Physics Vs Engineering | Which Is Best For You?

Zach Star
22 Sept 201820:56
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe transcript discusses the differences between physics and engineering majors, highlighting the pros and cons of each. Engineering offers more direct career paths and typically requires only a bachelor's degree, while physics provides a broader range of job sectors but often requires a PhD for research roles. The transcript also covers specific engineering disciplines and their corresponding career paths, as well as the potential for crossover between the two fields. It concludes with advice on pursuing further education in either field, emphasizing the flexibility and opportunities for those with a strong foundation in physics or engineering.

Takeaways
  • πŸŽ“ Engineering offers more direct career paths compared to physics, with most engineering majors not requiring more than a bachelor's degree for entry into the workforce.
  • 🌟 Physics graduates have a wider range of job sectors but often require a PhD for research-intensive roles, such as working with particle accelerators or on quantum computers.
  • πŸ”§ Engineering is more application-focused, with specialized branches like civil, aerospace, electrical, and chemical engineering leading to specific career paths in design, systems, and technology development.
  • πŸ“š Physics majors gain foundational knowledge across various branches of physics, providing a broad base for potential graduate studies or research in specialized areas.
  • πŸ”„ There is overlap between physics and engineering curricula, with both fields studying subjects like thermodynamics, electromagnetism, and quantum mechanics, but with different emphases and applications.
  • 🏫 Students can pursue an engineering physics major to combine aspects of both disciplines, or take electives and minors to supplement their primary degree.
  • 🀝 Switching from a physics bachelor's to an engineering master's is generally easier than the reverse, but both paths are possible with additional coursework and preparation.
  • 🌐 Graduate schools value a strong foundation in relevant coursework, high GPA, and research experience when considering applicants from different undergraduate backgrounds.
  • πŸ” For those considering a switch in graduate studies, advisors from various departments at top-tier schools can provide guidance and clarify admission requirements.
  • πŸ“ˆ Physics and engineering both provide opportunities for research and industry roles, with the choice largely depending on personal interests, desired career paths, and willingness to pursue higher education.
Q & A
  • What are some key differences between a physics major and an engineering major?

    -A physics major focuses on the foundational concepts and various branches of physics, providing a broad understanding of physical systems and preparing students for a wide range of job sectors. An engineering major, on the other hand, is more directed towards specific applications and problem-solving using engineering principles, leading to more direct career paths related to the specific engineering field studied.

  • What are the pros and cons of choosing a physics major?

    -Pros of a physics major include a broad educational foundation applicable to various industries and the potential for advanced study in diverse areas of research. Cons include the likelihood of needing a PhD for many research positions and less defined career paths compared to engineering.

  • What types of careers can a physics graduate pursue?

    -Physics graduates can work in engineering, finance, teaching, and research. They may also find roles as data scientists, work in tech companies, or even at large research institutions like NASA or CERN.

  • What are some specific areas of research for physics PhD holders?

    -Physics PhD holders can specialize in areas such as astrophysics, plasma physics, condensed matter physics, particle physics, and spintronics. They may work on understanding the nature of dark matter and dark energy, improving computer chip technology, or researching high-energy phenomena with particle accelerators.

  • What are some common engineering disciplines and their respective career paths?

    -Civil engineering can lead to roles in bridge and infrastructure design. Aerospace engineering involves working on aircraft and spacecraft structures. Electrical engineering can lead to jobs in improving electronic systems and communications. Chemical engineering is about designing processes for chemical reactions in industries like pharmaceuticals. Mechanical engineering offers roles in automotive, robotics, and aerospace industries.

  • What differences exist in the curriculum between physics and engineering programs?

    -While both programs cover topics like thermodynamics and electromagnetism, physics programs tend to be more theoretical and math-intensive, focusing on foundational concepts across various branches of physics. Engineering programs are more application-oriented, with a focus on practical problem-solving and design principles specific to the engineering discipline.

  • Is it possible to switch from a physics bachelor's to an engineering master's program?

    -Yes, it is generally possible to switch from a physics bachelor's to an engineering master's program. Many schools do not require an undergraduate degree in the specific engineering field, and students can catch up on prerequisite knowledge during the master's program.

  • What should a physics major do to prepare for an engineering master's program?

    -A physics major should take additional courses in the specific engineering field of interest during their undergraduate studies. They may also need to take prerequisite classes at the beginning of the master's program to bridge any knowledge gaps.

  • How do I decide between a physics and engineering major if I'm interested in both?

    -Consider your long-term career goals, the type of work you want to do, and whether you prefer theoretical study or practical applications. You could also explore an engineering physics major or take classes in both disciplines as electives or minors.

  • What are the general requirements for a student with an engineering bachelor's to pursue a master's in physics?

    -While specific requirements vary by institution, many schools value completed coursework in typical undergraduate physics classes. A strong GPA, high scores on necessary exams like the GRE Physics subject test, and research experience can also improve chances of admission.

  • What advice is given to students unsure about choosing between physics and engineering majors?

    -Students unsure about their major choice can explore both fields by taking introductory courses, speaking with advisors or professors, and considering their future career aspirations. They can also look into interdisciplinary options like engineering physics or take electives in both subjects.

Outlines
00:00
πŸŽ“ Understanding the Differences: Physics vs. Engineering

This paragraph discusses the common confusion students face between choosing physics and engineering as majors. It highlights the differences in career paths, the pros and cons of each, and the variety of options available post-graduation. Engineering is presented as a field with more direct career paths and typically only requiring a bachelor's degree, while physics opens up a wide range of job sectors but often requires a higher level of education, such as a PhD, for research roles. The paragraph also suggests watching a complementary physics video for more technical details and emphasizes the importance of making an informed decision based on personal career goals and interests.

05:01
πŸ” Exploring Career Opportunities in Physics and Engineering

The second paragraph delves into specific career paths for physics and engineering graduates. It outlines the diverse fields that physics majors can enter, such as astrophysics, plasma physics, and condensed matter physics, and contrasts these with the more focused and practical applications of engineering, including civil, aerospace, electrical, and chemical engineering. The paragraph also touches on the overlap between the two fields and the potential for physics majors to enter engineering roles, provided they have the necessary background knowledge and interest.

10:05
πŸ“š Comparing the Curriculum of Physics and Engineering

This paragraph compares the academic curriculum of physics and engineering, highlighting the similarities and differences in the classes taken by students in each field. It explains that while both majors cover fundamental concepts like thermodynamics and electromagnetism, the depth and focus of these subjects differ. Physics majors tend to study more theoretical and mathematical aspects, while engineering students focus on practical applications and problem-solving. The paragraph also mentions specific courses like statics, dynamics, and quantum mechanics, and how they are approached differently in each discipline.

15:08
πŸ€” Navigating the Decision Between Physics and Engineering

The fourth paragraph provides guidance for students who are undecided between physics and engineering. It suggests considering a dual major or taking classes in both fields as electives or minors. The paragraph also addresses the possibility of transitioning from a bachelor's degree in one field to a master's degree in the other, offering insights from various university advisors. It emphasizes that while there is no strict requirement for an undergraduate degree in the same field, having relevant coursework and a strong academic record can improve one's chances of admission to graduate programs.

20:13
πŸš€ Concluding Thoughts and Resources for Further Exploration

In the final paragraph, the speaker concludes the discussion by encouraging viewers to explore their interests further and reach out to academic advisors for personalized guidance. The speaker also promotes their social media platforms and a Facebook group for updates, emphasizing the importance of community and networking in making informed educational and career decisions.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Physics
Physics is a fundamental science that studies matter, energy, and the interactions between them. In the context of the video, it is presented as a potential major for students, focusing on the foundational concepts and principles that govern the natural world. The video discusses how a physics major can lead to a broad range of job sectors and is essential for those interested in pursuing research in various branches of physics, such as quantum physics or astrophysics.
πŸ’‘Engineering
Engineering is the application of scientific and mathematical principles to design, build, and maintain structures, machines, systems, and processes. The video emphasizes engineering as a major that offers more direct career paths, with specific disciplines like mechanical, electrical, and civil engineering leading to jobs closely related to the field of study. Engineering is portrayed as a practical application of physics principles to solve real-world problems.
πŸ’‘Career Paths
Career paths refer to the possible professional trajectories one can follow after completing their education. In the video, the comparison between physics and engineering majors is largely framed around the career opportunities each provides. It discusses how engineering tends to offer more direct and specific career paths, while physics can lead to a wider variety of sectors but may require further education for research roles.
πŸ’‘Bachelor's Degree
A bachelor's degree is an academic degree awarded by colleges and universities after completion of a specified program of study, typically lasting four years. In the context of the video, it is mentioned that most engineering majors can enter the workforce with a bachelor's degree, while physics majors often require a higher level of education, such as a master's or PhD, for certain research or specialized roles.
πŸ’‘PhD
A PhD, or Doctor of Philosophy, is the highest academic degree that can be earned in many fields. It involves original research and is often required for careers in academia and advanced research positions. The video explains that while a PhD is common for those pursuing careers as physics researchers, it is less necessary for most engineering roles, which can be entered with a bachelor's degree.
πŸ’‘Astrophysics
Astrophysics is a branch of astronomy that focuses on the properties, behaviors, and evolution of celestial objects using the principles of physics. In the video, astrophysics is mentioned as one of the specialized areas of physics research that might require a PhD for one to work in, such as studying black holes, galaxies, or the cosmic microwave background.
πŸ’‘Quantum Mechanics
Quantum mechanics is a fundamental theory in physics that describes the behavior of matter and energy at very small scales, such as atomic and subatomic particles. In the video, quantum mechanics is presented as a key subject for physics majors, with implications for understanding the behavior of electrons and atoms in transistors, which is relevant to electrical engineering and computer science.
πŸ’‘Thermodynamics
Thermodynamics is the study of energy, its conversion between different forms, and the ability to do work. It is a core subject in both physics and engineering, with different focuses in each field. In the video, thermodynamics for engineers is more application-oriented, dealing with practical aspects like heat exchangers and turbines, while physics majors might study it from a more theoretical perspective, often under the name of statistical mechanics.
πŸ’‘Electromagnetism
Electromagnetism is a branch of physics that deals with the interaction of electric and magnetic fields. It is a crucial subject for both physics and electrical engineering majors. The video explains that while both majors cover the principles of electromagnetic waves and their applications, physics majors delve deeper into the theoretical aspects, including relativistic electromagnetism, while electrical engineers focus on practical applications like waveguides and signal transmission.
πŸ’‘Engineering Physics
Engineering physics is an interdisciplinary field of study that combines elements of both physics and engineering. It is presented in the video as a potential major for students who are interested in both disciplines, allowing them to take classes in both areas. This major can serve as a foundation for graduate studies in either physics or engineering.
πŸ’‘Graduate School
Graduate school refers to education beyond a bachelor's degree, including master's and doctoral programs. The video discusses the possibility of transitioning from an undergraduate degree in one field to a graduate program in another, such as moving from a physics bachelor's to an engineering master's or vice versa. It highlights the importance of relevant coursework, maintaining a high GPA, and scoring well on necessary exams for such transitions.
Highlights

Physics and engineering are often considered as high school students' potential majors, each with its own set of pros and cons.

Engineering offers more direct career paths, with mechanical engineering leading to jobs with a title related to the field of study.

A bachelor's degree in engineering can lead to well-paying jobs right after graduation, allowing one to enter the workforce quickly.

Physics opens up a wide range of job sectors, including finance and teaching, not just engineering.

A physics major provides a strong foundation in various branches of the field, such as thermodynamics, classical physics, and quantum physics.

A PhD is generally required for a career as a physicist, especially for roles in research and advanced physics fields.

Physics graduates may not always end up in physics jobs, but their education can lead to diverse career opportunities.

Civil engineering can lead to roles in designing infrastructure like bridges, tunnels, and buildings.

Aerospace engineers work on the structure and propulsion systems of aircraft and spacecraft, analyzing aerodynamics and supersonic travel capabilities.

Electrical engineers improve the efficiency and speed of electronic systems, from consumer electronics to satellite communications.

Chemical engineers may work on chemical reactors and safety systems for large-scale chemical processes in industries like Procter & Gamble or Budweiser.

Mechanical engineers have a broad range of applications, from cars and aircraft to robotics and biomedical equipment.

Physics PhD positions involve research in areas such as astrophysics, plasma physics, and condensed matter physics.

Particle physicists study the fundamental particles and forces of the universe, including the search for a graviton and understanding dark matter and energy.

The curriculum of physics and engineering majors has overlaps but also significant differences, with physics being more math-intensive and theory-focused.

Engineering physics is a major that combines aspects of both physics and engineering, often leading to graduate studies in either field.

Switching from a physics bachelor's to an engineering master's is generally easier than the reverse, with many top-tier schools open to such transitions.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: