How Hitler Ruined the Reputation of the German Language 🇩🇪 | Feli from Germany

Feli from Germany
19 Jan 202316:14
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script discusses the stereotype of the German language being perceived as harsh, loud, and aggressive, largely due to the historical context of Adolf Hitler's speeches. The creator, Philly, a native German speaker, explains that this perception is not an accurate representation of the language. Hitler's speech style was influenced by the need to convey propaganda effectively and used a technique known as 'Bühnendeutsch' or 'stage German,' which included over-enunciation and a strong rolled 'R' sound. The video also highlights that prior to the 20th century, German was known as the language of poets and thinkers and is still widely used in science. Philly invites viewers to share their views on the German language and its reputation.

Takeaways
  • 🌍 The German language is often internationally perceived as harsh, difficult, and aggressive, largely due to its portrayal in media and historical context.
  • 😂 The stereotype of Germans always sounding angry is a common comedic trope, which some people genuinely believe represents the language.
  • 🎓 Native German speakers, like the video's host, often find the stereotype amusing but also surprising when they speak the language without aggression.
  • 📚 The reputation of the German language has been influenced heavily by historical figures like Adolf Hitler, whose aggressive and dramatic speeches contributed to this perception.
  • 🎙️ Hitler's speech style was actually a learned technique, influenced by the need to be heard clearly in the era of poor sound quality, known as 'Bühnendeutsch' or 'stage German'.
  • 📽️ Footage of Hitler and other Nazi officials has led to the association of the German language with shouting and harshness, even though this is not representative of everyday German speech.
  • 📚 Historically, German was known as the language of poets and thinkers, with a strong tradition in literature and philosophy before the 20th century.
  • 🧐 The German language does have naturally harsher sounds like the uvular R and CH sounds, and words with series of consonants are common.
  • 🌐 German remains the second most used language in science and has a rich cultural and intellectual history that is often overshadowed by its wartime reputation.
  • 🎥 The speech style of Hitler has been perpetuated in movies and comedy, often assigned to any German character, which reinforces the stereotype.
  • 💡 The video encourages viewers to challenge their preconceived notions about the German language and to appreciate its diversity and complexity.
Q & A
  • What is the general international perception of the German language according to the video?

    -The German language is often perceived as difficult, harsh sounding, and aggressive.

  • Why does the speaker believe the German language has a negative reputation?

    -The speaker attributes the negative reputation to the association with Hitler's speeches and the historical context of World War II and the Holocaust.

  • What is the name of the speaking technique Hitler used in his speeches?

    -The speaking technique is called 'Bühnendeutsch' or 'stage German'.

  • How did Hitler's speech style influence the perception of the German language?

    -Hitler's speech style, characterized by shouting and dramatic enunciation, has contributed to the perception of German as an aggressive and harsh language.

  • What is the term for the exaggerated pronunciation of the 'R' sound in Hitler's speeches?

    -The term for the exaggerated pronunciation of the 'R' sound is 'trilldar' or 'rolled R'.

  • How did the speaker describe the typical German language before the 20th century?

    -Before the 20th century, German was known as the language of poets and thinkers, associated with literature and science.

  • What is the name of the language learning platform mentioned in the video?

    -The language learning platform mentioned is Lingoda.

  • What is the Lingoda Sprint challenge?

    -The Lingoda Sprint is a two-month language learning challenge where participants can get up to a hundred percent cash back upon completion.

  • What is the historical significance of the German language in science?

    -German is the second most commonly used language in science, highlighting its historical importance in the field.

  • What is the name of the only known private conversation recording of Hitler?

    -The only known private conversation recording is from Hitler's attendance at the birthday party of Finnish commander-in-chief, Marshal Mannerheim.

  • How does the speaker describe the typical German language in contrast to Hitler's speech style?

    -The speaker describes the typical German language as less aggressive, with no over-enunciating, shouting, or overly rolled 'R' sounds.

  • What was the impact of World War I and II on the German language's reputation?

    -The wars led to a shift in the perception of the German language and culture, overshadowing its previous reputation as the language of literature and science.

Outlines
00:00
🗣️ The Perception of the German Language

The first paragraph introduces the video's topic, which is the stereotype of the German language as being harsh, aggressive, and difficult to understand. The speaker, Philly, acknowledges this perception and shares his experience as a native German speaker living in the United States. He humorously addresses common comedic portrayals of the language and discusses the surprise people express when they hear him speak German without the expected aggression. Philly also mentions his previous video where he demonstrated the softer side of the German language and promotes a language learning challenge by Lingoda, an online language school.

05:02
🎭 Hitler's Influence on German Speech

The second paragraph delves into the historical reasons behind the German language's negative reputation. It points out that many people's only exposure to the German language comes from World War II and Adolf Hitler's speeches, which were characterized by shouting and a specific speaking technique known as 'Bühnendeutsch' or 'stage German.' This style was used to ensure clarity in the era of poor sound quality and was taught to Hitler by opera singer Paul de Vienna. The paragraph explains how Hitler's speech style, with its dramatic and passionate delivery, has influenced the perception of the German language as aggressive.

10:02
🎙️ Hitler's Private vs. Public Speech Style

The third paragraph contrasts Hitler's public speaking style with his private conversations. It mentions that there is only one known recording of Hitler speaking informally, where he sounds like a regular person using standard German. The paragraph also discusses Hitler's efforts to suppress his Austrian dialect and the conscious decision to use a more pronounced speech style for his propaganda speeches. It acknowledges that while Hitler has influenced the global perception of the German language, it is not the sole reason for its reputation. The paragraph concludes by noting that the German language has historically been known as the language of poets and thinkers and has a rich literary and scientific tradition.

15:03
💬 Engaging with the Audience

The final paragraph invites the audience to share their thoughts on the topic. The speaker asks viewers if their perception of the German language was shaped by the same factors discussed in the video or if they believe the video gives too much credit to Hitler's influence. The speaker also encourages viewers to explore related articles and videos, subscribe to the channel, and support the content through various means such as buying a coffee or joining a Patreon community. The paragraph ends with a thank you note and an invitation to join the next live stream.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡German language
The German language is a West Germanic language primarily spoken in Central Europe. It is the most widely spoken and official language in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, South Tyrol in Italy, and Liechtenstein. In the video, the speaker discusses the negative perception of the German language as harsh and aggressive, which is often associated with historical propaganda speeches.
💡Reputation
Reputation refers to the beliefs or opinions that are generally held about someone or something. In the context of the video, the reputation of the German language is explored, particularly its international image as being harsh and unattractive, largely due to its association with historical figures and their manner of speech.
💡Hitler
Adolf Hitler was a German politician and the leader of the Nazi Party who rose to power as Chancellor of Germany and later Führer during World War II. His speeches and propaganda are mentioned in the video as a significant factor in shaping the negative perception of the German language due to his aggressive and dramatic speaking style.
💡Lingoda Sprint
Lingoda Sprint is a language learning challenge offered by Lingoda, an online language school. The challenge is designed to motivate learners to take a certain number of classes over a two-month period with the possibility of receiving cash back upon completion. In the video, it is presented as a way for people to learn German and potentially improve the language's reputation.
💡Propaganda
Propaganda refers to information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote or publicize a particular political cause or point of view. The video discusses how Hitler used propaganda and his dramatic speaking style to influence the masses, which has contributed to the harsh perception of the German language.
💡Bunol Deutsche
Bunol Deutsche, also known as 'stage German', is a set of rules for speaking German that were used in theater and movies to ensure clarity and dramatic effect. It includes over-enunciation and the use of a strong rolled 'R'. The video explains that Hitler's speeches followed this style, which contributed to the perception of German as a harsh language.
💡Uvular R
The uvular R is a speech sound that involves the back of the tongue touching the uvula, which is the small fleshy projection hanging down at the back of the throat. It is a characteristic sound of the German language and is mentioned in the video as one of the features that can make the language sound harsh to non-German speakers.
💡Consonant clusters
Consonant clusters are groups of consonants that appear together without any intervening vowels in a word. The video points out that German words often contain such clusters, which can contribute to the perception of the language as less smooth and more guttural compared to other languages.
💡Cultural perception
Cultural perception refers to how a particular culture or aspect of it is viewed or understood by others. The video discusses the cultural perception of the German language, which has been largely influenced by historical events and figures, leading to a negative image that contrasts with the language's historical reputation as the language of poets and thinkers.
💡World War II
World War II was a global war that lasted from 1939 to 1945, involving many of the world's major powers. The video suggests that the events of World War II, particularly the actions and rhetoric of Nazi Germany, have had a lasting impact on the international perception of the German language and culture.
💡Private conversation
A private conversation refers to a discussion that takes place between individuals in a non-public setting. The video mentions a rare recording of Hitler's private conversation, which contrasts with his public speaking style, suggesting that his aggressive tone was a deliberate choice for public speaking rather than a natural aspect of his voice.
Highlights

The German language is often perceived as harsh, ugly, and aggressive, largely due to its association with historical figures like Adolf Hitler.

The stereotype of the 'angry German' is a common comedic trope, where Germans are portrayed as shouting even when discussing pleasant topics.

The speaker, a native German, finds the stereotype amusing but acknowledges its prevalence in international perceptions.

German language actually has a history of being considered the language of poets and thinkers, with significant contributions to literature and science.

Adolf Hitler's speeches, known for their aggressive tone, were influenced by the dramatic and passionate style of the time, aiming to captivate audiences.

Hitler's speech style was taught to him by opera singer Paul de Vivre, who helped him improve his stage presence and protect his vocal cords.

Hitler's use of a strong, rolled 'R' sound was a deliberate choice and part of a set of rules known as 'Bühnendeutsch' or 'stage German'.

The aggressive speech style of Hitler has been perpetuated in films and media, often assigned to German characters, influencing global perception.

A rare recording of Hitler in a private conversation reveals a more standard German speech without the aggressive characteristics.

German language's reputation has been overshadowed by World War II, but it was once highly regarded in the fields of literature and philosophy.

The harsh sounds in the German language, such as the uvular 'R' and 'CH' sounds, contribute to its less smooth perception.

German words often contain a series of consonants without vowels, which can make the language seem more challenging to non-native speakers.

Despite the negative connotations, German remains the second most commonly used language in science.

The video discusses the impact of historical figures on language perception and invites viewers to share their thoughts on the topic.

The speaker offers a link to a language learning challenge with Lingoda, encouraging the learning of German and other languages.

Lingoda's online language school provides live classes via Zoom, allowing for interactive learning from native-level teachers.

The video emphasizes celebrating small language victories, such as ordering a coffee in a new language or understanding a movie plot without subtitles.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: