes made by major actors in the Balkans. He points out that there is currently little appetite for enlargement in Europe and that the process requires consensus, which is difficult to achieve.

  • How does Jeremić perceive the situation of Serbs in Kosovo?

    -Jeremić describes the Serb community in Kosovo as the most endangered ethnic group in Europe, living under exceptionally difficult circumstances and being constantly attacked and abused. He refers to official numbers indicating a quadrupling of incidents and hate crimes against Serbs in the last 12 months.

  • What is Jeremić's stance on the recent proposal from the European Union regarding Kosovo?

    -Jeremić finds the recent EU proposal completely unacceptable for Serbia as it would lead to the accession of Pristina to the United Nations, which he believes would open the door to further instability and the creation of a 'Greater Albania,' leading to less stability in the region.

  • How does Jeremić view the influence of Russia in the Balkans?

    -Jeremić acknowledges the long-standing presence of Russian influence in the Balkans for the past 400 to 500 years, similar to that of Turkey and Europe. He believes it is an illusion to think that any one of these influences can be squeezed out by the others and that they are likely to continue coexisting in the region.

  • What is Jeremić's opinion on the unilateral declaration of independence of Kosovo in 2008?

    -Jeremić considers the unilateral declaration of independence of Kosovo in 2008 as a significant mistake with catastrophic negative consequences for long-term peace and stability in the Balkans and beyond. He believes it set a dangerous precedent that has been used in other geopolitical conflicts.

  • What does Jeremić believe is the role of the Orthodox Church in Serbian national identity?

    -Jeremić sees the Serbian Orthodox Christianity as one of the three pillars of Serbian national identity, closely related to the nation's language and alphabet and the Kosovo myth. He suggests that the Orthodox Church plays a vital role in preserving and expressing Serbian national identity.

  • How does Jeremić view the potential for conflict in the Balkans regarding border changes?

    -Jeremić warns against the potential for conflict if border changes are considered in the Balkans, particularly in relation to Republica Srpska and the precedent set by Kosovo's declaration of independence. He advocates for the preservation of current borders and responsible politics to avoid instability and conflict.

  • What is Jeremić's perspective on the future of the Balkans within Europe?

    -Jeremić expresses hope for a future where the Balkan countries, including Serbia, can function like modern European states, even if full membership in the European Union is not immediately possible. He emphasizes the importance of good governance, democracy, and rule of law as crucial for the region's prosperity.

Outlines
00:00
📜 Introduction to Book Yeremich

The speaker introduces Book Yeremich, a prominent figure known for his roles as Serbia's Foreign Minister, the first Serbian President of the UN General Assembly, and a candidate for the UN Secretary-General. Yeremich is also recognized as an intellectual and the founder of the People's Party, a center-right political party in Serbia. The introduction sets the stage for Yeremich's lecture on the geopolitics of the Balkans, emphasizing his unique perspective and experience in international relations and his potential insights into the region's complex history and current affairs.

05:01
🌏 Geopolitical Fundamentals of the Balkans

The paragraph delves into the fundamental forces that shape geopolitics, specifically focusing on the Balkans. It discusses the importance of geography, history, culture, and religion in understanding the region's complexity. The speaker highlights the Balkans' strategic significance throughout history, as a crossroads for trade, military, and cultural exchanges between Europe and the Middle East. The paragraph also touches on the historical conflicts and power struggles that have defined the region, setting the stage for a deeper analysis of its geopolitical landscape.

10:02
🔥 Historical Conflicts and the Breakup of Yugoslavia

This section provides an overview of the historical conflicts in the Balkans, particularly focusing on the breakup of Yugoslavia in the 1990s. It discusses the impact of global affairs on the region and the illusion of the 'end of history' following the Cold War. The speaker reflects on the consequences of the unilateral declaration of independence by Kosovo in 2008, which they view as a significant mistake with long-term negative effects on peace and stability in the region. The paragraph also addresses the geopolitical implications of the European Union's expansion and the challenges it faces, including the changing outlook towards enlargement.

15:04
🗳️ The State of Democracy and Governance in Serbia

The speaker addresses the current state of democracy and governance in Serbia, expressing concern over the country's institutional, democratic, and human rights situation. They criticize the current administration's handling of the economy and corruption issues, and suggest that Serbia's governance is a significant burden on finding efficient solutions to the country's challenges. The paragraph also touches on the influence of Serbia's governance on the broader Western Balkans region and the international community's response to it.

20:06
🏛️ The Plight of the Serbian Orthodox Church in Kosovo

This paragraph discusses the difficult situation faced by the Serbian Orthodox Church in Kosovo, including the challenges related to property rights, security, and the preservation of holy sites. The speaker highlights the increase in hate crimes and incidents against the Serbian community in Kosovo, as well as the failure to implement decisions by Kosovo's Supreme Court regarding land returns to the Church. The paragraph underscores the precarious position of the Serbian Orthodox Church and the broader Serbian community in the region.

25:06
🤝 The Unacceptable Nature of the EU's Proposed Kosovo Plan

The speaker vehemently opposes the European Union's proposed plan for Kosovo, arguing that it is unacceptable for Serbia as it would lead to Pristina's accession to the United Nations. They express concern that this could trigger a new season of tragedy in the Balkans, potentially leading to the creation of a 'Greater Albania,' which they believe would destabilize the region further. The speaker emphasizes that recognizing Kosovo's independence would be a grave mistake, validating past injustices against the Serbian people.

30:08
🏛️ The Role of National Identity and the Orthodox Church

The paragraph explores the connection between national identity, the Orthodox Church, and the political landscape in Serbia and the Balkans. It discusses the historical and cultural significance of the Kosovo myth and its impact on Serbian national identity. The speaker also addresses the issue of Republic Srpska and the potential implications of its possible integration with Serbia, cautioning against any changes to existing borders that could lead to instability and conflict.

35:10
🕊️ The Pursuit of Peace and Stability in the Balkans

In this section, the speaker emphasizes the importance of peaceful coexistence and mutual understanding in the Balkans, particularly in relation to the complex situation in Kosovo. They advocate for finding ways to live together without crossing each other's red lines and for focusing on economic cooperation and people-to-people relationships that transcend political differences. The speaker also discusses the precedent set by Kosovo's declaration of independence and its potential implications for the region's future.

40:11
🏦 The Economic Challenges and the Need for a European Strategy

The speaker highlights the economic challenges faced by the Western Balkans, particularly the lack of a clear European strategy for the region. They argue that the focus should be on practical economic development, including infrastructure, decarbonization, energy systems, and transportation. The paragraph suggests that such an approach would not only create jobs and improve governance but also attract foreign investment and foster a more prosperous and stable region.

45:14
🗳️ Reflections on the State of Democracy and Elections in Serbia

This paragraph reflects on the state of democracy in Serbia, with a focus on the country's electoral processes and the influence of its leadership. The speaker contrasts the situation in Serbia with that in Slovakia, noting the lack of free and fair elections and the absence of balanced media representation in Serbia. They express hope for the future, suggesting that Serbia may eventually converge with countries like Slovakia that have successfully navigated difficult times.

50:16
🌐 The Geopolitical Recession and the Future of International Relations

The speaker discusses the concept of a geopolitical recession, drawing parallels with economic cycles and emphasizing the long-lasting nature of such periods in geopolitics. They express concern over the current state of international relations, suggesting that the world may be moving towards a new Cold War. The paragraph calls for a focus on areas of common interest, such as climate change, to build trust and cooperation among nations, while acknowledging the challenges of achieving consensus on issues related to national security.

55:19
🤹‍♂️ The Balancing Act of Small Nations in Great Power Politics

In the final paragraph, the speaker reflects on the historical role of small nations like Serbia in the context of great power politics. They describe the need for countries in the Balkans to navigate their relationships with major powers as a means of survival, emphasizing the importance of respecting geography, history, and each other. The speaker acknowledges the complexity of this balancing act and the challenges it presents for the future of the region.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Balkans
The Balkans is a region in southeastern Europe that has a complex history of cultural, ethnic, and religious diversity. In the video, the term is central to the discussion as the speaker explores the geopolitical dynamics and historical conflicts that have shaped the region. The Balkans are often portrayed as a place on the verge of war, with its current state being the result of millennia of conflict between Europe and the Middle East.
💡Geopolitics
Geopolitics refers to the study of international relations and how geography impacts global politics. The speaker discusses the geopolitics of the Balkans, emphasizing the fundamental forces of geography, history, and culture that influence the region's political landscape. The term is used to analyze the historical and current strategic interests of various powers in the Balkans.
💡Yugoslavia
Yugoslavia was a country in the Balkans that existed from 1918 to 1992, and its breakup in the 1990s is a significant historical event discussed in the video. The speaker mentions the breakup in the context of global affairs and the illusion of the end of history post-Cold War, highlighting the subsequent conflicts and geopolitical shifts that occurred as a result.
💡European Union (EU)
The European Union is a political and economic union of 27 member states in Europe. The video discusses the EU's role in the Balkans, particularly in relation to the enlargement process and the potential membership of Balkan countries. The speaker expresses skepticism about the future of EU enlargement, given the current geopolitical climate and the EU's internal challenges.
💡Kosovo
Kosovo is a disputed territory in the Balkans, and its declaration of independence from Serbia in 2008 is a key point of contention in the video. The speaker discusses Kosovo's status and the implications of its independence for Serbia and the broader region, arguing that it has had negative consequences for peace and stability.
💡National Identity
National identity is a person's sense of belonging to a nation, which is often tied to shared culture, language, and history. The video explores the concept of national identity in the context of Serbia and the Balkans, particularly in relation to the Kosovo myth and the role of the Serbian Orthodox Church in shaping and preserving Serbian identity.
💡Sanctions
Sanctions are measures imposed on a country, entity, or individual to coerce a change in behavior. In the video, the speaker discusses Serbia's stance on not joining the sanctions against Russia, citing political and economic reasons, as well as the historical experience of Serbia with sanctions and their impact on ordinary people.
💡Populism
Populism is a political approach that seeks to appeal to ordinary people who feel that their concerns are disregarded by established elite groups. The video touches on the thin line between responsible politics and populism in the context of national identity and the political elite's exploitation of high emotions for political gain.
💡Orthodox Christianity
Orthodox Christianity is a branch of Christianity that is a significant part of the national identity for many Balkan countries, including Serbia. The video discusses the role of the Serbian Orthodox Church in maintaining national identity and the unique canonical structure of Orthodox churches within nation-states.
💡Republic of Serbia
The Republic of Serbia is a country in the Balkans and the largest of the former Yugoslav republics. The video discusses Serbia's current political and economic situation, its relationship with the EU, and its stance on issues such as Kosovo's independence and international sanctions.
💡International Law
International law refers to the body of rules, norms, and standards governing the conduct of states and international organizations. The video discusses the concept of declarations of independence in international law, referencing the advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice on Kosovo's declaration of independence.
Highlights

Introduction of Vuk Jeremić, former Foreign Minister of Serbia, highlighting his extensive experience in international relations and his role in the United Nations.

Jeremić's perspective on the Balkans' complex geopolitical history and its influence from Europe and the Middle East, predating Christianity and Islam.

The role of geography, history, and culture as fundamental forces in understanding the Balkans' geopolitical landscape.

Analysis of the impact of the 1990s Yugoslav Wars and the illusion of the 'end of history' after the Cold War.

Jeremić's view on the 2008 global financial crisis as a turning point challenging the notion of globalization's benefits.

The unilateral declaration of Kosovo's independence in 2008 and its perceived negative consequences for regional stability.

Discussion on the European Union's enlargement process and its stagnation, particularly concerning the Western Balkans.

Jeremić's critique of the EU's requirement for consensus in decision-making and the challenges it poses for further enlargement.

Reflections on the state of Serbia's governance, democratic challenges, and economic outlook under the current administration.

Concerns about Serbia's influence on the Western Balkans and the implications of its governance model for regional cooperation.

Jeremić's stance on the Russian Federation's role in the Balkans and the importance of maintaining good relations for Serbia's national interests.

The significance of the Serbian Orthodox Church and its challenges in Kosovo, including the issue of religious sites and property rights.

Critique of the proposed European Union plan for the normalization of relations between Serbia and Kosovo, deemed unacceptable by Jeremić.

Jeremić's call for truth and honesty in domestic politics and the dangers of political disillusionment among the youth in the Balkans.

The importance of addressing demographic decline and its strategic implications for the future of the Balkans.

Jeremić's closing remarks on the need for responsible politics in the Balkans and the avoidance of populism for long-term stability.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: