The surprising beauty of mathematics | Jonathan Matte | TEDxGreensFarmsAcademy

TEDx Talks
9 Aug 201309:14
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this engaging script, the speaker explores Plato's 'Meno' dialogue, where Socrates awakens mathematical knowledge in a slave boy, suggesting innate knowledge in the soul. The speaker then shares personal stories of discovering Möbius strips and the Archimedean Spiral through doodling, illustrating the interplay between inherent talents and external inspiration. The talk encourages exploration and conversation to unearth and understand the knowledge within us, questioning whether it's solely innate or also shaped by experiences.

Takeaways
  • 📚 The script discusses Plato's 'Meno' dialogue, highlighting the philosophical question of the origin of knowledge and the idea that knowledge may be innate, waiting to be reawakened.
  • 🗣️ It uses the example of Socrates' conversation with a slave boy to illustrate the concept that knowledge can be brought to the surface through questioning.
  • 🤔 The speaker reflects on personal experiences that relate to the idea of innate knowledge, suggesting that there might be undiscovered talents or knowledge within us.
  • 🎓 The speaker's fifth-grade experience with creating a Möbius strip unknowingly foreshadowed their later interest in mathematics.
  • 😄 The humor in the script serves to engage the audience and make complex philosophical concepts more accessible.
  • 🔍 The script encourages exploration and curiosity, suggesting that we should actively seek out knowledge rather than passively wait for it to be reawakened.
  • 🎨 The speaker's encounter with Escher's art, which incorporates Möbius strips, demonstrates how exposure to new ideas can spark interest and understanding.
  • 📈 The doodle that the speaker unknowingly created as a high school student was an Archimedean Spiral, showing that mathematical concepts can be found in everyday life.
  • 🤓 The script emphasizes the importance of conversation and exposure to ideas, suggesting that these are crucial for unlocking and understanding the knowledge within us.
  • 🧠 It challenges the strict interpretation of Plato's theory, proposing that a combination of innate knowledge and external exposure to ideas is necessary for learning.
  • 💡 The speaker concludes by emphasizing the beauty of discovery and the importance of recognizing and pursuing what we find beautiful, as it can lead to personal growth and understanding.
Q & A

  • What is the central theme of the dialogue 'Meno' by Plato?

    -The central theme of 'Meno' is the exploration of the origin of knowledge, specifically whether knowledge is innate or acquired through learning.

  • Who does Plato call upon to discuss the nature of knowledge in 'Meno'?

    -Plato calls upon his old friend, Socrates, to engage in a conversation with a slave boy to explore the nature of knowledge.

  • What does Socrates demonstrate with the slave boy in the 'Meno' dialogue?

    -Socrates demonstrates that the slave boy is able to prove a rigorous formula about the area of a square, suggesting that knowledge may be innate and just needs to be reawakened.

  • What is the significance of the slave boy's ability to prove the formula in the dialogue?

    -The significance is that it supports Plato's theory of innate knowledge, or that knowledge is already present in the soul and can be brought to consciousness through questioning.

  • What did the speaker do differently when tasked with representing the number 100 in fifth grade?

    -Instead of forming a link as instructed, the speaker gave the paper a half twist, inadvertently creating a Möbius strip.

  • What is a Möbius strip and what happens when you cut one?

    -A Möbius strip is a surface with only one side and one boundary. When you cut it all the way around and through, it remains in one continuous piece.

  • What did the speaker discover about their doodle in college?

    -The speaker discovered that their doodle was an Archimedean Spiral, a mathematical concept that other mathematicians found relevant and exciting.

  • What is an Archimedean Spiral and how does it relate to the speaker's doodle?

    -An Archimedean Spiral is a simple mathematical function that forms a spiral pattern when connecting dots in an incremental pattern. The speaker's doodle unknowingly represented this concept.

  • What role does conversation play in the process of knowledge acquisition according to the speaker?

    -According to the speaker, conversation plays a crucial role in knowledge acquisition as it exposes one to ideas and helps in harnessing and expressing the knowledge that may be within.

  • What is the speaker's stance on the idea of innate knowledge?

    -The speaker is not wholly sold on the idea that all knowledge is innate and just waiting to be reawakened. They believe that exposure to ideas and conversation are also essential for knowledge to surface.

  • What does the speaker suggest about the presence of unknown potential within each individual?

    -The speaker suggests that each individual has something within them, possibly unknown, that could be considered beautiful or valuable, and that it's important to explore and discover what that might be.

Outlines
00:00
📚 Plato's Theory of Innate Knowledge

The first paragraph discusses Plato's exploration of the origin of knowledge in the dialogue 'Meno.' It narrates a hypothetical conversation between Socrates and a slave boy, where Socrates uses questioning to reveal the boy's inherent knowledge of geometry. The story illustrates Plato's belief in the recollection of knowledge that is already present in the soul. The paragraph also introduces the speaker's personal experiences, hinting at the theme of innate knowledge and its potential awakening through questioning.

05:01
🎨 Discovering the Möbius Strip and Archimedean Spiral

The second paragraph recounts the speaker's experiences with two mathematical concepts: the Möbius strip and the Archimedean Spiral. As a child, the speaker unknowingly created a Möbius strip during a school assignment, finding it more interesting than the task itself. Later, the speaker's doodle, which resembled an Archimedean Spiral, was found to be relevant and intriguing in the mathematical community. The paragraph emphasizes the idea that knowledge or understanding might not be solely innate but can also be discovered through exploration and exposure to new ideas. The speaker concludes by suggesting that a combination of innate knowledge and external stimuli may be necessary for learning and understanding.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Knowledge
Knowledge refers to the understanding, awareness, or familiarity gained through experience or education. In the video, the theme of knowledge is explored through Plato's dialogue 'Meno,' where Socrates engages in a conversation with a slave boy to demonstrate that knowledge is innate and can be reawakened through questioning. The video suggests that knowledge may not just be pre-existing but also requires the right prompts or questions to be fully realized.
💡Socrates
Socrates was a classical Greek philosopher credited as one of the founders of Western philosophy. In the script, Socrates is depicted as using dialogue to reveal inherent knowledge within an individual, specifically a slave boy, which is a central theme of the 'Meno' dialogue and a key point in the video's exploration of knowledge and learning.
💡Meno
Meno is one of Plato's dialogues, named after Meno, a friend of the tyrant of Thessaly. In the video, the dialogue 'Meno' is referenced to illustrate Plato's theory of a priori knowledge, where Socrates helps a slave boy deduce a geometric proof, suggesting that knowledge is innate and not learned through experience alone.
💡Möbius Strip
A Möbius strip is a surface with only one side and one boundary, formed by taking a strip of paper, giving it a half-twist, and then joining the ends together. In the video, the speaker recounts an experience from fifth grade where they unknowingly created a Möbius strip, which serves as a metaphor for the unexpected and non-linear nature of learning and discovery.
💡Archimedean Spiral
The Archimedean spiral is a type of spiral named after the ancient Greek mathematician Archimedes. It is a simple mathematical function that forms a spiral pattern when plotted. In the video, the speaker's doodle, which they later discovered was an Archimedean spiral, represents the idea that mathematical concepts can be found in everyday life and can be a source of beauty and intrigue.
💡Innate Knowledge
Innate knowledge refers to knowledge that is inherent or inborn, not acquired through learning or experience. The video discusses the concept of innate knowledge through the example of the slave boy in 'Meno,' suggesting that people may have knowledge within them that simply needs the right circumstances to be uncovered.
💡Recreational Mathematics
Recreational mathematics is a type of mathematics that is done for fun, often involving puzzles and games. In the script, the speaker mentions exploring recreational mathematics in the library, which led to their discovery of Möbius strips and Escher's art, illustrating the joy and discovery that can come from engaging with mathematics outside of a formal educational setting.
💡Escher
Maurits Cornelis Escher was a Dutch graphic artist known for his mathematically inspired works, including the use of Möbius strips in his art. In the video, the speaker connects their childhood experience with Möbius strips to Escher's art, showing how mathematical concepts can be expressed in creative and visually appealing ways.
💡Doodle
A doodle is a simple drawing made while a person's attention is otherwise occupied. In the video, the speaker's doodle of an Archimedean spiral is a key element, demonstrating how even a casual, seemingly unimportant act can lead to a deeper understanding of mathematical concepts.
💡Conversation
In the context of the video, a conversation is not just verbal exchange but also a metaphor for the process of learning and discovery. The speaker suggests that having conversations and being exposed to ideas are crucial for unlocking and understanding the knowledge that may be within us.
💡Beauty
Beauty, in the video, is used to describe the aesthetic appeal and the emotional response to mathematical concepts and their visual representations, such as the Archimedean spiral and Escher's art. It suggests that the appreciation of beauty can be a powerful motivator for exploring and understanding complex ideas.
Highlights

Plato's 'Meno' dialogue explores the origin of knowledge through Socrates' conversation with a slave boy.

Socrates demonstrates the innate knowledge of geometry in the slave boy, suggesting knowledge is reawakened rather than learned.

The speaker's fifth-grade experience with creating a Möbius strip unknowingly introduced them to a mathematical concept.

The Möbius strip's unique property of remaining a single piece after a complete cut is highlighted.

The speaker's doodle in high school unknowingly represented an Archimedean Spiral, a simple mathematical function.

The discovery of the speaker's doodle on the cover of 'The College Mathematics Journal' underscores the relevance of their unconscious creation.

The speaker's personal journey reflects on the idea that knowledge may not just be innate but also requires exposure and conversation to be fully realized.

The importance of asking questions and engaging in dialogue to awaken and understand the knowledge within us is emphasized.

The speaker's experiences with Möbius strips and Archimedean Spirals illustrate the intersection of play, curiosity, and mathematical discovery.

The concept of the Möbius strip is used to challenge and extend Plato's theory of innate knowledge.

The speaker encourages the audience to explore the Möbius strip further, suggesting that knowledge may be waiting to be uncovered through curiosity.

The idea that knowledge is not just pre-existing but also shaped by our experiences and interactions is presented.

The speaker's story about doodling and later recognizing it as an Archimedean Spiral highlights the potential for unrecognized mathematical insight in everyday activities.

The role of teaching and learning in facilitating the discovery and understanding of innate knowledge is discussed.

The speaker's narrative suggests that both innate knowledge and external exposure are crucial for intellectual growth.

The beauty of mathematical concepts and the joy of discovery are celebrated as key motivators for learning.

The speaker concludes by suggesting that the source of knowledge may be a combination of both innate understanding and external experiences.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

How to Speak English With Confidence: 5 Simple Steps

Plato and Aristotle: Crash Course History of Science #3

Why some people feel destined to study physics

Mysticism in Ancient Greece

What they don't tell you about entrepreneurship | Mark Leruste | TEDxCardiff

How to Study Physics Effectively | Study With Me Physics Edition

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Innate KnowledgeMathematicsPersonal GrowthSocratic MethodMöbius StripArchimedean SpiralEducational InsightCreative ThinkingAncient DialogueMental ExplorationPlatonic Ideas