Big Think Interview With Howard Gardner | Big Think

Big Think
23 Apr 201229:08
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe speaker discusses the theory of multiple intelligences, emphasizing the diversity of human cognitive abilities and their evolution. He highlights the changing values of intelligences across cultures and time, from linguistic to logical-mathematical, and the growing importance of social and emotional intelligence in the workplace. The speaker also touches on the potential of artistic intelligence in a future where machines may surpass human intelligence. He advocates for educational reform to recognize and nurture these varied intelligences and stresses the ethical dimensions of a society that values more than just academic achievement.

Takeaways
  • 🧠 The theory of multiple intelligences suggests that there are eight distinct types of intelligences, and individuals differ in their profiles of these intelligences.
  • πŸ”— The existence of these intelligences is tied to their value in human evolution, such as naturalist intelligence aiding in survival on the savannas.
  • πŸ›’ Modern society repurposes these evolved intelligences, like using naturalist intelligence for consumer choices rather than survival.
  • πŸ“š Historically, the value of different intelligences has shifted with cultural evolution, impacting what is emphasized in education.
  • πŸ’‘ The speaker emphasizes the growing importance of social and emotional intelligence in the workplace, beyond just linguistic and logical intelligence.
  • 🎨 Artistic intelligence may become more prominent in a future where machines surpass human intelligence in logical tasks.
  • πŸš€ The theory of multiple intelligences was initially developed to reform how psychologists think about intelligence and later expanded into education.
  • πŸŽ“ The speaker advocates for a more holistic approach to education that values different intelligences, not just the traditional academic ones.
  • 🌐 The speaker discusses the ethical dimensions of society and the importance of nurturing intelligences beyond just genetic predispositions.
  • 🏦 The speaker criticizes periods of greed in American history and suggests a need for societal reform towards more ethical and socially responsible values.
  • 🌟 The speaker believes in the potential of the United States to lead with moral authority, provided it can move past its current challenges and embrace progressive ideas.
Q & A
  • What is the theory of multiple intelligences?

    -The theory of multiple intelligences posits that there are eight distinct types of intelligences in humans. It suggests that individuals differ in their profiles of intelligences and that these intelligences are independent of each other.

  • How does the theory of multiple intelligences relate to human evolution?

    -The theory is based on the assumption that these intelligences developed because they were valuable for human survival and evolution. For example, naturalist intelligence helped our ancestors identify what to eat and which animals to avoid.

  • How has the application of intelligences changed with the evolution of cultures?

    -The value and focus on different intelligences have shifted as cultures evolve. For instance, linguistic intelligence was highly valued in higher education 150 years ago, while logical mathematical intelligence has gained more attention in the last century.

  • What is the significance of social and emotional intelligence in the workplace?

    -Social and emotional intelligence is crucial in the workplace because it helps individuals deal with people effectively. Even if someone has a high IQ, lacking social skills could hinder their career progression.

  • How might the value of artistic intelligence change with technological advancements?

    -As machines become smarter and perform more tasks, artistic intelligence may come to the fore. Creativity and the ability to think artistically could become more valuable in a world where machines handle more logical tasks.

  • What was the original intention behind Howard Gardner's development of the multiple intelligences theory?

    -Howard Gardner initially developed the theory to reform the way psychologists and others think about intelligence. He aimed to challenge the traditional view of a single, general intelligence.

  • How has Howard Gardner's perspective on education evolved due to his theory of multiple intelligences?

    -Gardner's perspective on education evolved from simply describing how the mind is organized to advocating for changes in education based on the theory. He believes that recognizing multiple intelligences can lead to more effective teaching and learning.

  • What is Howard Gardner's view on the role of genetics and environment in the development of intelligences?

    -Gardner believes that every intelligence has a genetic component and a certain level of heritability. However, the way intelligences are used is largely determined by cultural factors, parental values, and personal experiences.

  • How does Howard Gardner define 'stupid' in two different connotations?

    -Gardner defines 'stupid' in two ways: one is the technical sense of being slow or less capable in a particular intelligence, and the other is a more important sense related to how one leads their life and navigates challenges.

  • What is Howard Gardner's opinion on the current state of American society and its values?

    -Gardner criticizes the current American society for being dominated by the 'three Ms': money, markets, and me. He advocates for a shift towards the 'three Es': excellence, engagement, and ethics, to promote good work and responsible behavior.

  • What is the 'good work' project that Howard Gardner mentions, and what is its goal?

    -The 'good work' project is an initiative by Howard Gardner and his colleagues aimed at engaging young students in thinking about ethical issues. The goal is to foster a sense of responsibility and encourage the development of good work habits before they enter the workforce.

  • What are Howard Gardner's thoughts on the role of creativity in society?

    -Gardner believes that creativity is neutral and can be used for both positive and negative purposes. He emphasizes the importance of societal DNA for taking chances and doing things responsibly, rather than just focusing on individual creativity.

  • What is Howard Gardner's view on the future of education and the impact of digital media?

    -Gardner is optimistic that digital media will radically change education and the workplace. He believes that new technologies have the potential to revolutionize learning and engagement, but also acknowledges the challenges of ensuring equitable access to these resources.

  • What does Howard Gardner suggest as a solution to the issues with the No Child Left Behind policy?

    -Gardner suggests that the No Child Left Behind policy should not be a one-size-fits-all solution. He believes that different educational contexts require different approaches, focusing on excellence in inner cities, engagement in the heartland, and addressing the unique challenges among the elites.

Outlines
00:00
🧠 Multiple Intelligences and Their Evolutionary Value

The speaker discusses Howard Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences, which posits that there are eight distinct types of intelligences that vary among individuals. These intelligences are considered valuable because they have contributed to human evolution. The speaker uses the example of naturalist intelligence, which helped our ancestors identify edible plants and animals, and avoid predators. This intelligence is now manifested in modern society through consumer choices. The speaker also touches on how the value of different intelligences changes with cultural evolution, and emphasizes the importance of social and emotional intelligence in the workplace. The discussion concludes with a look towards the future, where artistic intelligence may become increasingly important as technology advances.

05:03
πŸŽ“ The Role of Genetics and Environment in Intelligence

This paragraph delves into the genetic component of intelligence, suggesting that every type of intelligence has a heritability factor, meaning it is influenced by genes passed down through generations. The speaker acknowledges that while genetics play a significant role, environmental factors such as culture, parenting, and social interactions also greatly impact how intelligences are developed and utilized. The speaker also addresses the idea of 'stupid' in two contexts: one being a lack of innate ability in a certain intelligence, and the other being an inability to effectively navigate life, which is more related to intrapersonal intelligence.

10:05
🌐 Societal Shifts and the Influence of Progressive Ideas

The speaker reflects on societal changes driven by progressive ideas and charismatic leaders. They mention historical figures like Franklin Roosevelt and contemporary ones like Barack Obama, who have the potential to inspire and motivate people towards a shared vision. The speaker expresses hope for a shift from a society dominated by money, markets, and self-interest to one guided by excellence, engagement, and ethics. They also discuss the importance of education in fostering these values and the need for a collective effort from government, private leaders, and individuals to drive positive change.

15:08
πŸ› The Impact of Creativity and the Changing Nature of Work

The speaker discusses the concept of creativity and how it has evolved from solitary endeavors to a more global and collaborative process. They highlight the importance of taking risks and learning from failures as part of the creative process. The speaker also addresses the potential of digital media to revolutionize education and the workplace, and the need for new analytic tools to understand creativity in a connected world. They mention the 'good play project' which examines how young people interact with technology, and the different levels of engagement, from social networking to serious interest in specific topics.

20:11
πŸ€” Existential Intelligence and the Quest for Meaning

In this paragraph, the speaker ponders the nature of existential intelligence, which involves an interest in big questions and a sense of mission. They reflect on whether political figures like Barack Obama can mobilize this type of intelligence to inspire and motivate people on a larger scale. The speaker also discusses the importance of education in fostering not just intellectual abilities, but also the desire to continue learning and the motivation to contribute positively to society.

25:11
🏫 The Challenges and Aspirations of Modern Education

The speaker addresses the challenges faced by modern education systems, particularly the disparity in educational quality between different socioeconomic groups. They emphasize the importance of educational aspirations and the need for policy that supports a wide range of educational goals, from ensuring basic literacy to fostering excellence. The speaker criticizes the 'No Child Left Behind' policy for not adequately addressing the diverse needs of different educational contexts and calls for a more nuanced approach to education reform.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Multiple Intelligences
The concept of 'Multiple Intelligences' refers to the theory that there are at least eight distinct types of intelligences that exist in human beings, rather than just one general intelligence. Howard Gardner, the theorist behind this concept, suggests that individuals differ in their profiles of intelligences and that these intelligences are independent of each other. In the script, Gardner explains that these intelligences have evolved because they were valuable for human survival and adaptation, such as the naturalist intelligence for identifying edible plants and animals. This theory challenges the traditional view of intelligence and has implications for education and understanding individual differences.
πŸ’‘Naturalist Intelligence
Naturalist intelligence is one of the multiple intelligences identified by Howard Gardner, which pertains to an individual's ability to recognize and classify plants and animals, as well as to understand the natural world. In the script, Gardner uses this concept to illustrate how humans have developed an innate sensitivity to nature, which has been crucial for survival throughout human evolution. He suggests that even in modern society, where people may not need to rely on these skills for survival, the neural networks that evolved for naturalist intelligence are still at play, albeit in different contexts like consumer choices.
πŸ’‘Cultural Evolution
Cultural evolution is the process by which cultural information changes over time, often driven by the development and transmission of ideas, practices, and technologies within a society. In the transcript, Gardner discusses how the value and focus of different intelligences can change as cultures evolve. For example, he mentions that linguistic intelligence was highly valued in higher education 150 years ago, while in the last century, logical-mathematical intelligence has gained more attention. This concept highlights the dynamic nature of human societies and their values.
πŸ’‘Social and Emotional Intelligence
Social and emotional intelligence refers to the ability to recognize, understand, and manage our own emotions and those of others. In the script, Gardner points out that while IQ, which is often associated with linguistic and logical-mathematical intelligence, may get someone a job, it is social and emotional intelligence that can help them succeed and advance in their career. This concept has gained significant attention because of its importance in personal relationships and professional success.
πŸ’‘Singularity
The term 'Singularity' in the context of this script refers to a hypothetical future point in time when technological growth has been so rapid and profound that it results in a rupture in the fabric of human history, with machines surpassing human intelligence. Gardner suggests that in such a scenario, artistic intelligences may become more prominent, as they will be needed to navigate a world where machines are smarter than humans.
πŸ’‘Reformist
A 'Reformist' is someone who advocates for or implements changes, improvements, or reforms in a system or institution. Gardner describes himself as having a reformist inclination, particularly in the realm of education. Initially, he aimed to reform the way psychologists thought about intelligence, but his ideas also resonated within the educational community. Over time, he has become more reformist, focusing on the ethical dimensions of society and advocating for changes in education to better accommodate the multiple intelligences theory.
πŸ’‘Genetic Component
The 'Genetic Component' refers to the hereditary factors that contribute to the characteristics or traits of an individual. Gardner believes that every intelligence has a genetic component, meaning that our innate abilities are influenced by our genetic makeup. He suggests that while genes play a significant role, the environment, culture, and upbringing also have substantial impacts on how intelligences are developed and expressed. This concept is important in understanding the interplay between nature and nurture in human development.
πŸ’‘Intrapersonal Intelligence
Intrapersonal intelligence is the ability to understand oneself, to know one's own goals, motivations, and desires, and to work towards achieving them effectively. In the script, Gardner emphasizes the importance of intrapersonal intelligence, stating that he would prefer someone who is 'stupid' in the traditional sense but has a good sense of how to navigate life over someone with high cognitive abilities but no insight into their own life direction. This concept underscores the value of self-awareness and personal growth.
πŸ’‘Existential Intelligence
Existential intelligence, as mentioned by Gardner, refers to an individual's ability to ponder and engage with deep, philosophical questions about existence, meaning, and purpose. While not a formally recognized type of intelligence in Gardner's theory, it is used here to illustrate the importance of thinking about larger life questions. Gardner suggests that Barack Obama has this type of intelligence, as evidenced by his ability to inspire and motivate people to think about broader issues.
πŸ’‘Good Work
The concept of 'Good Work' in the script refers to work that is excellent, engaging, and ethical. Gardner believes that promoting good work is one of the most important contributions he can make. He emphasizes the need for individuals to be not only skilled in their work (excellence) but also invested in it (engagement) and to conduct it responsibly (ethics). This idea is central to his educational philosophy and his efforts to inspire young people to think about the impact of their work on society.
πŸ’‘Educational Aspirations
Educational aspirations refer to the goals, ambitions, and expectations that individuals or communities have for education. In the script, Gardner discusses the importance of fostering educational aspirations, particularly among young people, to motivate them to continue learning and developing their skills. He acknowledges the challenges in achieving this, especially in underprivileged areas, and the need for policies that support education on a global scale.
Highlights

The theory of multiple intelligences suggests that there are eight distinct types of intelligences that vary among individuals.

There is no necessary link between different types of intelligences, and they evolved due to their value in human evolution.

Naturalist intelligence is used as an example of how our ancestors used it for survival, which is now adapted for modern consumer society.

The value of different intelligences changes with the evolution of cultures and what is prioritized in education and society.

Social and emotional intelligence is crucial in the workplace, not just IQ, for long-term success and human interaction.

When artificial intelligence surpasses human intelligence, artistic intelligence may become more prominent.

The theory of multiple intelligences aimed to reform how psychologists think about intelligence and has had a significant impact on educational theory.

The speaker emphasizes the importance of the arts in human development, contrasting it with the overemphasis on science.

Every intelligence has a genetic component and heritability, but the environment and culture play a significant role in how they are expressed.

The deployment of intelligences is largely influenced by nurture, including cultural and familial values.

Life isn't fair; some people are stronger in multiple intelligences, and the concept of 'stupid' has different connotations.

Intrapersonal intelligence is critical for navigating life successfully, even more so than technical intelligence.

The speaker criticizes Mensa for focusing on high IQ without considering the broader application of intelligence in life.

The speaker discusses the cycles of greed and generosity in American history and the need for progressive ideas.

The importance of education in creating a society that values excellence, engagement, and ethics, not just personal wealth.

The potential of digital media to radically change education and the workplace, including the concept of 'wiki government'.

The speaker's commitment to working with young students to instill ethical considerations and the importance of good work.

The challenge of addressing educational disparities and the need for a more nuanced approach than No Child Left Behind policy.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: