Time Travel For Real This Time with Brian Greene & Neil deGrasse Tyson

StarTalk Podcast Full Episodes
22 Dec 202254:12
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this episode of StarTalk Cosmic Queries Edition, Neil deGrasse Tyson and Brian Greene delve into the complexities and theories of time travel, inspired by Charles Dickens' 'A Christmas Carol'. They explore the implications of time's relativity, the effects of gravity on the passage of time, and the concept of a preordained, immutable timeline. The conversation also touches on the possibility of backward time travel through wormholes, the challenges of navigating space-time, and the philosophical and scientific paradoxes that arise when considering time travel. The discussion is both enlightening and thought-provoking, offering insights into the current understanding of time travel within the realms of physics and cosmology.

Takeaways
  • ๐Ÿ•ฐ๏ธ Time travel concepts are influenced by Einstein's theories of relativity, which suggest that time is not universal but can elapse at different rates depending on speed and gravity.
  • ๐Ÿ”ฌ Theoretical physicist Brian Greene discusses the implications of time travel, including the idea that events in time are immutable and cannot be changed, which has implications for free will.
  • ๐ŸŒŒ In the context of time travel, the multiverse theory is introduced as a possible solution to paradoxes, suggesting that travel to the past could affect parallel universes rather than our own.
  • ๐Ÿ“š Charles Dickens' 'A Christmas Carol' is highlighted as an early literary example of time travel, exploring the themes of past, present, and future.
  • ๐ŸŽฅ The discussion references various films like 'Frequency', 'Interstellar', and 'Back to the Future' to illustrate different time travel scenarios and their scientific plausibility.
  • ๐Ÿ‘จโ€๐Ÿš€ The show mentions the real-world experiment with geosynchronous satellites and atomic clocks to test time dilation effects due to relative motion and gravity.
  • ๐Ÿ“ก Time travel narratives often overlook the need for spatial accuracy alongside temporal accuracy, as the universe's expansion means Earth's position in space changes.
  • ๐ŸŒŒ The idea of a pre-existing timeline where all events, including our actions, are immutable is likened to 'Timeless Destiny', suggesting a fixed reality that we perceive as causal.
  • ๐Ÿ”ฎ The script touches on the philosophical and scientific aspects of time travel, including the potential for a time police to regulate its use if it were possible.
  • ๐Ÿš€ The concept of a wormhole as a means for time travel is discussed, with the possibility of using the time difference created by gravity near a black hole to travel to the past or future.
Q & A
  • What is the concept of immutable events in the context of time travel?

    -Immutable events refer to the idea that events in time cannot be changed. If one were to travel back in time, they would simply fulfill the precise set of events that allowed their existence in the first place, suggesting a self-consistent timeline where every event is unchangeable.

  • How did Einstein's theory of relativity change our understanding of time?

    -Einstein's theory of relativity shattered the common view of time as universal. He showed that time elapses at different rates depending on one's velocity and the strength of the gravitational field experienced, demonstrating that time is relative to the observer.

  • What is the significance of geosynchronous satellites in relation to time dilation?

    -Geosynchronous satellites are significant in the context of time dilation because they must adjust their clocks due to the differences in the passage of time caused by their orbital speed and the distance from Earth's gravity. This is a practical application of Einstein's theory of relativity.

  • Can you explain the concept of a chronology protection conjecture by Hawking?

    -Hawking's chronology protection conjecture suggests that the laws of physics prevent time travel to the past, thereby preserving the consistency of history. This could explain why we don't observe visitors from the future, as they theoretically would not be able to travel back in time to our present.

  • What is the role of wormholes in the concept of time travel?

    -Wormholes, hypothetical tunnels connecting different points in spacetime, are considered a potential mechanism for time travel. If one end of a wormhole is near a black hole, where time passes more slowly, it could create a time difference between the two openings, allowing for travel to the past or future.

  • How does the expansion of the universe affect the feasibility of time travel?

    -The expansion of the universe adds a layer of complexity to time travel. If one were to travel back in time, they would also need to account for the spatial movement of celestial bodies due to the expansion. This means that simply returning to a previous time would not guarantee being in the same location in space.

  • What is the paradox that arises when considering the possibility of traveling back in time and preventing one's own birth?

    -The paradox is known as a 'grandfather paradox', where one goes back in time and alters past events in such a way that prevents their own birth. This creates a logical inconsistency, as if one did not exist, they could not have traveled back in time to change the past.

  • How does the concept of a multiverse fit into discussions of time travel?

    -The multiverse concept suggests that there are multiple, parallel universes. In this context, time travel to the past could involve traveling to a different universe's past rather than one's own, thus avoiding paradoxes and allowing for changes to history without affecting one's own timeline.

  • What is the philosophical implication of the immutable timeline theory on the concept of free will?

    -The immutable timeline theory suggests that all events are predetermined and cannot be changed, which can lead to the conclusion that free will is an illusion. Every decision and action is part of a causal chain that is unchangeable, implying that free will is constrained by the events that must occur.

  • How does the theory of relativity affect our understanding of aging and time?

    -According to the theory of relativity, time dilation occurs when an object is in motion or under the influence of a strong gravitational field. This means that the aging process for someone in such conditions would be slower relative to someone not under those influences, as their experience of time is passing at a different rate.

Outlines
00:00
๐Ÿ•ฐ๏ธ Time Travel and the Immutability of Events

The script begins with a discussion on the concept of time travel, suggesting that all events are immutable and unchangeable. It references the idea that if one were to travel back in time, they would only fulfill the set of events that led to their existence in the first place. The conversation is set against the backdrop of Charles Dickens' 'A Christmas Carol', a classic novel that explores themes of time through the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future. The guest, theoretical physicist Brian Greene, is introduced as an expert on the subject, with his work on time, space, and the universe being highlighted.

05:03
๐Ÿ”ฌ The Impact of Einstein's Relativity on Time Perception

This paragraph delves into the scientific aspects of time travel, particularly focusing on Einstein's theories of relativity. It explains how Einstein's Special Relativity showed that time elapses at different rates depending on one's speed, and his General Relativity revealed that gravity also affects the passage of time. The discussion includes examples such as geosynchronous satellites and the famous 'twin paradox' to illustrate these concepts. The conversation also touches on the practical implications of these theories, such as the need to adjust clocks on satellites to account for these relativistic effects.

10:04
๐Ÿš€ Theoretical Time Travel and its Paradoxes

The script continues with an exploration of what modern physics, specifically Einstein's theories, can contribute to our understanding of time travel. It discusses the possibility of time travel to the future and the constraints on traveling to the past. The concept of a 'self-consistent' timeline is introduced, suggesting that any attempt to change the past would only reaffirm the events that led to the present. The conversation also touches on the philosophical implications of time travel, including the idea that it might negate free will.

15:05
๐ŸŽญ The Role of Time Travel in Storytelling and the Multiverse Theory

This section of the script discusses the role of time travel in literature and film, using the example of a character who attempts to prevent a tragic event but finds that the event is inherent in the timeline. It suggests that one's actions in the past are part of the causal chain of events that have already occurred. The script also introduces the idea of a multiverse, where time travel could involve moving between parallel universes, thus avoiding the paradoxes associated with changing one's own timeline.

20:06
๐ŸŒŒ The Nature of Time and the Concept of Photons

The conversation turns to the nature of time and the behavior of photons, which travel at the speed of light. It explores the idea that, from the perspective of a photon, time would appear to stop, although the panelists caution against ascribing human-like experiences to photons. The discussion also addresses the philosophical implications of time travel, including the potential loss of free will and the eternal, unchanging nature of past events.

25:08
๐ŸŽฌ Hollywood's Depiction of Time Travel and its Regulation

The script engages with the topic of time travel in Hollywood films, asking which film best depicts the concept and discussing the potential need for regulation if time travel were possible. The panelists consider the implications of time travel for changing past events and the potential paradoxes that could arise. They also touch on the idea that time travelers might be constrained in their actions, preventing them from altering the past in significant ways.

30:08
๐Ÿงฌ The Effects of Time Dilation on Cellular Aging

This paragraph explores the effects of time dilation on cellular aging, suggesting that all physical processes, including cellular aging, occur at a rate dictated by the flow of time. The conversation explains that time dilation, as predicted by Einstein's theories, would affect all processes equally, meaning that even one's thoughts would slow down in a strong gravitational field. The panelists emphasize that these effects are not due to the direct influence of gravity on one's physiology but are instead a result of the fabric of space-time itself.

35:09
๐Ÿ•ณ๏ธ Wormholes and the Practicalities of Time Travel

The script delves into the concept of wormholes as a potential mechanism for time travel. It describes wormholes as tunnels that can connect different points in space-time, with the possibility of using them to travel both forward and backward in time. The conversation also addresses the practical considerations of using wormholes for time travel, such as the need to ensure that one exits the wormhole at a specific location in space as well as time.

40:11
๐ŸŽญ Time Travel Paradoxes and the Multiverse Theory

The discussion continues with an exploration of time travel paradoxes and how they might be circumvented through the multiverse theory. The panelists consider the idea that time travelers might not be able to change their own past but could instead create changes in parallel universes. This approach avoids the paradoxes associated with altering one's own timeline and suggests that each universe represents a different set of outcomes.

45:12
๐Ÿ” Detecting Tachyons and the Possibility of Time Travel Before the Big Bang

This section of the script addresses the hypothetical detection of tachyons, particles that could potentially travel faster than light, and the implications of time travel for understanding the universe's origins. The conversation touches on the possibility of time travel to a point before the Big Bang, suggesting that there may be no 'before' in the context of the universe's beginning. The panelists also discuss the potential for multiple universes and the idea that our Big Bang may not have been the first in a series of cosmic events.

50:14
๐ŸŒŸ Charles Dickens' Time Travel and the Parallel Universes Concept

The script concludes with a reflection on Charles Dickens' use of time travel in 'A Christmas Carol', drawing parallels with the concept of wormholes and parallel universes. It suggests that Dickens' story may have invoked a form of time travel where characters observe outcomes in alternate realities rather than directly interacting with their own past. The discussion highlights how such a narrative approach allows for the exploration of different outcomes without altering the established timeline.

Mindmap
Keywords
๐Ÿ’กTime Travel
Time travel is a central theme in the video, referring to the concept of moving between different points in time, either to the past or the future, through hypothetical means such as wormholes or advanced technology. The script discusses various aspects of time travel inspired by Charles Dickens' 'A Christmas Carol', including the implications of time travel on the timeline and causality, as well as its portrayal in science fiction and its theoretical underpinnings in physics.
๐Ÿ’กImmutable Events
Immutable events, as mentioned in the script, refer to the idea that past events are unchangeable and cannot be altered, even if one were to travel back in time. This concept is crucial in discussions about the nature of time and causality, suggesting that any attempt to change the past would simply reaffirm the existing timeline and one's own existence within it.
๐Ÿ’กEinstein's Relativity
Einstein's theories of relativity, both special and general, are foundational to modern understandings of time and space. The script touches on how special relativity shows that time elapses at different rates depending on one's velocity, while general relativity reveals that gravity also affects the passage of time. These theories are key in discussions of time travel and the behavior of objects in strong gravitational fields or at high speeds.
๐Ÿ’กWormholes
Wormholes are hypothetical structures in spacetime that could potentially provide shortcuts for long-distance space travel or time travel. The script discusses the concept of wormholes as a means for time travel, where one end of the wormhole could be near a black hole to create a time difference between the two openings, allowing for travel to the past or future.
๐Ÿ’กGeosynchronous Orbit
Geosynchronous orbit is a specific type of Earth orbit where a satellite orbits at the same rate that the Earth rotates, thus remaining over the same point on the planet's surface. The script mentions geosynchronous satellites as an example of how time dilation due to relative motion and gravity can affect the passage of time, requiring corrections to the clocks on these satellites.
๐Ÿ’กMultiverse
The concept of a multiverse suggests that our universe may be one of many that exist in a larger cosmic framework. The script briefly touches on the idea that time travel to the past could potentially involve traveling to a parallel universe rather than altering one's own timeline, thus avoiding paradoxes and allowing for changes to history in a different reality.
๐Ÿ’กChronology Protection Conjecture
The chronology protection conjecture, attributed to Stephen Hawking, posits that the laws of physics prevent time travel to the past, thus preserving the consistency of history. The script discusses this idea in the context of avoiding paradoxes and the absence of time travelers from the future, suggesting that time travel may not be possible to times before the creation of a time machine.
๐Ÿ’กTachyons
Tachyons are hypothetical particles that travel faster than light and are often used in science fiction to facilitate time travel or superluminal communication. The script uses the concept of tachyons to illustrate a thought experiment where information could be sent back in time to prevent an event, thus raising questions about causality and the nature of time.
๐Ÿ’กEntropy
Entropy, in the context of the script, relates to the concept of information and the second law of thermodynamics, which states that the total entropy of an isolated system can only increase over time. The script implies a connection between entropy and the idea of time travel, suggesting that the flow of information and the direction of time are intertwined.
๐Ÿ’กInterstellar
The film 'Interstellar' is mentioned in the script as an example of a movie that accurately portrays certain aspects of time travel and relativity. The script discusses how the film depicts time dilation near a black hole, where time slows down for individuals close to the black hole compared to those further away, illustrating the effects of gravity on the passage of time.
๐Ÿ’กBig Bang
The Big Bang is the prevailing cosmological model for the beginning of the observable universe. The script touches on the concept of the Big Bang in the context of time travel, questioning whether it is possible to travel back to a time before the Big Bang occurred. This raises philosophical and scientific questions about the nature of time and the limits of our universe.
Highlights

Discussion on the immutability of events and the concept that events cannot change, even when time travel is considered.

Neil deGrasse Tyson's humorous introduction of Brian Greene, a theoretical physicist and author, as a returning champion to the show.

Brian Greene's explanation of how Einstein's theory of relativity revolutionized the understanding of time, making it relative rather than universal.

The real-world application of time dilation, demonstrated by the need to adjust clocks on geosynchronous satellites due to differing rates of time passage.

Exploration of the philosophical and scientific implications of time travel, including the potential paradoxes and logical conundrums.

Insight into the concept of time travel from the perspective of photons, which travel at the speed of light and for which time appears to stop.

The idea that time travel might not be possible due to chronology protection, a concept that prevents changes to the past to preserve history.

Brian Greene's involvement in the film 'Frequency', where he advised on the scientific accuracy of time travel elements.

The portrayal of time dilation in the film 'Interstellar', which accurately depicts the aging effect due to proximity to a black hole.

Discussion on the potential for time travel to require not just moving through time but also through space, considering the universe's expansion.

The hypothetical nature of tachyon particles, which if they exist, could travel faster than light and potentially be related to time travel.

The question of whether time travel could allow for travel before the Big Bang, and the philosophical implications of the concept of 'before' time.

The concept of a multiverse as a solution to time travel paradoxes, where changes to the past occur in parallel universes rather than our own.

Charles Dickens' portrayal of time travel in 'A Christmas Carol', which may have influenced modern perceptions of time travel.

The importance of scientific literacy in popular culture, as exemplified by the accurate depiction of scientific concepts in films like 'Interstellar'.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: