The Road to Depth: Thinking about what Character Is
TLDRIn this thought-provoking talk, the speaker reflects on the importance of cultivating depth over happiness, emphasizing the virtues that define our character. He shares personal anecdotes and insights on how experiences of love, suffering, struggle, obedience, and acceptance shape our moral core. The speaker advocates for a life guided by a moral compass, rather than societal pressures, and highlights the transformative power of these experiences in fostering a 'thousand-year heart.'
Takeaways
- π€ The speaker reflects on the importance of depth over happiness, emphasizing the value of developing 'eulogy virtues' rather than just 'resume virtues'.
- π The speaker discusses the transformative power of love, which humbles us, dissolves the self, and blurs the lines between giving and receiving.
- π Suffering, although often unwanted, can lead to personal growth by humbling us, revealing deeper parts of ourselves, and giving us a sense of moral calling.
- π‘οΈ Internal struggle is a key component of depth, as individuals battle their weaknesses and strive for self-improvement.
- π Obedience to a cause or problem outside oneself is highlighted as a path to depth, where one commits to addressing issues larger than personal interests.
- π‘ The concept of 'Adam I' and 'Adam II' is introduced, representing the external, resume-driven self versus the internal, moral self.
- π± The speaker suggests that our society nurtures 'Adam I' at the expense of 'Adam II', leading to an imbalance in our pursuit of success versus moral development.
- π The speaker advocates for a recovery of moral vocabulary and a deeper understanding of the soul as a metaphor for our moral core.
- π€ The importance of community and relationships is underscored, as they contribute to our depth and moral development.
- π The speaker shares personal anecdotes and encounters that illustrate the profound impact of acknowledging and responding to the suffering of others.
- π The ultimate goal is presented as achieving a balance between 'Adam I' and 'Adam II', cultivating a life of depth, virtue, and moral engagement.
Q & A
What is the main theme of the talk?
-The main theme of the talk is the exploration of depth and virtue in individuals, contrasting the 'resume virtues' with the 'eulogy virtues', and discussing how to cultivate inner depth and moral character.
What are the 'resume virtues' and how do they differ from the 'eulogy virtues'?
-The 'resume virtues' are the skills and qualities one offers to the job market that make them employable. In contrast, the 'eulogy virtues' are the personal qualities and moral characteristics that people will talk about at your funeral, such as kindness, bravery, honesty, and faithfulness.
How does the speaker describe the two sides of human nature, Adam I and Adam II?
-Adam I represents the external, resume-driven side of a person, focused on achievement and success. Adam II represents the internal, eulogy-driven side, focused on moral qualities, obedience to transcendent truths, and inner coherence of the soul.
What does the speaker suggest as the first step towards developing depth of character?
-The first step towards developing depth of character, according to the speaker, is experiencing transformative love, which can be for a person, a cause, or even God.
How does suffering contribute to the development of depth in a person?
-Suffering contributes to depth by first humbling a person, reminding them that they are not in control. It also forces individuals to confront and understand their own weaknesses and limitations, leading to personal growth and moral commitment.
What is the role of internal struggle in the process of going to depth?
-Internal struggle is a critical part of going to depth as it involves an individual's continuous effort to combat their core weaknesses and flaws. This struggle builds character and leads to self-improvement and moral growth.
What does the speaker mean by 'the art of presence'?
-The 'art of presence' refers to the ability to be fully present and attentive in the moment, especially when someone is sharing their suffering or trauma. It involves listening without trying to fix or judge the situation, simply offering one's presence as a form of support.
How does the speaker view the role of neuroscience in understanding human nature?
-The speaker views neuroscience as a tool that can clarify and confirm our understanding of human nature, but it does not necessarily teach us new philosophical insights. It helps us understand the mechanisms behind emotions and behaviors, but it does not provide a moral framework for understanding our actions.
What is the significance of the 'valley of vision' in the Puritan prayer mentioned by the speaker?
-The 'valley of vision' in the Puritan prayer signifies a place of deep introspection and spiritual realization. It's where one comes to terms with their sins and limitations, and learns to accept God's grace and love, leading to a transformative experience of personal growth.
What is the speaker's perspective on the impact of wealth on moral development?
-The speaker believes that wealth can be a challenge to moral development because it can lead to a loss of discipline and focus on materialistic pursuits rather than moral virtues. However, he also emphasizes that virtue is not tied to economic class and that individuals can cultivate depth regardless of their wealth.
How does the speaker describe the importance of forgiveness in the context of moral and spiritual growth?
-The speaker describes forgiveness as the final form of love that is essential for moral and spiritual growth. It allows individuals to let go of past wrongs, cultivate a sense of compassion, and deepen their relationships with others, contributing to their overall depth of character.
Outlines
π Embracing Suffering and the Art of Presence
The speaker reflects on the profound impact of personal encounters with individuals who have experienced loss and suffering. He discusses the importance of being present and the art of listening without trying to impose solutions or comparisons. The speaker shares insights on how to support those in trauma, emphasizing the value of acknowledging their pain, showing up consistently, avoiding comparisons, and not offering false hope or counsel. He also explores the concept of inner depth and the contrast between resume virtues (skills and achievements) and eulogy virtues (personal character traits), highlighting the significance of the latter.
π§ Balancing External Success with Inner Virtue
The speaker delves into the dichotomy between external achievements (Adam 1) and internal virtues (Adam 2), using the concepts from Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik's work. He contrasts the external drive for success and recognition with the internal desire for moral goodness and obedience to a higher truth. The speaker argues that while society often prioritizes resume virtues, it is the eulogy virtues that hold true importance and depth. He also discusses the tension and different logics governing these two aspects of human nature, emphasizing the need for balance and the cultivation of inner depth.
π‘ Defining and Developing Inner Depth
The speaker explores the qualities that define a deep person, such as the capacity for profound emotions, spiritual presence, philosophical convictions, and moral commitments. He discusses how depth is developed over time through experiences, particularly those involving love, suffering, and internal struggles. The speaker also examines the concept of the soul as a metaphorical moral center and emphasizes the importance of virtues such as humility, love, and moral engagement in achieving inner depth.
π The Transformative Power of Love
The speaker discusses the transformative power of love, detailing its ability to humble individuals and shift their focus outside of themselves. Love, according to the speaker, leads to a deeper understanding of oneself and others, and it blurs the lines between giving and receiving. He also touches on the importance of friendship and the profound impact it can have on one's depth of character.
πͺοΈ The Role of Suffering in Personal Growth
The speaker reflects on the paradoxical role of suffering in shaping an individual's character and depth. While suffering is not inherently noble, it can lead to personal growth by humbling individuals, revealing deeper aspects of their identity, and fostering a sense of moral responsibility. The speaker suggests that suffering can lead to a more profound understanding of oneself and a greater commitment to moral action.
π€ΌββοΈ The Internal Struggle for Virtue
The speaker emphasizes the importance of internal struggle in the pursuit of virtue and depth. He describes how individuals often battle their core weaknesses and strive for self-improvement. This internal conflict, according to the speaker, is a critical aspect of character development and leads to a deeper understanding of oneself and one's place in the world.
ποΈ Obedience to a Higher Calling
The speaker discusses the concept of obedience to a higher calling or external problems as a path to depth and virtue. He uses the examples of individuals who have devoted their lives to addressing societal issues, not because it was within them, but because it was presented to them. The speaker highlights the importance of responding to life's demands and the role this plays in shaping a person's moral and spiritual depth.
π§ Acceptance as the Path to Depth
The speaker explores the idea of acceptance as a counterintuitive path to depth. He shares a personal experience of feeling accepted and part of a transcendent community without having earned it. The speaker suggests that this unmerited acceptance, or grace, can lead to a profound transformation and a desire to pass on the gift of acceptance. He contrasts this with the active pursuit of achievements and argues that deep individuals often exhibit a passive acceptance of their worth and the love they receive from others.
π The Intersection of Virtue and Forgiveness
The speaker concludes by emphasizing the importance of hope, faith, and love in leading a virtuous life. He references Reinhold Niebuhr's words to illustrate that meaningful actions are often beyond our immediate understanding and require hope and faith. The speaker also highlights the significance of forgiveness as the ultimate form of love and a crucial aspect of spiritual depth.
π Navigating the Challenges of Moral and Personal Growth
The speaker discusses the challenges of nurturing moral and personal growth in a high-achieving culture that prioritizes external success. He shares insights on how to work with young adults to develop their moral vocabulary and inner strength. The speaker also reflects on the impact of conditional love and the pressure to succeed on individuals' moral development.
π The Impact of Wealth and Poverty on Depth of Character
The speaker explores the impact of wealth and poverty on the development of character and depth. He discusses how the discipline and focus required by poverty can foster depth, while the distractions and lack of discipline in wealth can lead to a loss of depth. The speaker also touches on the moral challenges presented by wealth and the importance of maintaining virtues regardless of one's economic status.
Mindmap
Keywords
π‘Depth
π‘Resume Virtues
π‘Eulogy Virtues
π‘Suffering
π‘Love
π‘Internal Struggle
π‘Obedience
π‘Acceptance
π‘Adam I and Adam II
π‘Moral Vocabulary
π‘Grace
Highlights
The speaker reflects on the importance of character morality and the profound impact of personal experiences and stories.
A mathematician's struggle with the senseless loss of her son in an auto accident highlights the difficulty of finding meaning in suffering.
The importance of being present and the art of presence is emphasized, as shared by Katie Couric's advice to 'just listen'.
Learning from those who have suffered: bringing up the trauma, showing up, not comparing traumas, and being practical in support.
The speaker discusses the concept of 'thousand-year heart' and how to develop inner depth through virtues.
The distinction between 'resume virtues' and 'eulogy virtues' and the societal focus on the former over the latter.
The duality of human nature represented by 'Adam 1' and 'Adam 2', and the tension between external success and internal goodness.
The paradoxical logic of moral logic versus economic logic and the importance of selflessness and humility.
The speaker explores the concept of 'depth' as a counterculture to the prevalent 'happiness culture'.
The transformative power of love to humble, dissipate the self, and blur the lines between giving and receiving.
The role of suffering in forming character and the moral commitments that arise from enduring pain.
Internal struggle as a means of building character and the importance of recognizing one's own weaknesses.
Obedience to a calling or a problem outside oneself as a path to depth and moral engagement.
The concept of acceptance and how it leads to a paradoxical sense of energy and purpose.
The speaker shares a personal experience of 'valley of vision' and the sensation of being admitted into a transcendent community.
The impact of neuroscience on our understanding of morality and the potential demoralizing effect of utilitarian language.
The importance of moral vocabulary and the moral dilemmas faced by young adults in a high-achieving culture.
The speaker's advice to his students and the value of moral ecology in personal development.
The challenge of maintaining depth and virtue in the face of wealth and the loss of moral discipline.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
The Four Commitments: The Choices That Create Your Life
Bullying | Madeline Morgan | TEDxYouth@ParkCity
The lies our culture tells us about what matters --- and a better way to live | David Brooks
Your Dark Side and Control Over Your Life | Robert Greene | EP 237
Stanford University CCARE w Thich Nhat Hanh and James Doty, MD
Neil deGrasse Tyson: StarTalk Live at Kings Theatre β Science and Morality
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: