Research Ethics | Ethics in Research

SciToons

4 Oct 202207:13

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe script explores the critical role of ethics in research, distinguishing between laws and moral principles that guide right and wrong. It emphasizes the importance of honesty, transparency, and respect for confidentiality and intellectual property in maintaining ethical standards. The Belmont Report's principles of respect for persons, beneficence, and justice are highlighted as foundational for ethical research involving human subjects. The script also discusses the consequences of unethical research, historical examples of such misconduct, and measures taken to prevent it, like the Nuremberg Code and the Belmont Report. It concludes by posing modern ethical questions raised by gene editing and the importance of ethical training for researchers.

Takeaways

💼 Ethical dilemmas are complex and can be more challenging than simple decisions like returning a lost wallet.
🔍 Good research is not just empirical, reproducible, and valid, but also ethical, guided by moral principles.
📚 Ethics are moral principles that distinguish 'right' from 'wrong', different from laws which are codified rules.
🤔 Ethics guide our daily actions, such as returning lost items or taking responsibility, and are crucial in academia to prevent behaviors like plagiarism and cheating.
🌐 Ethical standards can vary by region, discipline, or institution, but common themes like honesty, transparency, and respect for confidentiality are universally important.
📝 The entire research process, from study selection to participant treatment and citation, relies heavily on ethics.
🏛 Ethics committees play a vital role in academia and industry, reviewing and monitoring research for ethical compliance.
📋 The Belmont Report's three key principles—respect for persons, beneficence, and justice—are foundational for ethical decisions involving human subjects.
🚫 Unethical research, driven by fame, speed, or academic advancement, can have severe consequences such as public mistrust and harm to individuals.
🛡 Actions like the Nuremberg Code and the National Research Act have been implemented to prevent future unethical research.
🧬 Modern innovations like gene editing raise new ethical questions about privacy, social inequality, and the potential for misuse.

Q & A

What is the primary difference between laws and ethics as discussed in the script?
-Laws are codified rules that people must follow to maintain social order, whereas ethics are moral principles that guide how we determine 'right' and 'wrong' and are the norms of conduct people should follow to promote ideal human character and behavior.
Why is it important to consider ethics in research?
-Ethics in research are crucial because they ensure that the research is not only empirical, reproducible, and valid but also adheres to moral principles, guiding how we determine right from wrong and promoting ideal human character and behavior.
What are some examples of unethical behavior in academia mentioned in the script?
-Examples of unethical behavior in academia include plagiarism, cheating, and the fabrication of information.
How does the script describe the role of ethics committees in research?
-Ethics committees in academia and industry are responsible for reviewing research proposals, monitoring their implementation, and following up on their results. They have the authority to approve, reject, halt, or modify studies if they determine the research to be unethical.
What are the three key principles listed in the Belmont Report that guide the Institutional Review Board's decisions?
-The three key principles listed in the Belmont Report are respect for persons, beneficence, and justice.
How does the Institutional Review Board ensure informed consent for participants in a study?
-The Institutional Review Board ensures informed consent by making sure participants understand what they are asked to do for the study, evaluating the potential risks compared to the potential benefits, and judging that the selection of participants is fair, with special protections for vulnerable populations.
What was the Piltdown Man fraud and why was it significant?
-The Piltdown Man was a famous fraud in archeology, where remains from two known species were filed and stained to look like a new one, accepted as the missing evolutionary link between apes and early humans for decades. This dishonesty discredited accurate findings of early human remains in Asia and Africa, delaying the process of understanding human history.
What ethical issues were involved in the Tuskegee Experiment, and what were its consequences?
-The Tuskegee Experiment involved studying the effects of syphilis in Black men without their informed consent. Even after penicillin became a known cure, researchers did not provide adequate treatment to participants, who eventually died or experienced severe long-term health problems as a result of syphilis.
What was the 'Monster' Study and what were its ethical implications?
-The 'Monster' Study was conducted at the University of Iowa to find a cause or cure for stuttering. 22 orphaned children, unaware that they were participants, were given either positive or negative speech therapy. Some children who received negative speech therapy retained speech problems throughout their lives, highlighting the ethical implications of conducting research without proper consent and consideration for the psychological impact on participants.
What are some reasons why unethical research occurs, as mentioned in the script?
-Unethical research may occur due to a desire for recognition and fame, the need to get a project done quickly, to publish a finding first, or to climb up the academic ladder. Prejudices and biases may also lead to ethical violations.
What are some of the consequences of unethical research mentioned in the script?
-The consequences of unethical research include public mistrust of science, harm to individuals, loss of funding, and even the loss of jobs.
How has the Nuremberg Code influenced the field of research ethics?
-The Nuremberg Code, established after crimes against humanity during World War II, was the first international document to advocate for informed consent and voluntary participation in research involving human subjects, significantly influencing the field of research ethics.
What ethical questions does gene editing raise, as discussed in the script?
-Gene editing raises ethical questions such as the risk of creating a modern-day eugenics movement by 'breeding out' undesired traits, the privacy of genetic data to protect personal information, and the potential for gene editing to worsen social inequalities.
How does the script suggest preparing current and future researchers to work ethically in their discipline?
-The script suggests that ethical training, such as courses and workshops, prepares current and future researchers to work ethically in their discipline, equipping them with the knowledge of ethics to guide their research.

Outlines

00:00

🔍 Ethical Dilemmas and the Importance of Research Ethics

The first paragraph introduces the concept of ethical dilemmas using the example of finding a wallet filled with money, and poses the question of whether to keep it or turn it in. It then delves into the complexities faced by researchers in making ethical decisions. The paragraph discusses the definition of good research, questioning if it should be limited to empirical evidence or also include ethical considerations. It explains the difference between laws and ethics, with the former being mandatory rules and the latter being moral principles guiding behavior. The importance of ethics in daily life and academia is highlighted, with examples of unethical behavior such as plagiarism and cheating. The paragraph also touches on the variability of ethical standards and the reliance of the entire research process on ethics, from study selection to participant treatment and citation practices. It concludes by mentioning the role of ethics committees in reviewing and overseeing research to ensure ethical conduct.

05:03

🛡️ Preventing Unethical Research: Historical Lessons and Modern Challenges

The second paragraph focuses on measures taken to prevent unethical research, referencing historical events like the Nuremberg Code established after World War II, which advocated for informed consent in human research. It also mentions the National Research Act in the United States, prompted by the Tuskegee Experiment, which aimed to regulate biomedical and behavioral research. The paragraph then shifts to discuss current ethical questions surrounding gene editing, raising concerns about potential misuse and social inequality. It emphasizes the ongoing importance of ethical considerations in research and the role of ethical training for researchers. The summary concludes by emphasizing the role of ethics in guiding researchers to make discoveries that align with moral principles.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Ethics

Ethics refers to moral principles that guide our decisions on what is considered 'right' or 'wrong'. In the video's context, ethics are the foundation for determining the appropriateness of research actions and outcomes. Ethics in research is crucial as it influences how studies are designed, conducted, and reported, ensuring that the research is not only scientifically sound but also morally justifiable. The script mentions that ethics are the norms of conduct that should be followed to promote ideal human character and behavior, highlighting their importance in guiding daily actions, such as returning a lost wallet, and in academic settings, where plagiarism and cheating are cited as unethical behaviors.

💡Empirical

Empirical research is based on observable evidence that is gathered through experiments or other means of direct observation. It is a cornerstone of the scientific method, where theories are tested against real-world data. The script suggests questioning whether good research is only empirical, reproducible, and valid, indicating that while empirical evidence is vital, it may not be the sole criterion for defining good research, as ethical considerations also play a significant role.

💡Reproducible

Reproducible research means that the study's methods and findings can be duplicated by other researchers to verify the accuracy and reliability of the results. The script implies that while reproducibility is an important aspect of good research, it is not the only factor. The conversation around what constitutes good research in the script suggests that ethics must also be considered alongside empirical evidence and reproducibility.

💡Valid

Validity in research refers to the accuracy of the study's conclusions and the appropriateness of the methods used to arrive at those conclusions. The script raises the question of whether good research should only be empirical, reproducible, and valid, suggesting that while validity is essential for scientific integrity, ethical considerations are equally important in determining the overall quality of research.

💡Plagiarism

Plagiarism is the act of using someone else's work or ideas without proper attribution and presenting them as one's own. In the script, plagiarism is cited as an example of unethical behavior in academia. It underscores the importance of intellectual honesty and the ethical responsibility researchers have to give credit to the original creators of ideas and work.

💡Cheating

Cheating refers to dishonest actions taken to gain an unfair advantage, such as in academic assessments or research. The script mentions cheating as an unethical behavior, emphasizing the need for integrity and honesty in the pursuit of knowledge and the advancement of research.

💡Fabrication

Fabrication in research involves inventing data or results, which is a severe form of学术不端行为. The script uses the term to illustrate unethical behavior, highlighting the importance of maintaining the integrity and trustworthiness of research findings.

💡Ethical Guidelines

Ethical guidelines are a set of rules or principles that dictate how research should be conducted to ensure it is morally and socially responsible. The script discusses the importance of ethical guidelines in every stage of the research process, from the selection of the research topic to the treatment of participants and citation of contributions. These guidelines help to establish a standard for ethical behavior in research.

💡Codes of Ethics

Codes of ethics are formal documents that outline the ethical standards and principles that an organization or profession adheres to. The script mentions that different organizations have their own codes of ethics, such as the World Economic Forum Young Scientists Community, which lists seven key principles for achieving ethical research. These codes provide a framework for ethical decision-making and behavior within a particular field or organization.

💡Ethics Committees

Ethics committees are groups responsible for reviewing research proposals, monitoring their implementation, and following up on their results to ensure ethical standards are met. The script explains that these committees have the authority to approve, reject, halt, or modify studies if they determine the research to be unethical. They are composed of individuals from diverse backgrounds, including scientists and nonscientists, to offer a range of perspectives on ethical issues.

💡Informed Consent

Informed consent is a principle that participants in research must be fully informed about the study's purpose, procedures, risks, and benefits before they voluntarily agree to participate. The script refers to the Institutional Review Board using the Belmont Report as a foundation for its decisions, which includes the principle of respect for persons, emphasizing the importance of informed consent to ensure participants understand what they are agreeing to.

💡Belmont Report

The Belmont Report is a document created in 1974 that provides ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects in research. The script mentions it as the foundation for decisions made by the Institutional Review Board, highlighting its importance in shaping ethical research practices. The report lists three key principles: respect for persons, beneficence, and justice, which guide the ethical treatment of research participants.

💡Unethical Research

Unethical research refers to studies that violate ethical principles and standards, such as those that involve deception, lack of informed consent, or harm to participants. The script provides examples of unethical research, such as the 'Piltdown Man' fraud and the Tuskegee Experiment, to illustrate the severe consequences that can result from such actions, including public mistrust, harm to individuals, and damage to the scientific community.

💡Gene Editing

Gene editing is a modern innovation that allows for the alteration of an organism's DNA. The script raises ethical questions related to gene editing, such as the potential for creating a modern-day eugenics movement by 'breeding out' undesired traits, the privacy of genetic data, and the possibility of exacerbating social inequalities. These questions reflect ongoing debates about the ethical implications of new scientific advancements.

Highlights

The ethical dilemma of keeping a found wallet versus returning it to the police station is presented as an analogy for more complex research ethics.

Ethics are defined as moral principles that guide the determination of 'right' and 'wrong', distinct from laws which are codified rules.

Ethics in research are not just about empirical evidence but also about acting ethically in the research process.

Ethical behavior in academia includes avoiding plagiarism, cheating, and fabrication of information.

Ethical standards can vary by region, discipline, or institution, leading to different answers to the same ethical problem.

The entire research process from study selection to participant treatment relies heavily on ethics.

Honesty, transparency, confidentiality, and respect for intellectual property are fundamental to ethical research.

Different organizations have their own codes of ethics, such as the seven key principles of the World Economic Forum Young Scientists Community.

Ethics committees in academia and industry are responsible for reviewing, monitoring, and following up on research proposals.

Ethics committees consist of diverse members, including scientists and nonscientists, to offer a range of perspectives on ethics.

The Belmont Report's three key principles—respect for persons, beneficence, and justice—are used to guide ethical decisions involving human subjects.

The Institutional Review Board ensures informed consent, evaluates risks and benefits, and ensures fair participant selection in research.

Unethical research, such as the Piltdown Man fraud, can have long-lasting impacts on scientific understanding and credibility.

The Tuskegee Experiment exemplifies unethical research by studying the effects of syphilis without informed consent and adequate treatment.

The 'Monster' Study at the University of Iowa unethically manipulated orphaned children's speech therapy, causing lasting harm.

Unethical research can be motivated by recognition, speed, publication, or career advancement, and can be influenced by prejudices and biases.

Consequences of unethical research include public mistrust, harm to individuals, loss of funding, and job losses.

Preventative measures like the Nuremberg Code and the National Research Act have been established to avoid future unethical research.

Modern innovations like gene editing raise new ethical questions about potential misuse and social inequality.

Ethical training through courses and workshops prepares researchers to navigate the complex ethical landscape of their work.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

PRACTICAL RESEARCH 1 - Research Ethics - EP.4 (Research Simplified)

Basic Principles in Medical Ethics - CRASH! Medical Review Series

PRACTICAL RESEARCH 1 - The Characteristics, Processes, and Ethics of Research

Ethics | PRACTICE QUESTIONS | INBDE

Henrietta Lacks, the Tuskegee Experiment, and Ethical Data Collection: Crash Course Statistics #12

Moral Dilemmas That Will Break Your Brain

Research Ethics | Ethics in Research

Takeaways

Q & A

What is the primary difference between laws and ethics as discussed in the script?

Why is it important to consider ethics in research?

What are some examples of unethical behavior in academia mentioned in the script?

How does the script describe the role of ethics committees in research?

What are the three key principles listed in the Belmont Report that guide the Institutional Review Board's decisions?

How does the Institutional Review Board ensure informed consent for participants in a study?

What was the Piltdown Man fraud and why was it significant?

What ethical issues were involved in the Tuskegee Experiment, and what were its consequences?

What was the 'Monster' Study and what were its ethical implications?

What are some reasons why unethical research occurs, as mentioned in the script?

What are some of the consequences of unethical research mentioned in the script?

How has the Nuremberg Code influenced the field of research ethics?

What ethical questions does gene editing raise, as discussed in the script?

How does the script suggest preparing current and future researchers to work ethically in their discipline?