Why The Allies Couldn't Overcome German Trenches in Spring 1917 (WW1 Documentary)

The Great War
22 Apr 202228:34
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn 1917, the Western Front saw ambitious offensives by the Allies, aiming to break the deadlock of trench warfare. Despite initial gains, such as the Canadian Corps' success at Vimy Ridge, the French-led Nivelle Offensive and the British support at the Battle of Arras ultimately faltered against Germany's innovative defensive tactics. The German 'elastic defense in depth' and their strategic withdrawal to the Hindenburg Line proved effective, leading to heavy casualties and a stalemate that persisted. The failure of these offensives highlighted the ongoing challenges of trench warfare and the need for new tactics to achieve a decisive breakthrough.

  • ๐Ÿ‡ซ๐Ÿ‡ท In 1916, the Western Front battles showed that even victories resulted in massive losses with minimal territorial gains, leading to a manpower crisis for both sides.
  • ๐ŸŽ– By early 1917, the stalemate on the Western Front prompted commanders to develop new tactics to break the deadlock, with the French planning a large multi-front offensive.
  • ๐Ÿ‘ค French Commander-in-Chief Joseph Joffre was replaced by General Robert Nivelle, who was confident after his victory at Verdun and proposed a plan involving mass artillery and infantry assaults.
  • ๐Ÿค British and French forces compromised on operational control, with the British armies supporting the French attack but remaining under British control.
  • ๐Ÿ”„ The German Empire adapted to its manpower shortage by developing new defensive tactics, including the 'elastic defense in depth' and the construction of the Hindenburg Line.
  • ๐Ÿ’ฅ The British learned from past mistakes, adopting new assault tactics that emphasized small unit movement, decentralized command, and increased firepower.
  • ๐Ÿšœ The use of tanks and improved artillery coordination, such as the rolling barrage technique, became crucial for the British offensive efforts.
  • ๐ŸŒŸ The Battle of Aras and the subsequent offensives saw some successes, like the Canadian Corps' capture of Vimy Ridge, but also failures due to poor planning and execution.
  • ๐ŸŒง๏ธ The Nivelle Offensive, launched in April 1917, faced numerous challenges including bad weather, reinforced German defenses, and a lack of ammunition.
  • ๐Ÿ›‘ Despite initial gains, the French offensive ultimately failed, leading to high casualties and mutinies among French troops, resulting in Nivelle's replacement.
  • ๐Ÿ“š The script highlights the complexities and evolving tactics of trench warfare during WWI, emphasizing the importance of adapting to new information and enemy strategies.
Q & A
  • What was the general situation on the Western Front in early 1917?

    -In early 1917, after two and a half years of fighting, the Western Front had not moved significantly. The Germans had mostly held their early war gains and inflicted terrible casualties on the British and French, but they were also running short of manpower.

  • What was the strategic goal of the French plan devised by Joseph Joffre in November 1916?

    -Joffre's plan aimed for offensives on the Italian and Russian fronts to support a major Franco-British push in the west, with the objective of pushing the Germans out of France.

  • Why was the plan by French Commander-in-Chief Joseph Joffre not well received by the new British Prime Minister David Lloyd George?

    -David Lloyd George called Joffre's plan a complete farce, criticizing it for repeating the bloody and futile tactics of 1915 and 1916, which involved using human flesh and sinews to attack the strongest fortresses of the enemy.

  • Who replaced Joseph Joffre and what changes did he bring to the French plan?

    -General Robert Nivelle replaced Joseph Joffre. Nivelle, confident after his victory at Verdun, tweaked the plan to fit his style, which involved mass artillery followed by infantry assaults on narrow fronts.

  • What were the main concerns of British Commander Field Marshal Douglas Haig regarding the French plan?

    -Field Marshal Douglas Haig was concerned by rumors that his forces would fall under French leadership, which he believed would be detrimental to morale and effectiveness, stating that British troops would not fight under French command.

  • What was the significance of the German shift to a defensive strategy in 1916?

    -The shift to a defensive strategy was significant because it allowed the Germans to better conserve their manpower, which was dwindling due to heavy losses. They developed new principles of elastic defense in depth, which included a withdrawal to a shorter and more defensible Hindenburg Line.

  • How did the British army adapt its tactics after the failures of 1916?

    -The British army began to adopt new assault tactics that relied more on tactical movement at the platoon level, with troops advancing in open formation and moving from cover to cover. They also decentralized the command structure, allowing junior officers to take more initiative.

  • What was the significance of the Battle of Vimy Ridge in the Battle of Aras?

    -The Battle of Vimy Ridge was significant because it was one of the most successful British actions during the Battle of Aras. The Canadians, with British infantry and artillery support, captured most of the ridge in just one day, demonstrating the effectiveness of the new tactics.

  • What were the key issues faced by the French during the Nivelle Offensive?

    -The French faced several issues during the Nivelle Offensive, including abysmal weather that slowed the advance, practical air superiority by the Germans, reinforced German defenses, and a failure to achieve a quick breakthrough due to the German elastic defense tactics.

  • What was the outcome of the Nivelle Offensive and what were its consequences?

    -The Nivelle Offensive failed to achieve a breakthrough and resulted in heavy French casualties. It led to a loss of morale and mutinies among French troops, and Nivelle was replaced in May. His rigid adherence to his plan, despite changing circumstances and evidence of its flaws, was heavily criticized.

๐ŸŒ Stalemate and Strategic Shifts on the Western Front

In 1916, the Western Front battles of WWI demonstrated the futility of trench warfare with minimal territorial gains at the cost of massive casualties. Both British, French, and German forces faced a manpower crisis, prompting commanders to develop new tactics. The French Commander-in-Chief, Joseph Joffre, planned a large multi-front offensive for 1917 to push the Germans out of France. However, the plan was criticized by the new British Prime Minister, David Lloyd George, for its repetition of previous failed tactics. By January 1917, with Russia and Italy unable to sustain major offensives, General Robert Nivelle took over and adapted the plan to his preferred style, focusing on mass artillery and infantry assaults. The plan included a British diversionary attack to distract German reserves. Despite concerns over French leadership, a compromise was reached to keep British forces under British control. Meanwhile, the German Empire also adapted, shifting from offensive to defensive tactics, developing the principles of elastic defense in depth, and constructing the Hindenburg Line to consolidate their positions and free up divisions for other fronts.

๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ German Defensive Innovations and Allied Tactical Evolution

The German army introduced the concept of 'elastic defense in depth' in late 1916, allowing them to absorb and counter-attack Allied offensives more effectively. This strategy involved a three-sector defense system, with lightly defended forward trenches, a main line of resistance with reinforced positions, and a rear battle zone for counterattacks. The Germans also utilized reverse slopes to protect their machine gun positions from enemy artillery. Operation Albrecht in early 1917 saw a significant withdrawal to the Hindenburg Line, shortening the front and freeing up German divisions. Meanwhile, the British army, having learned from previous mistakes, began to adopt new assault tactics emphasizing small unit movement, decentralized command, and prioritizing enfilade fire. New weapons like the Lewis machine gun and rifle grenades were introduced to increase platoon firepower, and artillery tactics were refined to improve effectiveness.

๐Ÿšœ The Battle of Aras: Successes and Failures of New Tactics

On April 9, 1917, the British diversionary offensive, the Battle of Aras, commenced with the participation of 18 British divisions, 3,000 guns, and 48 tanks. The Canadian Corps' attack at Vimy Ridge was notably successful, with the use of new tactics and counter-battery fire allowing them to capture the ridge quickly. However, south of Aras, the Australians and New Zealanders faced difficulties due to inadequate artillery support and reliance on tanks, which were ill-prepared and often failed to reach the German lines. The Anzacs were pushed back to their starting positions, marking a failure for that part of the offensive. The successes and failures of the Battle of Aras highlighted the importance of preparation, coordination, and the effectiveness of new tactics in breaking the trench deadlock.

๐ŸŽ–๏ธ The Nivelle Offensive: High Hopes and Crushing Defeats

Despite the mixed results of the Battle of Aras, the main Allied effort focused on the Aisne sector, where General Nivelle's offensive was set to break the stalemate. The French plan involved three army groups, with the Reserve Army Group leading the assault to achieve a breakthrough within 48 hours, followed by a battle of maneuver in the German rear. Nivelle's tactics relied on narrow penetrations and breakthroughs with massive artillery support. However, internal doubts and evidence of German awareness of the impending attack raised concerns. The offensive began on April 16th with a massive barrage, but quickly faltered due to uncut wire, concrete emplacements, and the German's effective elastic defense tactics. French troops suffered heavy casualties, and by April 20th, it was clear that the offensive had failed. The failure of Nivelle's offensive led to his replacement in May and widespread disillusionment among French troops, culminating in mutiny.

๐Ÿฐ Lessons Learned: The Impact of Nivelle's Offensive on Future Strategy

The failure of Nivelle's offensive in 1917 underscored the ongoing challenges of trench warfare and the need for adaptive military strategies. Nivelle's inability to deviate from his established plan, despite new information and changing circumstances, was a critical error. His assumption that the German defenders would be passive and fight as they had at Verdun in 1916 proved incorrect, as the Germans had adopted new tactics that allowed them to maintain the initiative even on the defensive. The battles of Aras and the Aisne, while initially showing promise, ultimately resulted in protracted and indecisive fighting. The experiences of spring 1917 highlighted the necessity for tactical innovation and the recognition that in warfare, the enemy's actions are a critical variable that must be accounted for in planning and execution.

๐Ÿ“š The Great War Channel and the Quest for Unrestricted Military History Content

The Great War channel, a production of Real-Time History, focuses on military history, providing in-depth content on topics like the 1917 Spring Offensive. However, due to the fluctuating advertising rules on platforms like YouTube, which can lead to demonetization of such content, the creators are building a new streaming platform called Nebula. This service aims to provide a space for military history content without the risk of censorship or demonetization, allowing for a wider range of historical documentaries and discussions. The channel also acknowledges the contribution of Mark Newton in helping with their episodes and encourages viewers to explore the sources provided in the video description for further information.

๐Ÿ’กWestern Front
The Western Front refers to the main battle line between the Allies and the Central Powers during World War I, running from the English Channel to the Swiss border. In the video's context, it is where the bloody battles of 1916 took place, resulting in minimal territorial gains and massive casualties, highlighting the stalemate and the need for new tactics.
๐Ÿ’กManpower Crisis
A manpower crisis refers to a situation where an army or nation lacks sufficient personnel to maintain its military operations. In the video, it is mentioned that both British, French, and German commanders were dealing with this crisis, which necessitated the development of new tactics to conserve resources and maintain the fighting force.
๐Ÿ’กElastic Defense
Elastic Defense is a military tactic where forces intentionally give ground to an advancing enemy, allowing them to expend energy and resources, before counter-attacking when the enemy is vulnerable. The video explains that the Germans adopted this tactic in response to their losses, creating a defense in depth that made them a tougher opponent.
Verdun refers to the Battle of Verdun, one of the longest and most devastating battles of World War I, which took place in 1916. The video mentions Verdun as a context for General Robert Nivelle's confidence, stemming from his victory there, and his subsequent plan for a new offensive.
Aras, mentioned in the script, refers to both the town and the battle that took place there in April 1917. The Battle of Aras was a British offensive that aimed to divert German attention and resources away from the main French offensive in the Aisne sector. It is an example of a localized success within the broader context of the stalemate.
Mutiny is an open rebellion against authority, particularly within a military context. The video describes how the failure of Nivelle's offensive led to a significant number of French troops mutinying, which underscores the severity of the situation and the desperation of the soldiers.
๐Ÿ’กTrench Warfare
Trench Warfare describes the type of fighting that took place primarily on the Western Front during World War I, where opposing armies faced each other across a network of trenches. The video discusses the Allies' struggle to break the deadlock of trench warfare and the tactical innovations they attempted to employ.
๐Ÿ’กNivelle's Offensive
Nivelle's Offensive, also known as the Second Battle of the Aisne or the Chemin des Dames Offensive, was a major French attack in 1917. The video details how this ambitious plan, led by General Robert Nivelle, aimed to break through German lines but ultimately failed, leading to his replacement and widespread disillusionment among French troops.
๐Ÿ’กMachine Guns
Machine guns are automatic firearms capable of firing rounds in quick succession. In the context of the video, they were a critical defensive weapon for the Germans, particularly when placed on reverse slopes, which allowed them to surprise and inflict heavy casualties on attacking forces.
๐Ÿ’กChemin des Dames
The Chemin des Dames refers to a ridge in northern France and the site of the failed Nivelle Offensive. The video discusses how this offensive was intended to be a decisive blow against the Germans but instead resulted in heavy losses and mutiny among French soldiers, marking a turning point in the war.

In 1916, the Western Front battles showed that even victory resulted in heavy losses with minimal territorial gains.

Both sides faced a growing manpower crisis and commanders sought new tactics for the ongoing war.

French Commander-in-Chief Joseph Joffre planned a multi-front offensive to push Germans out of France.

British Prime Minister David Lloyd George criticized the plan as repeating the mistakes of previous years.

General Robert Nivelle took over from Joffre and modified the plan to include a British diversionary attack.

Field Marshal Douglas Haig was concerned about British forces falling under French leadership.

A compromise was reached where British armies would support the French attack but remain under British control.

German commanders accepted a move to the defense due to difficulty replenishing losses.

The German 'elastic defense in depth' strategy was developed, allowing them to withdraw and counterattack effectively.

Operation Alberich saw the German withdrawal to the Hindenburg Line, shortening the front and freeing up divisions.

British troops began adopting new assault tactics with more emphasis on tactical movement and decentralization of command.

The Battle of Aras saw the Canadian Corps successfully capture Vimy Ridge using new tactics and artillery support.

Anzac forces faced difficulties and failed to make significant progress south of Aras due to lack of preparation and support.

General Nivelle's offensive aimed for a quick breakthrough but faced internal criticism and loss of the element of surprise.

The French introduced tactical changes focusing on increased firepower and faster rolling barrages.

Despite initial gains, the French offensive failed due to weather, reinforced German defenses, and ammunition shortages.

Nivelle's plan was criticized for not adapting to new information and underestimating the German defense.

The battles of Aras and the Ais showed some tactical successes but ultimately resulted in stalemate and heavy casualties.

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: