✅Types of Research Papers | Journals or Conferences? | Journal vs Conference papers | Research paper

Prof. Rahul Pandya - IIT Dharwad
29 Mar 202205:38
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRDr. Rahul Pandya's video elucidates the distinctions between journal and conference papers. Conferences offer a platform for researchers to present and discuss their work, with papers typically being 4-5 pages and published in proceedings. Journals, on the other hand, publish more extensive articles, undergo a more rigorous review, and do not require registration fees. The video advises early-career researchers to attend conferences for networking and feedback, while highlighting that journal articles carry more weight in academia.

Takeaways
  • 📚 A conference is an event for researchers to present and discuss their work, seek feedback, and network.
  • 🎓 Early phase researchers and students are encouraged to attend conferences to establish a collaborative network.
  • 📝 To participate in a conference, researchers submit a 4-5 page summary of their work, which is peer-reviewed and published in the conference proceedings if accepted.
  • 🗞️ A journal publishes full-length, comprehensive research articles on a regular basis, such as quarterly or monthly.
  • 🔍 Journal articles undergo a more rigorous and sophisticated review process compared to conference papers.
  • 📈 Journal articles can range from 8-10 pages for high-quality research to 20-30 pages for comprehensive review articles.
  • 🕒 The review process for conferences is typically shorter with a fixed timeline of 1-3 months, while journals have a flexible timeline of 1-12 months.
  • 🤝 Conferences are ideal for beginners and researchers looking to expand their network, while journals are more suitable for intermediate and experienced researchers.
  • 🏅 Journal papers carry more weight on a CV compared to conference papers, which have low to medium weightage.
  • 💰 There is usually no registration fee for publishing in journals, but authors may pay an open access fee if they want their article to be freely accessible.
  • 🔄 Excellent conference papers may be invited for submission to journals, but they are still subject to the journal's review process.
Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of a conference according to the video?

    -The main purpose of a conference is to provide a platform for researchers worldwide to participate, present their research, seek feedback, strengthen their network, and establish research collaborations.

  • Why is it advisable for students in the early research phase to participate in conferences?

    -It is advisable for students in the early research phase to participate in conferences to present their research, seek comments and suggestions, and establish a collaborative network.

  • What is the typical length of a paper submitted to a conference?

    -The typical length of a paper submitted to a conference is a summary of the research work in 4-5 pages as per the predefined format.

  • How are conference papers peer-reviewed and what happens after acceptance?

    -Conference papers are peer-reviewed by a review panel following a fixed timeline. If accepted, authors are invited to register and present their papers during the conference, and the final paper is published once presented.

  • What is the term used for the collection of presented papers at a conference?

    -The collection of presented papers at a conference is often known as the conference proceedings.

  • How does the publication process of a journal article differ from that of a conference paper?

    -Journal articles are full-length and comprehensive, undergo a more rigorous review process than conference papers, and are published online within a few days or months of acceptance without the need for physical presentations.

  • What are the differences in the review process between conference papers and journal articles?

    -The review process for conference papers is shorter, with generally one iteration of review, while journals have a more rigorous process with multiple iterations demanding significant revisions.

  • How does the expected complexity of work differ between conference papers and journal articles?

    -The expected complexity of work in conference papers is medium, whereas in journal papers, the outcome is expected to be at the highest level of complexity.

  • What is the typical page length for a high-quality journal article according to the video?

    -The typical page length for a high-quality journal article is approximately 8-10 pages, with comprehensive review articles covering 20-30 pages.

  • How do conference papers and journal articles differ in terms of weightage on a CV?

    -Conference papers carry low to medium weightage on a CV, whereas journal articles are rated high and bring more significant weightage compared to conference papers.

  • What is the difference in registration fees between conferences and journals?

    -Authors have to register and pay a fee if their paper is accepted for a conference, whereas there is no registration fee for publishing in journals. However, an open access fee may apply if authors want their journal article to be accessible to all.

Outlines
00:00
📚 Introduction to Journals and Conferences

Dr. Rahul Pandya welcomes viewers to the channel and introduces the topic of the video, which is to explain the fundamental differences between journal and conference papers. He encourages viewers to subscribe, hit the bell icon for notifications, and like the video if they find it informative. The video aims to answer common questions among early-phase researchers and students regarding the nature of journals and conferences, the distinctions between their respective papers, and where they should publish their work. The video outlines the purpose of conferences as events for presenting research and networking, and it advises students to participate in conferences for feedback and collaboration. It also describes the process of submitting a paper to a conference, including drafting a summary, peer-review, and presentation. The video contrasts this with the process of submitting to a journal, which involves full-length articles, a more rigorous review process, and no physical gathering. It concludes with a summary of the differences, emphasizing that conference papers are concise and presented in person, while journal papers are comprehensive and communicated in writing.

05:06
📈 The Distinction and Impact of Publication Types

The video continues by discussing the impact of publishing in conferences versus journals. It explains that excellent conference papers may be invited for publication in journals, but they are still subject to the journal's review process. The video concludes by thanking viewers for watching and encouraging them to subscribe for more research-related content. It also reminds viewers to like and share the video before they leave.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Journal
A 'journal' is a scholarly publication that periodically publishes full-length research articles. It plays a central role in the academic community as a platform for disseminating in-depth and comprehensive research findings. In the video, journals are contrasted with conferences, highlighting that journal articles are more detailed and undergo a rigorous peer-review process, which can involve multiple iterations of revisions.
💡Conference
A 'conference' is an event where researchers gather to present their work and engage in discussions with peers. It is a platform for networking and collaboration, allowing researchers to receive immediate feedback on their work. The script mentions that conferences are beneficial for early-phase researchers and students, who can present their research in a summarized form and strengthen their professional network.
💡Peer-review
Peer-review is the process by which scholarly works are evaluated for their intellectual content by others in the same field prior to publication. It is a critical part of maintaining academic standards and integrity. The video explains that both conference papers and journal articles undergo peer-review, but the process for journals is more sophisticated and can involve multiple review iterations.
💡Research Publication
Research publication refers to the act of making research findings available to the public, typically through academic journals or conference proceedings. The video discusses the two main forms of research publication: conference papers and journal articles, each serving different purposes and audiences within the academic community.
💡Conference Proceedings
Conference proceedings are the published records of papers presented at a conference. They often contain summaries of research work and are an important part of the conference experience. The script explains that the collection of presented papers at a conference is known as the conference proceedings, which are published after the event.
💡Oral Presentation
An 'oral presentation' is a method of presenting research findings through spoken communication, often accompanied by visual aids such as slides. The video mentions that at conferences, researchers present their papers through oral presentations, which allows for direct interaction with the audience.
💡Poster Presentation
A 'poster presentation' is another way researchers can present their work at a conference. It involves displaying research findings on a large board or poster and discussing them with conference attendees. The script does not explicitly mention poster presentations, but it is a common method of presenting research at conferences, similar to oral presentations.
💡Academic CV
An 'academic CV' is a document that outlines an individual's academic and professional achievements, including publications, presentations, and other relevant experiences. The video notes that journal papers carry more weight in an academic CV compared to conference papers, indicating the perceived value of different types of scholarly contributions.
💡Open Access
Open access refers to the practice of providing unrestricted access via the Internet to peer-reviewed scholarly research. The video explains that while there is typically no registration fee for publishing in journals, authors may choose to pay an open access fee to make their articles freely accessible to all.
💡Research Collaboration
Research collaboration is the process of two or more researchers working together on a research project. The video emphasizes the importance of conferences in facilitating research collaborations by bringing researchers together and providing opportunities for networking and feedback.
💡Review Process
The 'review process' is a critical part of academic publishing where submitted papers are evaluated for quality, relevance, and originality. The video contrasts the review processes of conferences and journals, noting that the latter is more complex and can involve multiple rounds of review and revisions.
💡Research Feedback
Research feedback is the input and critique provided by peers or experts on a researcher's work. It is essential for improving the quality of research and is a significant benefit of attending conferences, as mentioned in the video. Feedback can help researchers refine their work before submitting it for publication.
Highlights

Introduction to the fundamental differences between journal and conference papers.

Conferences enable researchers to meet, seek feedback, strengthen networks and establish collaborations.

Advisable for early phase researchers and students to participate in conferences to present their research.

Conference papers are 4-5 page summaries of research work that get peer-reviewed.

Accepted conference papers are presented during the conference and published in the proceedings.

Journals publish full-length, comprehensive research articles periodically.

Journal articles undergo a more rigorous and sophisticated review process than conference papers.

Journal papers can go through multiple peer review iterations with major/minor revisions.

Accepted journal papers are published online within days or months of acceptance, without physical gatherings.

No registration fee for journal papers, but open access fee may apply.

Conference papers are concise summaries while journal papers are detailed and comprehensive.

Conference papers presented through oral/poster presentations, journal papers through written communication.

Conference papers summarize ongoing research, journal papers expected to be in-depth and comprehensive.

Optimal page length for conference papers is 4-5 pages, journal papers can be 8-10 pages or more.

Conference papers have medium complexity, journal papers expected to have the highest level of complexity.

Conference review process is short with one iteration, 1-3 month timeline. Journals have flexible 1-12 month timeline.

Conferences suitable for beginners and network expansion, journals for intermediate and trained researchers.

Conference papers have low to medium CV weightage, journal papers have higher weightage.

Authors must register for conferences if accepted, no registration for journals but open access fee may apply.

Excellent conference papers may receive invitations for journal publication, subject to further review.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

How to choose a right journal for publication? Criteria, tools and tips

The Dark Side of Science: Misconduct in Biomedical Research. Lecture by dr. Boris Barbour (PubPeer).

How to find latest Impact Factor of a journal? Best way to find out impact factor of an article?

Easy Way to Identify Journal Quartile (Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4) - PART ONE

Understanding the impact factor

Fast Publication Multidisciplinary 10 Scopus Index Journals - Open Access with no fees

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
ResearchPublicationConferenceJournalPeer ReviewAcademicNetworkingPresentationCollaborationResearch Methods