Gravitas Plus: Why are women being denied the Right to abortion?

WION
30 May 202109:18
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis script delves into the complexities and controversies surrounding abortion, highlighting the impact of restrictive laws on women's rights and health. It challenges common misconceptions, such as the association of abortion with depression and reduced fertility, and emphasizes the importance of choice. The discussion also touches on the influence of religious beliefs, particularly the Catholic Church's stance, and contrasts this with progressive movements in countries like Argentina and India, advocating for women's autonomy over their bodies.

Takeaways
  • 🗣️ The script discusses the controversial nature of the word 'abortion' and its difficulty to discuss openly in society.
  • 🏛️ It highlights the influence of institutions like the Catholic Church on the perception of abortion, labeling it as taboo and morally evil.
  • 🌎 The script points out the recent regressive laws in the United States, particularly in Texas and Mississippi, that restrict abortion rights.
  • 🚫 It emphasizes the global impact, with 26 countries completely banning abortion and 39 allowing it only when a woman's life is at risk.
  • 🤰 The script explains that women may choose abortion due to unforeseen economic, social conditions, or health complications during pregnancy.
  • 🛑 It refutes myths about abortion causing depression and reducing fertility, citing studies that show otherwise.
  • 🛡️ The script argues against the anti-abortion stance, stating that it is not truly pro-life but rather anti-choice and anti-women.
  • 💉 It clarifies that pain is not felt by a fetus during an abortion until around 26 weeks, which is beyond the upper legal limit.
  • ⚰️ The script presents data showing that unsafe abortions lead to numerous maternal deaths, highlighting the danger of outlawing abortion.
  • 🌐 It points out the shift in some conservative societies towards favoring abortion rights, using Argentina and India as examples.
  • 📖 The script concludes by emphasizing the victimization of women in the abortion debate, using the tragic case of Savita Halappanavar in Ireland to illustrate the consequences of restrictive abortion laws.
Q & A

  • Why is the word 'abortion' considered difficult to speak about in public?

    -The word 'abortion' is difficult to speak about in public due to its controversial nature and the complex social, religious, and ethical implications it carries.

  • What are the two other eight-letter words mentioned in the script that are also considered taboo?

    -The two other eight-letter words mentioned are 'religion' and 'marriage', both of which are complex institutions and can be controversial topics.

  • According to the script, what is the current situation regarding abortion laws in the United States?

    -The script mentions that the state of Texas has passed a regressive law banning abortion after six weeks of pregnancy, and Mississippi is asking the court to re-examine the 22-week limit, which could potentially lead to a reversal of legal rights to an abortion.

  • What is the definition of abortion provided in the script?

    -Abortion is defined as a procedure to end a pregnancy, which can be done using medicine or surgery to remove the embryo or the fetus and placenta from the uterus.

  • Why do some women choose to undergo an abortion?

    -Women may choose to undergo an abortion due to various reasons such as unwanted pregnancies, failed birth control, rape, economic or social conditions, health complications, or personal unpreparedness for pregnancy.

  • How many countries completely ban abortion, and what percentage of women does this affect?

    -There are 26 countries that completely ban abortion, affecting 90 million women, which is 5 percent of women of reproductive age globally.

  • What is the stance of the Catholic Church on abortion, and how has it evolved over time?

    -The Catholic Church views abortion as murder and has held this stance since the first century. However, the script points out that scientific understanding has evolved since the early writings of the church, suggesting a need for reevaluation.

  • Does the script suggest that a fetus can feel pain during an abortion?

    -No, the script states that pain or sensation of any kind is not felt by the fetus until around 26 weeks of pregnancy, and the upper limit for abortion is 24 weeks.

  • What are some of the myths about abortion that the script aims to debunk?

    -The script aims to debunk myths such as abortion causing depression, reducing fertility, and the idea that anti-abortion activists are truly 'pro-life', arguing instead that they are anti-choice.

  • What are the consequences of outlawing abortion according to the script?

    -The script suggests that outlawing abortion does not stop it but instead leads to unsafe abortions, which can result in the death of women, highlighting the importance of safe and legal access to abortion.

  • Can you provide an example of a country that has recently changed its stance on abortion?

    -Argentina is mentioned as the first major Latin American country to legalize abortion, indicating a shift even in traditionally conservative regions.

Outlines
00:00
📢 The Complexity and Controversy of Abortion

This paragraph delves into the contentious nature of the term 'abortion,' highlighting its simplicity yet difficulty in public discourse. It juxtaposes abortion with other complex societal institutions like religion and marriage, noting their intertwined taboo status. The script points out the influence of the Catholic Church and the impact of restrictive laws on women's rights, particularly in the United States with the Texas law banning abortion after six weeks. It emphasizes the need to dispel myths about abortion, such as its association with murder and anti-life sentiments, and to discuss the reality of unwanted pregnancies, failed birth control, and the hardships women face in making such decisions. The paragraph concludes by defining abortion medically and emphasizing the need for a broader conversation on the topic.

05:00
🌏 Global Perspectives on Abortion and Women's Rights

The second paragraph examines the global landscape regarding abortion laws and their implications for women's rights. It discusses the stark reality of countries with total bans on abortion, even in cases of rape, and the restrictive laws in 39 countries that only allow abortion when a woman's life is at risk. The paragraph refutes common myths about abortion, such as its impact on fetal pain, women's mental health, and fertility, citing medical research and studies that debunk these misconceptions. It also addresses the anti-choice movement's misleading claims and labels them as anti-women and anti-equality. The paragraph presents data on unsafe abortions and their deadly consequences, emphasizing the urgent need for safe and legal abortion access. It concludes with examples of progressive shifts in abortion laws, such as in Argentina and India, and a poignant story from Ireland that led to a change in the country's abortion policy.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Abortion
Abortion refers to the termination of a pregnancy before the fetus can survive outside the womb. In the video, it is a central theme, highlighting the complexity and controversy surrounding the procedure. The script discusses the various social, legal, and ethical aspects of abortion, including restrictive laws in different countries and the impact on women's rights.
💡Controversial
Controversial indicates a subject that is susceptible to debate and disagreement, often due to differing moral, ethical, or political views. The video script uses this term to emphasize the divisive nature of the abortion debate, where opinions can vary widely and discussions can become heated.
💡Catholic Church
The Catholic Church is a significant religious institution with a specific stance on moral issues, including abortion. The script mentions the Church's opposition to abortion, citing its belief that it is morally wrong and equates to murder, thus illustrating the religious influence on societal views and laws regarding abortion.
💡Regressive Laws
Regressive laws are those that are considered to take society backward in terms of rights or social progress. The video script refers to recent legislation in the United States, particularly in Texas and Mississippi, that imposes stricter limitations on abortion, suggesting a move away from progressive policies that support women's rights.
💡Unwanted Pregnancies
Unwanted pregnancies are those that occur unintentionally and are not desired by the individual. The script acknowledges the reality of such pregnancies, which can result from failed birth control or other circumstances, and how they contribute to the necessity of abortion as an option for women.
💡Economic or Social Conditions
Economic or social conditions refer to the financial and societal factors that can influence a person's life and decisions. The video discusses how these conditions, such as job loss or the death of a partner, can lead women to choose abortion due to being unprepared to raise a child under such circumstances.
💡Health Complications
Health complications are medical issues that arise during pregnancy, which can pose risks to the mother or the fetus. The script points out that sometimes, a woman's health may not permit her to continue with the pregnancy, indicating a medical rationale for abortion.
💡Unsafe Abortion
Unsafe abortion refers to a procedure that is performed without the necessary medical standards and can pose serious risks to the woman's health. The video script provides data on the prevalence of unsafe abortions and their consequences, emphasizing the dangers that arise when legal access to abortion is restricted.
💡Anti-Choice
Anti-choice is a term used to describe individuals or groups that oppose a woman's right to choose whether to have an abortion. The script critiques those who are labeled 'pro-life' but are, in fact, against women's autonomy and equality, suggesting that their stance is not genuinely about protecting life but about controlling women's decisions.
💡Fetal Pain
Fetal pain is a concept that has been used in the abortion debate to argue against the procedure. The script refutes this by citing medical evidence that suggests a fetus cannot perceive pain before 24 weeks of gestation, which is beyond the typical legal limit for abortion, thus debunking a common anti-abortion argument.
💡Turn Away Study
The Turn Away Study is a research project mentioned in the script that investigated the effects of receiving or being denied an abortion. The study found that women who were denied abortions were more likely to face serious complications and negative mental health outcomes, providing empirical evidence against the idea that abortion causes depression.
💡Savita Halappanavar
Savita Halappanavar was an Indian dentist whose death in Ireland due to being denied an abortion during a miscarriage brought international attention to restrictive abortion laws. The script uses her tragic story to illustrate the real-life consequences of denying women the right to make decisions about their own bodies.
Highlights

The word 'abortion' is simple yet difficult to discuss publicly or at home.

Other eight-letter controversial words include 'religion' and 'marriage'.

Abortion is often branded as taboo, especially by the Catholic Church and in many 21st-century marriages.

Texas has passed a regressive law banning abortion after six weeks, when most women don't even know they're pregnant.

Mississippi is challenging the 22-week abortion ban in the Supreme Court, raising fears of losing legal abortion rights.

Abortion is defined as a procedure to end a pregnancy, done through medicine or surgery.

Unwanted pregnancies, failed birth control, and rape are realities that may lead to the choice of abortion.

There are 26 countries that completely ban abortion, affecting 90 million women.

39 countries allow abortion only when a woman's life is at risk, and 56 only on the basis of health.

Latin American countries with strong Catholic influence tend to outlaw abortion.

The Catholic Church views abortion as murder, a belief that has remained unchangeable.

Scientific understanding of human embryology has evolved since early Christian texts were written.

The difference between killing life and killing a person is central to the anti-abortion argument.

Fetuses do not feel pain until around 26 weeks, and abortion is typically not performed after 24 weeks.

There is no medical evidence supporting the claim that abortion causes depression.

Abortion does not reduce fertility, contrary to what some anti-abortion activists claim.

Outlawing abortion does not stop it; instead, it leads to unsafe abortions and maternal deaths.

Argentina became the first major Latin American country to legalize abortion, and India allows abortion up to 24 weeks.

Societal restrictions often limit the choices of women regarding abortion, even in countries with legal allowances.

The tragic case of Savita Halappanavar in Ireland highlights the deadly consequences of restrictive abortion laws.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Abortion rights around the world - Global News Podcast, BBC World Service

What Happens When We Deny People Abortions? | Diana Greene Foster | TED

How The Supreme Court Killed Roe v. Wade

Women's Suffrage: Crash Course US History #31

Is Abortion Murder? | Middle Ground

The Enlightenment [AP World History Review] Unit 5, Topic 1

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Abortion RightsWomen's RightsHealthcare LawsSocial IssuesCatholic InfluenceFetal PainMental HealthUnsafe AbortionLegal DebatesGlobal PerspectivesReproductive Freedom