i read every book Margot Robbie and Cillian Murphy recommended
TLDRIn this entertaining video, the host pits the book recommendations of celebrities Margot Robbie and Killian Murphy against each other in a friendly competition. After reading and reviewing a variety of books chosen by both stars, the host reflects on the themes and literary tastes of each, ultimately favoring Killian Murphy's selections for their deep character studies and intimate portrayals of family and small-town life. The video concludes with a final score of 4-3 in favor of Killian, but acknowledges the subjective nature of literary preferences.
Takeaways
- 📚 The video is a comparison of book recommendations by celebrities Margot Robbie and Killian Murphy.
- 🎥 The creator of the video runs a YouTube series called 'celebrity book club' where they analyze and compare books recommended by celebrities.
- 🌟 Margot Robbie's recommendations include 'Animals' by Emma Jane Unworth and 'The Hobbit' by J.R.R. Tolkien, showing a preference for high-concept and dramatic literature.
- 🌌 Killian Murphy's choices feature 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers' by Max Porter and 'The Old Man and the Sea' by Ernest Hemingway, reflecting a taste for domestic and character-driven stories.
- 📈 The video presents a head-to-head competition format to determine whose book recommendations are more appealing to the creator.
- 🤔 The creator's personal preference leans towards Killian Murphy's book selections due to their focus on deep character studies and intimate settings.
- 📖 The video also discusses the importance of representation in literature, particularly highlighting female friendships.
- 🎭 Killian Murphy's involvement in adapting 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers' for the stage adds a personal connection to his book recommendation.
- 📚 The creator's dislike for 'Dune' by Frank Herbert is mentioned, despite its status as a genre classic.
- 🎉 The final score is 4 points to Killian Murphy and 3 points to Margot Robbie, indicating the creator's ultimate preference for Killian's recommendations.
- 💬 The video concludes with the creator expressing enjoyment in making the video and encourages viewers to stay in touch and subscribe.
Q & A
What is the main concept behind the video series 'Celebrity Book Club'?
-The main concept of 'Celebrity Book Club' is to research and analyze the books that specific celebrities have read or recommended, and then provide a personal opinion on these books after reading them.
Why were the originally planned videos for Margot Robbie and Killian Murphy not released?
-The originally planned videos for Margot Robbie and Killian Murphy were not released because everyone went on strike, and the videos were scrapped in solidarity with the SAG-AFTRA strikes.
What book did Margot Robbie recommend that explores adult female friendships?
-Margot Robbie recommended 'Animals' by Emma Jane Unworth, a book that explores adult female friendships and is about two best friends living in London causing chaos wherever they go.
Which book by Max Porter did Killian Murphy find moving and later adapt for the stage?
-Killian Murphy found 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers' by Max Porter moving and later adapted it for the stage, where he played both the father and the crow.
What is the unique aspect of the book 'The Old Man and the Sea' by Ernest Hemingway?
-A unique aspect of 'The Old Man and the Sea' is that every single word in the title has three letters.
How does the book 'One for the Money' by Janet Evanovich challenge gender expectations?
-'One for the Money' challenges gender expectations by featuring a female protagonist, Stephanie, who enters a traditionally male-dominated world of bounty hunting and proves to be quite inept at it, creating humor and commentary on gender roles.
What is the central theme of 'Shine On' by Max Porter?
-The central theme of 'Shine On' is a lyrical study of troubled youth and the burdens of being a teenager, following a young expelled student as he contemplates his life on the water's edge.
What is the significance of the book 'The Hobbit' in the context of the video?
-In the context of the video, 'The Hobbit' is significant as it is one of the books recommended by Margot Robbie and is considered an undeniable classic and a prequel to 'The Lord of the Rings'.
How does the book 'Appointment in Samara' by John O'Hara differ from 'The Hobbit' in terms of content and style?
-'Appointment in Samara' differs from 'The Hobbit' as it is more of a reality TV show in a novel form, focusing on personal destruction and the drama of small-town life, whereas 'The Hobbit' is an epic fantasy saga with intricate world-building.
What was the final verdict in the head-to-head comparison of book recommendations between Margot Robbie and Killian Murphy?
-The final verdict in the head-to-head comparison was that Killian Murphy's book recommendations were preferred, with a final score of four points to Margot Robbie's three points.
Outlines
📚 Celebrity Book Club Showdown: Margot Robbie vs. Cillian Murphy
The video script introduces a unique concept of pitting two celebrities' book recommendations against each other in a friendly competition. The narrator explains their YouTube series 'Celebrity Book Club,' where they analyze books recommended by celebrities. The twist this time is a head-to-head comparison between Margot Robbie and Cillian Murphy's picks, with the narrator having read all the books to give a personal verdict on which celebrity has better taste in literature.
🎲 Book Battle: 'Animals' vs. 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers'
The first round of the book battle features 'Animals' by Emma Jane Unsworth, recommended by Margot Robbie, and 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers' by Max Porter, chosen by Cillian Murphy. The narrator provides a synopsis of both books, sharing their personal impressions and the celebrities' connections to the books. Margot's choice explores female friendship in London, while Cillian's recommendation is a poetic and moving portrayal of grief. The narrator admits the difficulty in choosing between the two but ultimately favors 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers' for its emotional impact.
🌟 Hemingway's 'The Old Man and the Sea' vs. 'One for the Money'
The second round presents a stark contrast with Ernest Hemingway's 'The Old Man and the Sea' going up against 'One for the Money' by Janet Evanovich. The narrator expresses a strong dislike for 'Dune,' a book mentioned as Margot's choice, and swiftly moves on to Hemingway's work, which they find impactful despite its simplicity. On the other hand, 'One for the Money' is a light-hearted, contemporary novel about an unlikely bounty hunter. The narrator finds Hemingway's book to be the clear winner due to its profound themes and writing style.
📖 Comparing 'Shine', 'The Hobbit', and 'Appointment in Samara'
In this round, the narrator discusses 'Shine' by Jess Walter, 'The Hobbit' by J.R.R. Tolkien, and 'Appointment in Samara' by W. Bruce Cameron. 'Shine' is a lyrical study of troubled youth with a bold writing style, while 'The Hobbit' is a classic fantasy novel with intricate world-building. 'Appointment in Samara' is described as a novel akin to a reality TV show, exploring personal destruction. The narrator praises 'The Hobbit' for its magnificence and cultural impact, making it the winner against 'Appointment in Samara'.
🏆 Final Round: 'To Kill a Mockingbird' vs. 'Eclipse'
The final round features 'To Kill a Mockingbird' by Harper Lee, a universally studied and captivating book, and 'Eclipse' by John Banville, a poetic and introspective novel. The narrator struggles with Banville's writing, finding it too obscure and detached. In contrast, 'To Kill a Mockingbird' is appreciated for its powerful prose and exploration of racial injustice. The narrator's personal preference leans towards Killian Murphy's selections, with 'To Kill a Mockingbird' securing another point for his side.
🥇 Conclusion: Margot Robbie vs. Cillian Murphy - The Verdict
The video concludes with a tally of the points, showing Cillian Murphy leading with 4 points to Margot Robbie's 3. The narrator reflects on the book selections, noting Margot's preference for high-concept, dramatic, and world-building books, while Cillian recommended more domestic, character-driven stories. Despite the verdict, the narrator emphasizes the enjoyment of exploring a diverse range of books and the subjective nature of literary preferences.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Celebrity Book Club
💡SAG-AFTRA Strikes
💡Literary Analysis
💡Female Friendships
💡Grief
💡World Building
💡Stream of Consciousness
💡BetterHelp
💡The Hobbit
💡To Kill a Mockingbird
💡The Sun Also Rises
Highlights
The video is a comparison of book recommendations between Margot Robbie and Killian Murphy.
The creator of the video runs a YouTube series called 'celebrity book club' where they analyze books recommended by celebrities.
Due to the SAG-AFTRA strikes, the video creator initially scrapped the videos but resumed after a tentative agreement was reached.
Margot Robbie's first book recommendation is 'Animals' by Emma Jane Unsworth, which explores adult female friendships.
Killian Murphy's first recommendation is 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers' by Max Porter, a poetic exploration of grief.
The video creator personally connects with Killian Murphy's choice of 'Grief is the Thing with Feathers'.
The video creator dislikes 'Dune' by Frank Herbert, criticizing its world-building and storytelling.
Killian Murphy's recommendation of 'The Old Man and the Sea' by Ernest Hemingway is appreciated for its simplicity and depth.
The video creator finds 'One for the Money' by Janet Evanovich fun but reflecting outdated gender stereotypes.
Killian Murphy's choice of 'Shine On' by David W. Vann is a lyrical study of troubled youth, but the video creator felt disconnected from the character.
The video includes a paid partnership with BetterHelp, promoting online therapy.
Margot Robbie's recommendation of 'The Hobbit' is an undeniable classic with intricate world-building.
Killian Murphy's choice of 'Appointment in Samara' is compared to a reality TV show in novel form, focusing on personal destruction.
The video creator prefers 'To Kill a Mockingbird' over John Banville's 'Eclipse' for its captivating storytelling and powerful prose.
Margot Robbie's preference for 'The Sun Also Rises' by Hemingway is noted, highlighting her interest in books about places she travels to.
Killian Murphy's recommendation of 'Small Things Like These' by Claire Keegan is praised for its understated writing and powerful impact.
The video creator's childhood love for Enid Blyton's 'The Secret Seven' is shared, reflecting on the nostalgia and joy the books brought.
Killian Murphy's final recommendation, 'Rabbit Run' by John Updike, is a provocative exploration of an unlikable protagonist.
The video concludes with Killian Murphy's recommendations being preferred by the creator, but acknowledges that personal preferences vary.
Transcripts
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: