The real Jon Snow
TLDRThis video script explores the character of Jon Snow from 'A Song of Ice and Fire', contrasting his development in the TV adaptation 'Game of Thrones' with George R.R. Martin's original books. It delves into Jon's internal struggles, his transformation post-resurrection, and speculates on his ultimate fate, including his potential role as Azor Ahai reborn and the moral dilemmas he may face in the series' conclusion.
Takeaways
- ๐ Jon Snow is portrayed differently in the 'Game of Thrones' TV series compared to the books by George R.R. Martin, with TV Jon being a more straightforward warrior and book Jon a more complex character with political acumen and moral dilemmas.
- ๐ฐ The TV adaptation closely follows the books in the initial seasons but diverges significantly in later seasons, resulting in a Jon Snow character that lacks the internal conflict and development present in the literary version.
- ๐ฅ Book Jon Snow is depicted as having a strong connection to the old gods and magic, which is a significant aspect of his character development and is less emphasized in the TV show.
- ๐ Jon's heritage is a central theme, with the TV show revealing his true parentage as Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark, making him a potential heir to the Iron Throne, a revelation that is hinted at but not confirmed in the books.
- ๐ Jon's death and potential resurrection in the books are suggested to have profound effects on his character, possibly changing him physically and mentally, and possibly involving a second life as a warg with his direwolf, Ghost.
- ๐ก๏ธ Jon's struggle with his duty to the Night's Watch and his love for the Starks and the realm is a recurring theme, leading him to make difficult decisions that often come with a high personal cost.
- ๐ค Jon's efforts to unite the wildlings with the Night's Watch and the realm at large showcase his leadership and his vision for a more inclusive and cooperative society.
- ๐ฎ The role of prophecy and destiny in Jon's life is explored, with the TV show touching on it less than the books, where it is deeply intertwined with Jon's actions and decisions.
- ๐ฅ The relationships Jon forms, particularly with characters like Ygritte, Daenerys Targaryen, and his Stark siblings, are central to his character development and the choices he makes.
- ๐ถ Jon's experiences as a bastard and his quest for identity and belonging are key aspects of his journey, influencing his actions and his sense of self throughout the series.
Q & A
How does Jon Snow's character differ between the TV show and the books in 'Game of Thrones'?
-In the TV show, Jon Snow is portrayed as a brave but somewhat 'stupid' warrior who is not adept at politics due to his stubborn honesty. He is primarily focused on doing the right thing and has no desire to be a king. In contrast, the book version of Jon Snow is more of a smart politician with a complex moral compass. He is not always honest, has secret plans, and is tempted by desires for honor, revenge, love, and home.
What is the significance of Jon Snow's direwolf, Ghost, in the books?
-Ghost is not only a symbol of Jon Snow's difference from his Stark siblings but also connects him to the mysterious magic of the old gods and possibly to Bloodraven, the three-eyed crow. Ghost's white fur and red eyes resemble the characteristics of the weirwood trees, and there are hints that Bloodraven may have influenced Ghost to guide Jon on his path.
How does Jon Snow's upbringing at Winterfell affect his sense of belonging and identity?
-Growing up as a bastard at Winterfell, Jon Snow feels rejected and experiences prejudice and exclusion. He is not accepted by Lady Catelyn and is seen as a potential political rival to her son, Robb. This upbringing instills in Jon a strong desire for a sense of belonging and a struggle with his identity.
What moral dilemmas does Jon Snow face in the books?
-Jon Snow constantly faces moral dilemmas that question what it means to be a hero. He is torn between his desires and his duty, often having to make tough choices that have no clear right answer, such as whether to stay loyal to the Night's Watch or to help his family, the Starks, in times of need.
How does Jon Snow's relationship with the wildlings in the books differ from his portrayal in the TV show?
-In the books, Jon Snow's relationship with the wildlings is more complex. He is not just their enemy but also sees them as people with their own perspectives and motivations. He even contemplates joining them to learn their plans, showing a more nuanced understanding of the world beyond the Wall.
What is the significance of Jon Snow's potential royal lineage in the TV show and the books?
-In both the TV show and the books, it is revealed or hinted that Jon Snow might be the son of Lyanna Stark and Prince Rhaegar Targaryen, which would make him a legitimate Targaryen and a potential claimant to the Iron Throne. However, this revelation has different impacts on his character and story arc in the two mediums.
How does Jon Snow's leadership style differ between the TV show and the books?
-In the TV show, Jon Snow's leadership is often portrayed as brave and somewhat impulsive. In the books, however, his leadership is more strategic and politically aware, as he makes calculated decisions and attempts to bring about change within the Night's Watch to prepare for the threats ahead.
What is the role of prophecy in Jon Snow's story in the books?
-Prophecy plays a significant role in Jon Snow's story in the books, with various hints and foreshadowing suggesting that he might be the prophesied hero Azor Ahai reborn. This includes his potential to wield a flaming sword, his connection to ice and fire, and his role in the fight against the white walkers.
How does Jon Snow's relationship with Daenerys Targaryen develop in the TV show and the books?
-In the TV show, Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen develop a romantic relationship. In the books, while their relationship is not as advanced, there are hints that they could become allies or even fall in love, given their shared goals and potential familial connection.
What is the potential outcome of Jon Snow's moral and emotional struggles in the books?
-Jon Snow's moral and emotional struggles in the books could lead to a transformative experience, possibly including his resurrection and a deeper connection to his Targaryen heritage and the magic of the old gods. His struggles may also influence his decisions regarding leadership, alliances, and his ultimate role in the fight against the white walkers.
Outlines
๐ฐ Jon Snow: Fantasy Hero and Moral Struggles
Jon Snow is depicted as a fantasy hero with a complex journey. He is a bastard seeking family and identity, and his character evolves significantly between the books and the TV adaptation of 'Game of Thrones'. In the earlier seasons, he is portrayed as a brave but naive warrior, stubbornly honest and not adept at politics. However, in the books, Jon is more of a smart politician who is not always honest and has secret plans. He is also tempted by desires for honor, revenge, love, and home. His internal conflict between his desires and his duty is a central theme, and his character is deeply connected with prophecy and magic that will change the world of ice and fire.
๐ฆ Jon's Family and Early Life
Jon Snow grows up at Winterfell with the Stark family, but as a bastard, he feels different and faces prejudice. His mother's identity is a mystery, with theories suggesting she might be Lady Ashara Dayne or a commoner. In reality, Jon is likely the son of Ned Stark's sister, Lyanna Stark, and Prince Rhaegar Targaryen, making him the rightful King of Westeros. His upbringing is marked by a sense of not belonging, especially with Catelyn Stark's cold treatment, and his physical appearance sets him apart from his Stark siblings.
๐บ Jon's Connection with Ghost and the Old Gods
Jon's connection with his direwolf pup, Ghost, symbolizes his difference from his Stark siblings and hints at his deeper connection to the old gods and the magic of the North. The white fur and red eyes of Ghost could be a sign of Jon's true heritage, linking him to his father Rhaegar and the Targaryen lineage. The mysterious circumstances of finding Ghost and the wolf's silent nature suggest the influence of Bloodraven, a greenseer with the magic of the old gods, who might have plans for Jon in the prophecy to defeat the white walkers.
๐ก๏ธ Jon's Decision to Join the Night's Watch
Feeling rejected and with no future at Winterfell, Jon decides to join the Night's Watch, an ancient brotherhood guarding the Wall in the North. His uncle Benjen warns him about the lifelong commitment and the 'cost' of the oath, which includes renouncing marriage, children, and titles. This decision is influenced by his desire for honor and adventure, as well as the political implications of his potential claim to the throne if he is indeed Rhaegar's son.
๐จ๏ธ Jon's Challenges and Growth in the Night's Watch
Jon's life at Castle Black is initially difficult, marked by harsh training under Alliser Thorne and the resentment of his fellow recruits. However, he learns to empathize with others, befriending Grenn and Pyp, and teaching the recruits to fight better. His leadership skills emerge as he protects Samwell Tarly and convinces the recruits not to harm him. Jon's journey is one of personal growth, learning to navigate the complexities of duty and loyalty.
๐ฅ Jon's Moral Dilemmas and the Night's Watch
Jon faces his first significant moral dilemma when he must choose between his duty to the Night's Watch and his love for the Starks. Maester Aemon advises that love can be the death of duty, and Jon's decision to ride south to help Robb, knowing the punishment for desertion is death, shows his willingness to sacrifice for love. However, his friends remind him of his duty, and Jeor Mormont emphasizes the importance of the war in the North against the white walkers, leading Jon to return to the Wall.
๐๏ธ Jon's Adventures Beyond the Wall
Beyond the Wall, Jon experiences a harsh reality that contrasts with hisๅนปๆณ็ๅ้ฉ็ๆดป. He learns that life is more complicated than he imagined, and good and evil are not always clear-cut. The Night's Watch's alliance with Craster, a man who sacrifices his sons to the white walkers, forces Jon to question the morality of the Watch. His encounter with Ygritte, a wildling, further complicates his understanding of the world, as he begins to see the wildlings as people, not just enemies.
๐น Jon's Struggle with Loyalty and Identity
Jon's struggle with his loyalty and identity intensifies when he is forced to kill Qhorin Halfhand to infiltrate the wildlings and discover their plans. This act of betrayal against his sworn brother and his subsequent acceptance by the wildlings, including his relationship with Ygritte, further blurs the lines between friend and foe. Jon's internal conflict is highlighted by his torn loyalties and his growing connection to the wildlings, despite his duty to the Night's Watch.
๐ก๏ธ Jon's Leadership and the Defense of Castle Black
As the wildling army led by Mance Rayder threatens Castle Black, Jon takes command after the death of Donal Noye. He employs strategic tactics, such as burning and collapsing stairs, to defend the Wall against the wildlings. This battle tests Jon's leadership and his commitment to the Night's Watch, as he must make difficult decisions to protect the realm, even if it means sacrificing his personal feelings.
๐ Jon's Election as Lord Commander and Future Challenges
Jon's election as the 998th Lord Commander of the Night's Watch marks a significant turning point in his journey. Despite initial resistance due to his bastard status and connection to the old gods, he gains support through political maneuvering and a sign from a talking raven. As commander, Jon faces the daunting task of uniting the Night's Watch and dealing with external threats, including Stannis Baratheon's ambitions and the ongoing conflict with the wildlings.
๐ฅ Jon's Resurrection and Transformation
Jon's death and potential resurrection are pivotal events that could transform his character. George R.R. Martin suggests that characters who return from death are changed, losing something of themselves. Theories about Jon's resurrection involve his spirit living on in his direwolf, Ghost, which could make him more wolfish and less human. This transformation could lead to a more reckless and dangerous Jon, focused on his own desires.
๐ Jon's Claim to Winterfell and the North
Jon's legal claim to Winterfell and the North is a significant aspect of his story. Robb Stark's will, which may name Jon as his heir, could lead to a complex inheritance struggle. Jon's desire for Winterfell and his potential role as King in the North are complicated by the return of other Stark siblings and the political machinations of various factions in the North.
๐ Jon's Connection to Daenerys and the Targaryen Legacy
Jon's connection to Daenerys Targaryen and the revelation of his true parentage could have profound implications for his identity and destiny. As the son of Lyanna Stark and Prince Rhaegar Targaryen, Jon is not only a Stark but also a Targaryen with a claim to the Iron Throne. This discovery could lead to a deeper bond with Daenerys, as well as a moral and emotional struggle as he grapples with his newfound royal heritage and the responsibilities it entails.
๐ฎ Jon's Role in the Prophecy of Azor Ahai
Jon's potential role as Azor Ahai reborn, the prophesied hero destined to fight against the darkness, adds another layer to his character's complexity. The prophecy suggests that Jon, with his ice and fire heritage, could be the one to wield a flaming sword against the white walkers. However, the fulfillment of this prophecy could come at a great cost, testing Jon's morality and his commitment to his duty.
โ๏ธ Jon's Final Battle Against the White Walkers
Jon's ultimate confrontation with the white walkers is set to be a defining moment in his story. Theories suggest that he might journey north to destroy the Great Other, the entity controlling the white walkers, possibly involving a sacrifice or a profound moral choice. The outcome of this battle could determine the fate of Westeros and the nature of Jon's heroism.
๐ Jon's Heroism and the Complexities of Being a Savior
Jon's heroism is not simply a result of prophecy or royal blood but is rooted in his choices and his commitment.
Mindmap
Keywords
๐กJon Snow
๐กMoral Dilemma
๐กInternal Conflict
๐กNight's Watch
๐กWildlings
๐กIdentity
๐กProphecy
๐กAzor Ahai
๐กWhite Walkers
๐กSelf-Sacrifice
๐กResurrection
๐กKing in the North
Highlights
Jon Snow is a complex character in the 'Game of Thrones' universe, evolving from a fantasy hero to a morally conflicted leader.
The TV adaptation of 'Game of Thrones' diverges from the books, particularly in the portrayal of Jon Snow.
TV Jon is depicted as a brave but 'stupid' warrior, while Book Jon is a more nuanced character with political acumen and moral complexity.
Jon's internal conflict between his desires and his duty is a central theme in the books, contrasting with his more straightforward portrayal in the TV show.
Jon's resurrection in the TV show is a pivotal plot point, but in the books, it is suggested to have deeper magical and prophetic implications.
The revelation of Jon's true parentage as the son of Lyanna Stark and Prince Rhaegar Targaryen is a significant twist with potential to redefine his identity and destiny.
Jon's relationship with his direwolf Ghost symbolizes his connection to his Stark heritage and the old gods.
Jon's struggle with his identity as a bastard and his search for a sense of belonging is a recurring theme throughout the series.
The Night's Watch and the wildlings represent contrasting ideologies and lifestyles that challenge Jon's beliefs and loyalties.
Jon's leadership style, particularly as the Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, is marked by difficult decisions and moral dilemmas.
The potential transformation of Jon Snow after his death and resurrection is a point of speculation, hinting at a deeper connection to magic and prophecy.
Jon's relationship with Daenerys Targaryen is complex, with potential romantic and political implications that could shape the future of Westeros.
The role of prophecy in Jon's life, particularly the prophecy of Azor Ahai, is a significant aspect of his character arc, suggesting a destined role in the world's fate.
The possibility of Jon making a peace deal with the White Walkers is a unique twist that challenges traditional fantasy tropes of good versus evil.
Jon's potential sacrifice to defeat the White Walkers, including the possibility of sacrificing Daenerys or his own life, is a key point of speculation in the books.
The exploration of Jon's moral compass and his struggle to balance duty, love, and the greater good is a central theme of his character development.
The potential for Jon to reject his Targaryen heritage and choose his own path, independent of prophecy or bloodline, is a significant aspect of his character's journey.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
What Killed Alexander the Great?
Why Caesar's Legion is Ultimately a GOOD thing for the WASTELAND - Fallout New Vegas Lore
Conflict in Literature
The American Revolution: Bloody Struggle For Freedom *3 HOUR MARATHON* | The Revolution
Wyatt Langford Responds to Huge MLB Prospect Hype & Chance to Make 2024 Texas Opening Roster
Quantum Physics & Quantum Theory | Discovery Science Channel Documentary Full HD
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: