The Disparity Between Abortion Rates for Communities of Color | EWTN News In Depth
TLDRThe video script discusses the complexities of abortion in America, highlighting data from the CDC and the Charlotte Lozier Institute. It reveals that while 60% of women seeking abortions have other children, a 15-year study shows a lower rate among low-income women with children. The conversation also touches on the racial disparity in abortion rates, with a disproportionate impact on the black community. The role of the pro-life movement in providing resources and healing is emphasized, along with the need for a comprehensive approach to support women and families.
Takeaways
- 📊 A New York Times article examined data from the CDC and the Guttmacher Institute, revealing that 60% of women seeking abortions already have children, and 42% have had one or more previous abortions.
- 🔍 The Charlotte Lozier Institute's study provided a broader perspective, focusing on Medicaid-enrolled women over 15 years and showing that 5.7% of women with children were getting abortions, while 92.8% of births were to women with no history of abortion.
- 👶 The study by the Charlotte Lozier Institute highlighted that abortion is relatively rare among low-income women with children, contradicting the New York Times' implication that women with children commonly seek abortions.
- 📈 The method of data collection varied between the studies, with the New York Times using CDC data from one year, while the Charlotte Lozier Institute analyzed a 15-year span of all pregnancy outcomes for Medicaid-enrolled women.
- 🔄 The Charlotte Lozier Institute found a pattern where women who had an abortion were more likely to have another in subsequent pregnancies, emphasizing the importance of abortion healing and support.
- 🏥 The discussion touched on the lack of data on race in CDC statistics, but available data suggests a disproportionate impact of abortion on the black community, with three times as many black women getting abortions compared to white women.
- 🌐 The issue of race was considered sensitive by the New York Times, which did not delve into it due to incomplete data, but the disproportionate rates of abortion among black women were noted as a significant concern.
- 🏛 Christina Bennett, a voice in the pro-life movement, especially within black communities, confirmed the targeting of black communities by the abortion industry, particularly Planned Parenthood.
- 💔 Bennett argued against the notion that abortion helps lift women out of poverty, stating that despite nearly 50 years of legal abortion, black communities continue to suffer from high rates of single parenthood, maternal, and infant mortality.
- 🤝 The pro-life movement is working to reach out to women, especially those of color and low-income, offering resources and support to prevent repeat abortions and promote healing.
- 🌟 The conversation emphasized the need for the pro-life movement to build bridges within communities, particularly in reaching out to black churches and community leaders to foster understanding and support.
Q & A
What was the main focus of the New York Times article titled 'Who's getting abortions in America'?
-The article examined data from the Centers for Disease Control and the Guttmacher Institute to report on the demographics of women seeking abortions in the United States, including the fact that 60 percent of these women have other children and 42 percent have had one or more previous abortions.
What did the Charlotte Lozier Institute study reveal about women who have children and seek abortions?
-The study, which looked at Medicaid-enrolled women over a 15-year period, found that only 5.7 percent of women who had children were getting abortions, suggesting that abortion is quite rare for low-income women who already have children.
How does the method of data collection differ between the New York Times report and the Charlotte Lozier Institute study?
-The New York Times report used CDC data from a single year (2019), while the Charlotte Lozier Institute study examined Medicaid-enrolled women from 1999 to 2014, considering all pregnancy outcomes including births, abortions, and miscarriages.
What was the finding regarding the likelihood of a woman having a subsequent abortion after her first one?
-The Charlotte Lozier Institute study found that if a woman had an abortion, she was more likely to have another one in the subsequent pregnancy.
What is the role of the pro-life movement in addressing the issue of abortion, according to the script?
-The pro-life movement is focused on providing support for women who have had abortions, helping them work through the trauma and offering alternatives to abortion, such as adoption and resources for child care and housing.
How does the script address the issue of race in relation to abortion in the United States?
-The script notes that CDC data indicates a disproportionate impact of abortion on the black community, with three times as many black women getting abortions compared to white women. It also mentions the high rate of abortions among black babies in New York City.
What is the stance of the pro-life movement on the targeting of the black community by the abortion industry?
-The pro-life movement, as represented by the speakers in the script, denounces the targeting of the black community by the abortion industry and is working to reach out to these women with support and resources.
How does Christina Bennett, a voice in the pro-life movement, describe the impact of abortion on the black community over the past 50 years?
-Christina Bennett argues that abortion has not helped the black community prosper or grow, citing high rates of single parent families, maternal mortality, and infant mortality as ongoing issues.
What are some of the resources and support that the pro-life movement is advocating for to help women avoid abortion?
-The movement is advocating for affordable housing, paid parental leave, and resources through pregnancy resource centers to support women in their choice to carry pregnancies to term.
How does the script discuss the importance of building bridges within the pro-life movement to include more black and minority communities?
-The script suggests that the pro-life movement should actively engage with black churches, student unions, and community leaders to foster connections and offer support, emphasizing the importance of shared values like faith and community love.
What is the significance of the Dobbs case from Mississippi in the context of the pro-life movement?
-The Dobbs case is significant because it has the potential to overturn the Roe v. Wade and Casey decisions, which would have a major impact on abortion laws and the pro-life movement's efforts to reduce the number of abortions.
Outlines
📊 Overview of Abortion Studies and Key Findings
The New York Times examined data from the CDC and the Guttmacher Institute, revealing that 60% of women seeking abortions have children, and 42% have had previous abortions. The Charlotte Lozier Institute provided a broader study over 15 years, focusing on Medicaid-enrolled women, showing that abortion among low-income women with children is rare. The contrasting methods and time spans of these studies highlight different perspectives on abortion in America.
🧮 Differences in Abortion Data Collection
The New York Times used CDC data from 2019 to analyze abortion rates among women with children, while the Charlotte Lozier Institute examined Medicaid data from 1999 to 2014. The latter study included all pregnancy outcomes, revealing broader patterns. One finding was that women who have had abortions are more likely to have subsequent abortions. Pro-life advocates emphasize the need for abortion healing to prevent repeat abortions.
📉 Racial Disparities in Abortion Rates
The CDC lacks complete racial data on abortions from 20 states, but existing data shows significant disparities: Black women have abortions at three times the rate of white women. In New York City, more Black babies are aborted than born alive. This disproportionate impact on the Black community raises concerns about targeting.
🤝 Pro-Life Movement's Response to Abortion Trends
Pro-life advocates focus on addressing the trauma and lack of resources that lead women to choose abortion. The movement aims to provide healing and support for low-income women to prevent repeat abortions and to help them choose life.
👶 Targeting of Black and Brown Women for Abortions
Christina Bennett from Middletown, Connecticut, discusses the targeting of Black and brown women by the abortion industry, particularly Planned Parenthood. She argues that abortion has not alleviated poverty in the Black community, which still faces high rates of single parenthood, maternal mortality, and infant mortality.
🏛️ Pro-Life Efforts Post-Roe v. Wade
Bennett discusses the extensive pro-life work needed if Roe v. Wade is overturned. She highlights the need for affordable housing, paid parental leave, and resources to support women and families. Pregnancy resource centers play a crucial role, but broader community involvement is essential.
✊ Addressing White Supremacy in the Pro-Life Movement
The March for Life condemned the presence of a white supremacist group. Bennett emphasizes that white supremacy has no place in the pro-life movement, which is inclusive and compassionate. She supports efforts to denounce racism and to build bridges within the community.
🤝 Building Bridges in the Pro-Life Movement
Bennett advocates for greater engagement with the Black community by pro-life organizations. This includes collaborating with Black churches and student groups to foster understanding and support for pro-life initiatives, emphasizing shared values like faith and community.
🌟 Hope and Intentionality in Pro-Life Advocacy
Bennett believes in the potential for Black political candidates to support pro-life issues. She underscores the importance of prayer, education, and intentional outreach to Black leaders to build support for pro-life policies.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Abortion
💡Centers for Disease Control (CDC)
💡Charlotte Lozier Institute
💡Pregnancy Outcomes
💡Pro-Life Movement
💡Race
💡Planned Parenthood
💡Supreme Court Decision
💡Pregnancy Resource Centers
💡Pro-Black Pro-Life
💡White Supremacy
Highlights
60 percent of women who seek an abortion have other children.
42 percent of women getting an abortion have had one or more previous abortions.
Charlotte Lozier Institute's study examined a 15-year span of all pregnancy outcomes for Medicaid enrolled women.
Only 5.7% of women with children were getting abortions during the study period.
92.8% of births were from women who had no abortion in the 15-year study.
Abortion rare for low-income women with children, according to the Charlotte Lozier Institute's findings.
Differences in data collection methods between the New York Times and Charlotte Lozier Institute.
Women who have had an abortion are more likely to have another in subsequent pregnancies.
Pro-life movement focusing on abortion healing and support to prevent subsequent abortions.
Miscarriages are a significant but often overlooked aspect of the abortion discussion.
CDC does not collect race information from 20 states, affecting the completeness of racial data on abortions.
Disproportionate impact of abortion on the black community, with three times more black women getting abortions compared to white women.
High rates of black babies aborted in New York City, a concerning statistic.
Pro-life advocates working to reach women and address the root causes of abortion, not just the procedure itself.
The need for resources and healing in the pro-life movement to support women facing difficult choices.
Christina Bennett discusses the targeting of the black community by the abortion industry, particularly Planned Parenthood.
The myth that abortion helps lift women out of poverty is debunked, with ongoing struggles in the black community despite 50 years of abortion availability.
The importance of building bridges within the black community to promote pro-life values and support.
Christina Bennett's involvement with Pro Black Pro-Life and efforts to integrate pro-life messages into the black community.
The need for intentional action and education to reach black leaders and politicians on the abortion issue.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
How abortion bans make inequality worse
Inside the fight to slash the maternal mortality rate in the South | 60 Minutes
What Happens When We Deny People Abortions? | Diana Greene Foster | TED
4 ways Americans are still getting abortion pills
20 Domestic Violence Statistics
Pregnant and trapped: Guatemala’s child sex abuse crisis | Unreported World
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: